It was resolved that the sampling would consist of complaints received between 30 April 2017 and 30 September 2018: · which had resulted in dissatisfaction from the subject member or the complainant. · all complaints handled solely by the monitoring officer without any view from the independent person. · a cluster of complaints which relate either to an individual or an individual parish council. · all complaints which have been made against members of the cabinet or those acting in support to the cabinet. · All complaints that have been rejected as out of the scope of the complaints procedure · A random sample of the categories of complaints listed in paragraph 6 of the report. The officers were asked to effect a randomised sample using a random number table. It was noted that this would mean that Standards Panel convened to sample complaints would be an all day meeting. The panel requested that in future a breakdown of the complaints by category be provided in order to aid with the choosing of the sample complaints. It was noted that this selection may result in a number of complaints and that a pragmatic approach will be taken to possibly reduce the numbers by two thirds for example. This will be a matter for the panel undertaking the sampling.
Word for word from the decision Herefordshire published for this meeting.Source: councillors.herefordshire.gov.uk
Meeting: Standards Panel Meeting date: 16 October 2018 Title of report: How to undertake an annual sample review of decisions made by the monitoring officer under the code of conduct complaint process
Report by: Monitoring officer
Classification Open
Key Decision This is not an executive decision.
Wards Affected All Wards Purpose and summary To agree a process for the annual sampling of code of conduct complaints by the Standards Panel.
Recommendation THAT
a process by which the annual sampling of code of conduct complaints be undertaken is agreed
Alternative Options 1. Not to agree a process by which to sample code of conduct complaints. This is not recommended as under the Herefordshire Council Constitution, one of the panel’s functions is to undertake an annual sample review and there needs to be an agreed methodology for doing so.
Key Considerations 2. As part of the amendments to the constitution agreed at Council on 25 May 2018, an annual sampling of code of conduct complaints was approved.
3. At the audit and governance committee meeting on 30 July 2018, it was requested that the sampling takes place prior to its meeting in November 2018 so that the views of the panel could be taken into account as part of the annual report on the code of conduct. Further information on the subject of this report is available from Caroline Marshall, democratic services officer, Tel no. 01432 260249 4. As this is the first time that sampling of the complaints will take place, it is for the panel to decide how this is undertaken.
5. For the period 30 April 2017 to 30 September 2018, there were 64 complaints received by the monitoring officer.
6. The decisions made under the code of conduct complaints process fall broadly into the following categories affecting parish and ward councillors:
Rejected under the initial assessment process – with the views of the independent person sought Rejected under the initial assessment process – without the views of the independent person sought Monitoring officer resolution with a breach of the code of conduct Monitoring officer resolution without a breach of the conduct Discontinued with no finding as the subject member has resigned and it is not in the public interest to continue with the complaint.
7. Possible options are:
that a maximum number of complaints are sampled representing an agreed percentage. The sampling could be randomised, with the panel selecting from a list of reference numbers, or partially randomised by providing the panel with lists of reference numbers to select from different categories such as Herefordshire Councillors; parish councillors; complaints upheld; complaints dismissed as categorised above. A decision or a number of decisions from each of the categories above are sampled.
8. As part of the annual governance statement report to the audit and governance committee on 30 July 2018, the independent person expressed concern that two complaints against Herefordshire councillors had been rejected without his views being taken into account. The independent person has suggested that these two complaints are reviewed by the standards panel.
9. A member of the audit and governance committee who is not part of this standards panel has also made suggestions as to how the sampling should proceed which is attached at appendix 1
Community Impact 10. Having an effective process for dealing with code of conduct complaints upholds principle A and G of the code of corporate governance by ensuring that councillors behave with integrity and that councillors are accountable for their actions. This should provide reassurance to the community that councillors are behaving in the best interests of their communities and that appropriate action is being taken to ensure that the code is being upheld.
Equality duty 11. Under section 149 of the Equality Act 2010, the ‘general duty’ on public authorities is set out as follows:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.