RESOLVED to approve application 17/T/00045 subject to the conditions and reasons as detailed in the report, the following updated condition 4 and two additional informatives : 4. Replanting must be in accordance with the approved Tree Planting Plan submitted by ACD Arboriculture dated May 2017 (ref. PR118897-02). Replanting must take place no later than the first February following the felling of the tree. The LPA must be informed once the replacement tree is planted. Additional Informatives : 2. The replacement Walnut Tree will be afforded protection with the making of a new Tree Preservation Order. 3. Failure to replant following the felling of the Silver Birch will result in the issuing of a Tree Replacement Notice and subsequent enforcement action.
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
The application has been referred to the planning committee because more than 20 letters of objection have been received contrary to the officer recommendation.
Site description.
The application site, 15 Abbotswood, is located within the Abbotswood Conservation Area. The Silver Birch tree proposed to be felled is afforded protection by Tree Preservation Order No. 11 of 2013.
Proposal.
T2 Silver Birch - fell.
Relevant planning history. Reference: Description: Decision Appeal: Summary: 17/N/00047 Non material Amendment re Pending N/A 14/P/02282-Window on upper rear ground floor to be double panel width similar to one on ground floor. 3 bays on lower ground floor to be full width bi- fold door as opposed to french doors with side panel windows.
17/T/00045 T2 Silver Birch - fell. Pending N/A
17/P/00354 New entrance gates and piers. Approve N/A 30/03/2017
15/P/00909 Proposed rear and side extension Withdrawn N/A 15/09/2015
14/P/02282 Proposed three storey rear extension Refuse ALLC and two storey side extension. 05/03/2015 09/09/20 15 14/P/00099 Proposed three storey rear extension Refuse N/A (amended by plans received 14/03/2014 05/03/2014).
13/T/00179 Western red cedar (T1) - fell. Common Decision To N/A silver birch (T2) - fell. Intervene 09/09/2013
Consultations.
Arboricultural Officer:
Third party comments:
Twenty nine representations have been made to the Council objecting to the proposal to fell the Silver Birch. Two representations were by the same individual but referred to different concerns.
The majority of the concerns can be categorised as below:
remedy the damage and retain tree impact of the development on the tree due to limited tree protection and not adhering to the tree protection condition for the re-development of the site as per and the ACD Arboricultural Report dated 15th May 2015 protect the tree during the continued development work and allow it to grow and prosper simply object to a mature TPO’d tree being removed within a Conservation Area convenient for the builders to lose the tree drainage issues due to clay soil
These issues are addressed in the Planning Consideration below.
Planning policies.
The following policies are relevant to the determination of this application.
Guildford Borough Local Plan 2003 (as saved by CLG Direction 24 September 2007): G1(12) Safeguarding and Enhancement of the land NE5 Dev. Affecting Trees, Hedges & Woodlands
Planning considerations.
The main planning considerations for this case is the impact of the proposed felling of the tree and the amenity value the tree currently provides.
The Silver Birch tree is a mature specimen approximately 12 metres in height. The tree is situated to the left hand side of the property 15 Abbotswood which is currently undergoing extensive re-development. Although the tree was graded as a C1 (following the guidelines within the British Standard 5837:2012 Tree in Relation to Design, demolition and construction) in the arboricultural report prepared by ACD Environmental dated 15th May 2016, the tree was proposed to be retained during the re-development of the site. A C1 categorisation refers to a tree of low quality that is unremarkable for the species and of little merit. In general terms, the best quality trees are those belonging to the higher BS categories (A and B) which are considered as potential constraints on any development proposal, whereas those belonging to Category C would not normally be retained where they would impose a significant constraint on site development.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.