RESOLVED i) That the Committee agree to transfer the management of listed equities excluding emerging markets to the London CIV noting that ultimate management will remain with Legal and General; ii) That the Committee delegate authority to the Chief Operating Officer or in their absence the Head of Finance – Treasury and Pensions to execute any documents required to complete the transfer of assets to the London CIV.
Word for word from the decision Haringey published for this meeting.Source: www.minutes.haringey.gov.uk
(a) Agree to transfer the management of listed equities excluding emerging markets to the London CIV noting that ultimate management will remain with Legal & General, and
(b) Delegate authority to the Chief Operating Officer (CFO) or in their absence the Head of Finance – Treasury & Pensions authority to execute any documents required to complete the transfer of assets to the London CIV.
4. Other options considered
Page 1 of 6 4.1 The paper considers the two options of investing through the London CIV or maintaining the current direct relationship with Legal & General.
5. Background information
5.1The Committee has supported the establishment of the London CIV through a contribution of £75,000 towards its establishment costs and at the September 2015 meeting agreed to contribute share capital as required to a maximum value of £150,000.
5.2The CIV has now received regulatory approval from the FCA to act as a collective manager. It has reached fee agreements with four fund managers - Legal & General, BlackRock, Allianz (active equity) and Baillie Gifford (DGF). It is now asking boroughs to indicate their willingness to transfer assets to the CIV.
5.3Of these four managers, only one is relevant to Haringey, L&G, and only in respect of equities. However, that does represent over 60% of the fund, circa £600 million. Initially the Index Linked Gilts (ILG) gilts will remain directly invested with L&G, who have confirmed that the current 3 bps fees will remain.
5.4In considering whether to switch assets to the CIV, the Committee should consider:
The financial implications, balancing ongoing fees and one of initial costs. The impact on the quality of the fund management and the anticipated returns. The ability to have a dialogue with the fund manager and influence its behaviour e.g. voting and corporate engagement. Whether investing through the CIV will add to or reduce future investment options. Meeting the expectation of government.
Each of these issues is considered below.
Financial implications
5.5The fee and cost schedules prepared by the CIV and verified with L&G indicate an initial annual net benefit of £15,000 from using the CIV based on its assumed starting asset base. The savings largely arise from enhanced tax recoveries within the CIV structure. The CIV fees will also fall as its asset base grows. There will be a one off cost linked to the transfer of assets and that is estimated as £360,000 to £400,000. The transition costs are substantial and will take many years to recoup from annual fee savings.
Page 2 of 6 5.6 An alternative to improve the financial outcome will be to retain Emerging Market equities in the current direct ownership structure and only move developed market equities to the CIV. This will lead to annual fee savings of £113,000 and reduce one off transition costs to £26,000, a clear financial benefit, which justifies utilizing the CIV.
Changes in anticipated returns and the quality of investment management
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.