RESOLVED to defer application 19/P/01003 to the next meeting of the Planning Committee scheduled on 19 August 2020. RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Jan Harwood X 2 Liz Hogger X 3 David Bilbe X 4 Colin Cross X 5 Angela Gunning X 6 Jon Askew X 7 Chris Blow X 8 Caroline Reeves X 9 Christopher Barrass X 10 Susan Parker X 11 Marsha Moseley X 12 Paul Spooner X 13 Maddy Redpath X 14 Fiona White X 15 Ruth Brothwell X TOTALS 10 1 4
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
This application is the subject of a non determination appeal.
Had the Council retained the right to determine this application, the recommendation would have been to approve subject to the terms and conditions and the completion of a s106 Agreement as set out in this report.
The 13 week deadline expired on 5.12.19. The Council has been in discussions with the applicant resulting in the amendments to the original scheme. The intention was to take the application to 22 April 2020 planning committee. Unfortunately due to COVID 19 the planning committee was cancelled. Moving forward with virtual planning committees the Council resolved not to consider major applications which generate public speaking for the first two virtual meetings. In light of this the applicant chose to make an appeal against non determination. The appeal against non determination was formally submitted on 15 June 2020. The appeal is awaiting a start date.
The applicant has recently submitted an identical application (also on this planning committee's agenda) which they hope will be considered favourably by the Council. Should the duplicate application be approved the applicant has advised that they will withdraw the current appeal.
Reason for referral
This application has been referred to the Planning Committee because more than 20 letters of objection have been received, contrary to the Officer's recommendation.
This application qualifies for public speaking.
Key information
The application is for outline permission for 29 residential dwellings including means of access, layout and scale (appearance and landscaping to be reserved):
The 29 units would comprise 15 houses and 14 flats. Proposed housing mix: 6 x 1 bed 8 x 2-bed 10 x 3 bed 5 x 4 bed
Proposed affordable mix: Proposed SHMA 1 bed 6 50% 40% 2 bed 4 34% 30% 3 bed 2 16% 25% 4 + bed 0 0% 5%
Proposed market mix: Proposed SHMA 1 bed 0 0% 10% 2 bed 4 24% 30% 3 bed 8 47% 40% 4 + bed 5 29% 20%
40% affordable housing would be provided.
A total of 50 Parking spaces would be provided.
A two storey building height is proposed.
Access is via the natural termination point within Heath Drive.
Matters reserved are appearance and landscaping.
Summary of considerations and constraints
The site is located within 400m - 5km of the TBHSPA.
A TPO protects all trees on site following substantial felling in 1997.
The area is identified as open space having visual amenity value only due to the private landownership of the site.
The proposal gives an opportunity to provide publicly accessible open space increasing the open space value of the site. This in addition to the biodiversity enhancements through planting, management and removal of non-native species and windfall additional market and affordable housing out weighs the identified harm of building upon part of the woodland.
Were the Council in a position to determine the application the recommendation would have been to approve subject to conditions and a s106 agreement to secure:
Education provision: A financial contribution is sought for the following contributions: Early Years Contribution: £19,518 Primary Contribution: £95,135 Secondary Contribution: £103,839 Overall Contribution: £218,492.
Affordable Housing: 40% based on a 70:30 split Accessible and adaptable homes 10% to be accessible and adaptable and 5% to be wheelchair user dwellings.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.