What was decided
Cabinet will procure three refuse collection vehicles: one new vehicle and two new chassis with replacement bodies. [D] [2.1] The estimated total cost is £610,000. [2.1] [3.1] Report 2.1, 3.1
Procurement will follow the Council’s Contract Procedure Rules and all applicable public procurement requirements. [2.3] The TPPL framework is expected, subject to confirmation that it provides the most appropriate compliant route to market. [2.5] Report 2.3, 2.5
Tender submissions will be assessed on whole life cost, including purchase price, maintenance, reliability, useful life, warranty and residual value. [3.4] Affordability will be confirmed before contract award. [3.4] Report 3.4
Why
The current reliance on older vehicles raises the risk of breakdowns, higher maintenance costs, reduced operational resilience and service disruption. [1.5] [P6] Replacing the vehicles is required to maintain a safe, reliable and resilient waste collection service. [4.1] Report 1.5, P6, 4.1
The chosen combination combines the reliability, warranty protection and longer life of a new vehicle with the lower capital cost and shorter lead times of refurbished bodies. [P18] It balances reliability and whole life value against upfront cost. [P20] Report P18, P20
The estimated saving against buying three new vehicles is £140,000. [3.3] Report 3.3
What happens next
Develop the final specification to cover operational requirements, whole life cost, availability, maintenance support, safety features, environmental performance and compatibility with current depot and collection arrangements. [2.4] Report 2.4
Procure through the TPPL framework if it is confirmed as the most appropriate compliant route. [2.3] [2.5] Manage lead time, availability and price risks through early procurement, a clear specification, whole life cost evaluation and contractual controls. [P36] Report 2.3, 2.5, P36
Assess tender submissions on whole life cost and confirm affordability before contract award. [3.4] Manage refurbishment risks through detailed refurbishment specifications, full inspection, replacement of key components, testing, certification, clear warranty arrangements and interim fleet planning. [P19] Report 3.4, P19
The money
- £610,000 Estimated total cost and capital expenditure for the preferred purchase Report 2.1, 3.1
- £250,000 Estimated cost of one new vehicle Report 2.1
- £360,000 Estimated cost of two new chassis with refurbished bodies Report 2.1
- £140,000 Estimated saving against purchasing three new vehicles Report 3.3
Options considered
- Chosen: One new vehicle and two new chassis with refurbished bodies. The combination balances reliability and whole life value with lower upfront cost and shorter delivery times. Report 2.1, P18, P20
- Rejected: Do nothing. It avoids immediate capital expenditure but increases breakdown, health and safety, maintenance, hire and service disruption risks. It only defers the eventual replacement cost. Report P16
- Rejected: Three used refuse vehicles. Uncertainty over availability, condition, remaining life, maintenance costs and reliability creates greater breakdown and downtime risk. It is better suited to interim use than long term fleet replacement. Report P22
Implications
- Financial: The preferred option has estimated capital expenditure of £610,000. Sufficient budget provision has been identified and approved. Report 2.1, 3.1, 3.2
- Financial: The refurbished body element gives an upfront saving but carries greater financial risk from maintenance, split warranties, lower residual values and potentially earlier replacement. Report 3.4
- Legal: Procurement must follow the Council’s Contract Procedure Rules and all applicable public procurement requirements. The project is recorded as involving no processing of personal data, special category data or criminal offence data. Report 2.3, P37
- Risk: Failure to replace vehicles risks missed collections, service disruption and reputational damage. Older vehicles can also create higher maintenance costs and greater reliance on short term hire. Report P36
- Risk: Lead times, market availability and tender prices may affect delivery dates and affordability. Report P36
- Other: The specification must fit collection routes, carry the required loads, protect crew safety and meet depot requirements. Report P36
- Climate: The final specification will include environmental performance. Report 2.4
- Equalities: The equality impact assessment records no potential adverse impact or discrimination against people with protected characteristics. The Chief Officer confirms that due regard has been given to equality impacts. Report P38, P39, P40, P41
Who and where
- Residents receiving scheduled household waste collections Report 1.1
- The Council’s waste collection crews Report 1.1
- The Council’s refuse collection fleet Report 1.1, 1.6
- Residents relying on separate food, residual and recycling collections Report 1.2
Timeline
- 2026-11-02: Cabinet decided to procure the three refuse collection vehicles
- around 12 to 18 months: Expected lead time for the new vehicle Report 2.2
- around 10 to 12 months: Expected lead time for the two chassis with refurbished bodies Report 2.2
- 10 years: Scheduled replacement age under the fleet replacement plan Report 1.6
- 3 to 9 years: Current age range of vehicles in the fleet Report 1.7
Plain English for the jargon
- TPPL framework: The procurement framework expected to provide a compliant route to market, subject to confirmation. [2.5]
- Whole life cost: The combined assessment of purchase price, maintenance, reliability, useful life, warranty and residual value. [3.4]
- Refurbished body: A replacement refuse collection body fitted to a new chassis. [2.7] [P18]
- Simpler Recycling: Government policy linked to separate food, residual and recycling collection vehicles and service rescheduling. [1.2]
- Contract Procedure Rules: The Council’s rules that the procurement must follow. [2.3]
- DPIA: A data protection impact assessment for major projects involving personal data or significant process changes. [P37]