RESOLVED to: 1) Approve the Council’s participation as a Founding Member of the “Local Government Mutual”, which is a new company limited by guarantee, from which to develop an insurance Mutual; 2) Nominate the Deputy Leader to be appointed as a Founding Member committee member of the “Local Government Mutual” to oversee and make strategic decisions in respect of its initial phase of activity pending trading; 3) Delegate authority to the Deputy Chief Executive and Director of Finance to submit the Application for Membership of the “Local Government Mutual” as a Founding Member; 4) Authorise the Deputy Chief Executive and Director of Finance to share the Council’s relevant risk transfer and protection data with the LGA officers working on the project on a strictly confidential basis; and 5) Note that once the new Mutual is established, a report on options and recommendations for the Council to utilise the Mutual will be presented to Cabinet at the appropriate time.
Word for word from the decision Gedling published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gedling.gov.uk
The LGA has looked at various mutual structures. One model being reviewed is a ‘hybrid discretionary mutual’ whereby the mutual takes the first part of the risk up to a specified limit on a discretionary basis and above this limit it arranges insurance to the full limit of cover required. Members pay a ‘contribution’ into the mutual to benefit from the protection it provides. The contribution varies between members based on the risks they bring to the mutual.
2. How do mutuals work?
A mutual is owned by its members. Mutuals must act in the interests of their members and it is the membership which, through the elected board, exercises ultimate control of a mutual.
Research indicates that mutual membership could produce immediate and long term benefits including cost savings. Mutuals can balance risks retained within the mutual with an optimum use of the insurance market, and can attract beneficial tax treatments, such as Insurance Premium Tax savings on the contributions from members.
A mutual is created to provide cost effective risk transfer, not to generate profit. Any surplus of mutual trading funds belongs to the members of the mutual and surpluses may, in time, be returned to members. Members of the mutual can also benefit from better risk management driven by the transparency of available data and the mutual ethos to pool information to share best practice.
3. How secure is a mutual?
Mutuals operate successfully in many other sectors and in different countries. The LGA is exploring a mutual model which allows for attritional/expected losses to be met from mutual funds, with exceptionally large losses/accumulations of losses being met by insurers. This type of model is very secure.
The perceived risks of a mutual having to decline valid claims or make calls for additional contributions can be eliminated through the arrangement of excess of loss and aggregate insurance at the appropriate levels, so that the mutual’s board knows at the start of every financial year what its worst-case scenario is – and this worst-case scenario is already funded.
The board of the mutual will retain the services of suitably qualified and experienced professional managers to ensure efficient management of the mutual fund and the insurance protection programme. The long term strength of a Local Government mutual will, however, be determined by the pace of membership growth provided by authorities seeking better, more cost-effective protection and being willing to take control with other like-minded local authorities of their own risk transfer programmes.
4. Is there any possibility of the proposed mutual going the same way as MMI in the early 1990’s
MMI was established in 1903 by local authorities in the UK, and it served as the sector’s insurance supplier until the early 1990s. In 1991, having de-mutualised, the net assets of the Municipal Mutual Insurance Limited (MMI) and the Municipal General Insurance Limited (MGI) fell below the minimum solvency requirements calculated, and Managing Trustees concluded that the business should be sold.
A key factor affecting the company’s losses was a lack of reinsurance at a time of significant increase in the number and cost of local government liability insurance claims. This issue will be explicitly addressed in arrangements for the new mutual.
5. Are mutuals less expensive?
The LGA commissioned modelling work in partnership with a number of local authorities which has identified significant savings opportunities. No authority will be asked to commit to the Mutual without knowing the level of contribution it would be required to make. Authorities will, therefore, be able to make fully informed decisions on the financial advantages of mutual membership. In fact, the only way for local authorities to seek admission to the mutual will be as a consequence of a properly conducted business case that has been submitted for Executive decision by the council’s finance team.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Gedling Economic Growth FrameworkThat Cabinet: 1) Approved the (2026–2030). 2) Noted the findings within the appendices which have been considered as ...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.