AI summaryGuildford Borough Council has amended its Constitution to formally recognise a Leader of the Opposition and to set a mechanism for tied opposition groups, with special responsibility allowances, speaking rights and committee nominations to be shared between joint leaders.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedFormal recognition of Leader of the Opposition and tie-break mechanism
MoneyNo direct financial implicationsSpecial Responsibility Allowance only shared at Waverley (WBC)
What happens nextConstitution to be updatedNecessary changes to be made to the Council's Constitution
Who it affectsOpposition political groups and committee rolesNomination of O&S Chair and JSSC appointment
What was decided
The Constitution will define the Leader of the Opposition as the leader of the largest political group that is not part of the Administration. Report P3
If two or more opposition groups are of equal size, their leaders will be jointly recognised, sharing any special responsibility allowance, speaking rights and committee nominations unless they agree otherwise. Report P4
Why
The existing Constitution mentions a Principal Opposition Group but does not define it, leaving no agreed mechanism for dealing with a tie in opposition group sizes. Report 6.3
The Joint Constitutions Review Group wanted clarity and transparency in recognising the official Leader of the Opposition, especially in cases of political parity. Report 6.5
What happens next
If approved, the necessary changes will be made to the Council's Constitution, with 13 months left for the Councils in their current form before Local Government Reorganisation. Report 4.1, P19, 8.1
Options considered
Chosen: Recognise all tied group leaders as Opposition Leaders, sharing SRA, O&S Chair nomination and JSSC appointment (option b). JCRG considered it fair and it provides constitutional certainty while allowing flexibility Report P3, P4, 6.5
Rejected: Appoint no Leader of the Opposition in the event of a tie (option a). Would leave no mechanism for nominating the O&S Chair or appointing to the JSSC
Rejected: Opposition groups agree among themselves who leads (option c). An informal agreement may not suffice and a formal mechanism is needed in the Constitution
Rejected: Rotate opposition leadership between groups (option d). Impracticable given only 13 months remain for the Councils in their current form Report P19
Implications
Legal: Under section 9P of the Local Government Act 2000 every local authority must keep its written Constitution up to date, though this does not require a Leader of the Opposition mechanism. Report P36
Equalities: The Public Sector Equality Duty has been considered and no equality and diversity implications arise directly from the report. Report P42
Financial: There are no direct financial implications arising from this report. Report P34
Climate: No climate change or sustainability implications arise from this report. Report P44
Risk: Without a tie-break mechanism, fluctuating group sizes could force a Council decision each time a tie arises. Report 10.1
Who and where
Non-administration political groups on the Council Report P3, P4
The Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, subject to opposition members exceeding 10% of overall membership Report P13, P17, P18
Members appointed to the Joint Senior Staff Committee (JSSC) Report P14
The future West Surrey Council (under Local Government Reorganisation) Report 8.1
Timeline
23 February 2026: Joint Constitutions Review Group considered the four tie-break options.
23 March 2026: Joint Standards Committee agreed the proposals should be recommended to Council. Report 6.6
7 April 2026: Full Council considered the constitutional amendment.
Plain English for the jargon
SRA: Special Responsibility Allowance paid to councillors with specific duties.
O&S Committee: Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
JSSC: Joint Senior Staff Committee.
JCRG: Joint Constitutions Review Group.
LGR: Local Government Reorganisation.
WBC: Waverley Borough Council, the only council that shares an SRA in this way.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemCO122
Resolved
That the Constitution be amended to provide as follows: (a) That the Leader of the Opposition shall be the Leader of the largest political group which is not part of the Administration. (b) That, in the event that two or more political groups are of equal size and jointly constitute the largest non-Administration grouping, the Leaders of those groups shall be jointly recognised as Leaders of the Opposition, with any Special Responsibility Allowance, speaking rights and committee nominations shared between them, unless otherwise agreed between those group Leaders. Reason: To ensure that, in the event of a ‘tie’ in the numbers on the largest opposition groups on the Council, an agreed mechanism exists for dealing with this.
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
1.1This report recommends that Council formally recognises in the Constitution a Leader of the Opposition, and makes arrangements for how to deal with the question of two or more opposition groups having equality of membership.
Recommendations
2.1That Full Council resolves to amend the Constitution to provide that:
2.1.1 The Leader of the Opposition shall be the Leader of the largest political group which is not part of the Administration.
2.1.2 In the event that two or more political groups are of equal size and jointly constitute the largest non-Administration grouping, the Leaders of those groups shall be jointly recognised as Leaders of the Opposition, with any Special Responsibility Allowance, speaking rights and committee nominations shared between them, unless otherwise agreed between those group Leaders.
3. Reason(s) for recommendation:
3.1To ensure that, in the event of a ‘tie’ in the numbers on the largest opposition groups on the Council, that an agreed mechanism exists for dealing with this.
4. Next steps
4.1If approved by Council, the necessary changes will be made to the Council’s Constitution.
5. Exemption from publication
5.1No part of this report is exempt from publication. Leader of the Opposition Group
6. Background 6.1 Guildford’s Constitution refers to the Principal Opposition Group but does not define it.
6.2There are a number of actions that flow from being Leader of the Opposition:
(a) Principal opposition group allowed to nominate the Chair of the O&S Committee for election at the Annual Meeting1 (which carries an SRA).
(b) a seat on the Joint Senior Staff Committee (JSSC).
(c) speaking next on the budget after it has been formally proposed and seconded at the Budget Council Meeting (no longer relevant in view of LGR).
6.3It is considered prudent to have a set of rules around what would happen in the event of an equality of numbers in opposition groups. 6.4 The Joint Constitutions Review Group (JCRG) on 23 February 2026 considered the following options in the event of an equality of numbers: (a) No Leader of the Opposition is appointed in the event of an equality of numbers. This avoids disputes and having to pick the Leader of the Opposition but leaves the Council without a mechanism for nomination of the O&S Chair and appointment of the Leader of the Principal Opposition Group to the JSSC as required by its current terms of reference. (b) Recognise all tied group leaders as Opposition Leaders. This is fair but means that the Council will have to consider how to deal with the sharing of an SRA (WBC only), nomination of O&S Chair and appointment to the JSSC unless a mechanism is set out. (c) The opposition groups to agree themselves who will be the Leader of the Opposition. This would need a mechanism
1 Subject to the total number of Opposition members on the Council exceeding 10% of the overall
membership Leader of the Opposition Group
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Overview and Scrutiny Annual Report(1) To approve the attached at Appendix 1 to the report submitted to the Council. (2) To not amend the current O&S wo...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.