AI summaryGuildford Executive adopted a hurdle rate framework for affordable housing schemes, setting benchmark returns of 3.88% IRR for rented and 4.88% for shared ownership, to be used as indicative guidance rather than fixed rules.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefusedHurdle rate framework approved as indicative guidance for assessing financial viability of new affordable housing schemes
MoneynullNo additional expenditure committed; consultancy costs met from existing budgets
What happens nextFramework applied to new schemesAll new affordable housing development schemes delivered by the Council will use the hurdle rates
Who it affectsAffordable housing schemesAll new Council-delivered affordable housing development schemes in Guildford borough
What was decided
The Executive adopted the proposed hurdle rate framework for affordable housing development schemes across the Borough as an indicative guide to support the assessment of financial viability. Report P3
The hurdle rates are 40 year payback period, 3.88% target IRR for rented and 4.88% for shared ownership, and 98% and 95% gross cost to value respectively. Report P33, P34, P35
The framework will be reviewed and updated periodically to ensure it remains flexible and responsive to changing circumstances. Report P41
Why
The framework will promote transparency and comparability in early-stage appraisals, helping to identify schemes that are broadly financially viable. Report 3.1
By adopting the framework as a guide rather than an absolute, the Council retains the ability to approve schemes that do not meet the benchmark where this can be justified, ensuring best value and social, economic and environmental considerations continue to inform decisions. Report 3.2
The framework will support greater consistency in assessments, helping officers and Members to compare schemes on a like-for-like basis and identify potential financial risks at an early stage. Report P62
What happens next
The proposed hurdle rate framework will be applied to all new affordable housing development schemes delivered by the Council. Report 4.1
The rates will be reviewed and updated periodically to ensure they remain flexible and responsive to changing circumstances. Report P41
Each development will be subject to an Internal Carbon Price calculation to identify potential financial benefits for choosing sustainable options. Report P81, P82
The money
3.88% Target Internal Rate of Return for rented schemes Report P34
4.88% Target Internal Rate of Return for shared ownership schemes Report P34
40 years Target payback year Report P33
98.00% Target gross cost to value for rented schemes Report P35
95.00% Target gross cost to value for shared ownership schemes Report P35
Options considered
Rejected: Option 1: Continue without formal hurdle rate framework, relying on scheme-by-scheme appraisals. May result in less consistency across schemes, making it harder to demonstrate financial discipline and potentially reducing transparency. Report P54, P55
Rejected: Option 2: Adopt hurdle rates as fixed absolute thresholds. Could be overly rigid and potentially exclude schemes that deliver substantial wider benefits, discouraging investment in measures that support long-term sustainability. Report P55
Chosen: Option 3 (Recommended): Adopt hurdle rates as indicative guidance with scope to approve exceptions. Balances the need for financial discipline with strategic flexibility by allowing consideration of wider social, environmental and economic factors. Report P55
Implications
Financial: The framework does not commit the Council to any additional expenditure, borrowing or investment. It provides an indicative guide for early-stage assessment of financial viability. Report P59
Risk: If hurdle rates are set too high and applied rigidly, they may fail to reflect changing market conditions, funding availability or policy priorities. Report P41
Risk: Higher-cost, low-carbon or longer-term sustainability measures may appear uneconomic under hurdle rates, potentially discouraging investment in climate-friendly solutions. Report P41
Legal: The Council must continue to discharge duties in relation to best value, which requires securing value for money while recognising that best value does not equate to maximising financial return alone. Report P69
Who and where
Housing delivery and finance teams who will apply the framework when developing new housing schemes Report P48
Council decision-makers who will use hurdle rates to assess scheme viability
West Surrey Council as successor authority on vesting day 1 April 2027
Timeline
Over ten years: Council has been working to provide additional affordable homes through direct development, acquisition and buybacks Report P18
2025: Council commissioned work to review existing assumptions and develop hurdle rates Report P29
2026: V4 Services developed the Hurdle Rate Framework following review of HRA running costs
10 March 2026: Surrey (Structural Changes) Order 2026 came into effect
1 April 2027: Vesting Day for transfer of functions to West Surrey Council
Plain English for the jargon
