Resolved
That approval be given to the adoption of the Revised House Extensions in South Tottenham Supplementary Planning Document (SPD), in place of the original House Extensions in South Tottenham SPD, adopted in October 2010. Alternative options considered The recommended proposals are considered to meet the balance of residents and stakeholder’s concerns over extensions in South Tottenham; of both those that want greater freedom to build larger extensions with fewer restrictions on their use and appearance and those that want stronger restrictions on extensions and fewer extensions built. There are a number of ways in which the Council could have granted greater freedom. It could, for instance, have considered permitting larger extensions, whether single storey or on two or more floors; however, this would have caused significant loss of amenity, particularly daylight, sunlight and privacy to neighbours and have lead to further loss of back garden space, which provides amenity, recreation space, food growing space and wildlife habitats. If the Council had chosen not to insist on greater attention to detail of extensions, evidence from those built so far demonstrates that extensions would be built, which in many cases would not match the original house, increasing the loss of architectural unity and consistency of appearance of streets. This would lead to diminished property values and lack of acceptance of extensions from other residents living in the neighbourhood. It is worth nothing that the guidance reiterates that ‘potential applicants can always discuss particularly peculiar circumstances that lead them to consider extra large extensions acceptable in a pre-application enquiry’. If instead the Council had sought to restrict extensions, there would not be a solution to the problem of overcrowding of large families within the capabilities of home owners to resolve the issue and the clear demand would not be met. This would continue social and health problems associated with overcrowding, further pressure for one off planning applications for extensions of all sorts, including rear extensions and the previously popular ‘grossly over scale dormers’, in all likelihood greater construction of extensions without or in contravention of planning permission and causing greater workload on the Council’s planning officers. Alternatively the Council could have elected to not revise the SPD at all. This would have maintained existing restrictions on ‘Type 3’ extensions only being built in pairs, which many residents wanting to build such extensions are finding difficult to follow, the Council’s planning officers are finding it difficult to enforce and considered not to make significant difference to the impact on appearance and neighbour’s amenity compared ... view the full minutes text for item 509.