Hurdle rate: Minimum rate of return that an investor may expect to see against specified appraisal outputs before deciding to proceed with a project or investment
IRR (Internal Rate of Return): Discount rate that balances the initial investment against the income and costs generated by a project throughout its life
NPV (Net Present Value): Metric used to assess the value of an investment by calculating the difference between present value of future cash inflows and outflows, discounted back to today
Payback period: The length of time it takes for a project to recover its initial investment from its net cash inflows
HRA (Housing Revenue Account): Ring-fenced account used by local authorities to manage housing stock and related expenditure
Vesting Day: 1 April 2027, when Guildford Borough Council's functions transfer to West Surrey Council
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemEX60
Resolved
To adopt the proposed hurdle rate framework for affordable housing development schemes across the Borough as an indicative guide to support the assessment of financial viability. Reason(s): 1. The introduction of the proposed hurdle rate framework for assessing the financial viability of housing development schemes will promote transparency and comparability in early-stage appraisals, helping to identify schemes that are broadly financially viable. 2. By adopting the framework as a guide, rather than an absolute, the Council will retain the ability to approve schemes that do not meet the benchmark where this can be justified, ensuring that best value, and social, economic and environmental considerations continue to inform decisions. Other options considered and rejected by the Executive: OPTION 1: The Council could decide not to progress with adopting the hurdle rate framework proposed, and instead, continue to rely on scheme-by-scheme appraisals and affordability metrics without a formal benchmark return. This approach offers maximum flexibility, allowing each scheme to be assessed on its own merits and enabling full consideration of social, environmental and housing delivery objectives. However, it may result in less consistency across schemes, making it harder to demonstrate financial discipline and potentially reducing transparency. Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None.
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
1.1This report outlines the work undertaken by Officers, and supported by external consultants, to develop a hurdle rate framework to support the initial assessment of the financial viability of new housing development schemes. It recommends that the Executive approves the adoption of the proposed framework for all new affordable schemes being considered by the Council, applying it as guidance rather than an absolute requirement.
Recommendations
2.1That the Executive resolves to:
2.1.1 Adopt the proposed hurdle rate framework for affordable housing development schemes across the Borough as an indicative guide to support the assessment of financial viability .
3 Reason(s) for recommendation:
3.1The introduction of the proposed hurdle rate framework for assessing the financial viability of housing development schemes will promote transparency and comparability in early- stage appraisals, helping to identify schemes that are broadly financially viable.
3.2By adopting the framework as a guide, rather than an absolute, the Council will retain the ability to approve schemes that do not meet the benchmark where this can be justified, ensuring that best value, and social, economic and environmental considerations continue to inform decisions.
2 GBC New Build Housing Development – Hurdle Rates
4 Next steps
4.1Should the Executive approve the recommendations in this report, the proposed hurdle rate framework will be applied to all new affordable housing development schemes delivered by the Council.
5 Exemption from publication
5.1This report is not exempt from publication.
6 Background and Proposal
6.1For over ten years, the Council has been working to provide additional affordable homes for residents through an active programme of direct development, acquisition of section 106 properties and buybacks.
6.2This work has been funded via a variety of sources including use of Housing Revenue Account (HRA) reserves, capital receipts generated from the sale of HRA properties under the Right to Buy scheme, external grant funding and borrowing.
6.3In developing the Business Case for each project, Officers use viability appraisals to assess whether the affordable housing development can be delivered in a financially sustainable way.
6.4Viability appraisals bring together key assumptions on development costs, rental and (if applicable) sales income, grant funding, borrowing, and long-term management costs to test the overall financial performance of a scheme, producing a range of outputs which help decision-makers understand whether a scheme is ‘viable’.
6.5Key measures of viability for Council-led affordable housing projects include:
Internal Rate of Return (IRR) – discount rate that balances the initial investment against the income and costs generated by a project throughout its life.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.