CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
London Borough of Hillingdon
CABINET, Thursday 26 May 2011 at 7.00pm

Review of Support for Music Tuition in Hillingdon: Interim Report of the Working Group

Approved Executive 5 papers

CABINET approved this item on Thursday 26 May 2011. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item322

Resolved

That Cabinet: Thanks all those involved in the review for their efforts; Endorses and approves all 12 recommendations in the Interim Report from the Working Group; Gives all necessary authority to implement the Working Group’s recommendations to the Deputy Chief Executive and Director of Planning, Environment, Education and Community Services, in consultation with the Leader of the Council and; Notes that the Working Group will undertake a further review with additional proposals for music tuition and report back to Cabinet in due course. Reasons for decision Cabinet received the Interim report of Working Group, led by Councillor Judy Kelly, which had reviewed support for music tuition in Hillingdon. Cabinet noted the conclusions of the review: That the Hillingdon Music Service was of a high quality and well regarded by everyone. The level of commitment by the ‘Friends’ in supporting the Service was greatly valued. There was a substantial need for improvements to the way Hillingdon Music Service operated and provided value for money, and this was clearly evidenced by the Working Group and leading people involved in the Hillingdon Music Service. A longer-term, more sustainable vision for music tuition in Hillingdon was an essential next step that was shared by both the Council and those involved in the Hillingdon Music Service. Cabinet heard that the Leader of the Council and Cabinet Member for Education and Children’s Services had held a meeting earlier in the week to present and discuss the review with those involved in the Music Service, of which the findings and recommendations to Cabinet were: Operation 1. The Working Group endorses the decision made to move the Music Service to Adult and Community Learning, within Education Services, and the synergies that can be made therein; 2. The Working Group endorses actions to implement a more flexible service structure and staff contracts for the benefit of service users, in particular a high rate of pay for advanced practitioners; 3. Whilst the Working Group endorses bringing the Hillingdon Music Service properly back into the council structure making it more accountable and corporate, it recommends that the service maintains its unique identity, in particular through any marketing and promotional activities; Value for Money 4. The Working Group endorses an increase in music tuition fees by 20% from September 2011 and recommends that both this, and the clarity of the fee structure, be reviewed as part of Phase 2 of the Working Group’s activity; 5. The Working Group recommends that Cabinet consider a higher rate of fees for non-residents in line with the Council’s ‘Hillingdon First’ Policy and recommends that reduced fees for disadvantaged pupils remain unchanged; 6. The Working Group recommends that an interim financial model is implemented consisting of the new Music Grant, with all other activities not funded from this grant being provided on a self-funding basis. Furthermore, that the Working Group is consulted on the priorities and balance of music tuition / services making use of the external grant; 7. Linked to recommendation 6, the Working Group recommends that the Management Committee be consulted on what enrichment activities should be prioritised; 8. The Working Group recognises the importance of continuity of provision for those pupils currently undertaking examinations; 9. The Working Group recommends that Cabinet modernise the payment and income collection processes, making it easier for parents to pay, specifically by introducing a 24/7 self service facility; 10. The Working Group recommends that Officers review the way in which user feedback is sought to improve the quality of provision; Marketing 11. T he Working Group recommends that in conjunction with Corporate Communications, officers be asked to undertake intensive marketing activities immediately to maintain and increase interest in music tuition following the recent uncertainty about the future of the Service; Governance 12. The Working Group recommends that officers review the Terms of Reference of the Management Committee to ensure its powers and responsibilities are consistent with the Council’s Constitution, consulting the Working Group and Management Committee and that delegated approval be given to the Deputy Chief Executive and Director of Planning, Environment, Education and Community Service in consultation with the Leader of the Council, to approve any changes. In agreeing the Working Group’s recommendations, Cabinet appreciated the need for continuity and certainty for pupils and their families in relation to music courses and tuition fees from September 2011. In addition, Cabinet welcomed that the recommendations would place the Hillingdon Music Service on a much firmer financial footing for the future. Cabinet noted that the Working Group was tasked to develop longer-term proposals, which would be undertaken in earnest over the next few months working closely with the Hillingdon Music Service Management Committee and ‘Friends’ Group. Cabinet thanked Members of the Working Group and the cross-Council team of officers for their efforts to-date in carrying out the first phase of this comprehensive review. Alternatives considered and rejected Cabinet could have rejected or amended the Working Group’s recommendations. Officer to action: Tricia Collis - Planning, Environment, Education and Community Services.
Word for word from the decision Hillingdon published for this meeting. Source: modgov.hillingdon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Hillingdon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to CABINET

Recommendations

That Cabinet:

1. Thanks all those involved in the review for their efforts;

2. Endorses and approves all 12 recommendations in the Interim Report from the Working Group;

3. Gives all necessary authority to implement the Working Group’s recommendations to the Deputy Chief Executive and Director of Planning, Environment, Education and Community Services, in consultation with the Leader of the Council and;

4. Notes that the Working Group will undertake a further review with additional proposals for music tuition and report back to Cabinet in due course.

Cabinet Report 26 May 2011 INFORMATION

On 24th February 2011, the Council established a Working Group to be led by Councillor Judy Kelly, to review support for music tuition in Hillingdon in two distinct phases. Firstly, to review the operation and value for money of the Hillingdon Music Service bringing forward interim proposals to Cabinet in May 2011. Secondly, the Working Group was tasked to develop longer- term proposals, which it will undertake in earnest over the summer and autumn of 2011.

The Working Group is now in a position to report to Cabinet and their interim report and appendices are attached for information.

Members of the Working Group concluded that:

1. The Hillingdon Music Service is of a high quality and well regarded by everyone. The level of commitment by the ‘Friends’ in supporting the Service is greatly valued.

2. There is a substantial need for improvements to the way Hillingdon Music Service operates and provides value for money, as clearly evidenced by this Working Group and leading people involved in the Hillingdon Music Service.

3. A longer-term, more sustainable vision for music tuition in Hillingdon is an essential next step that is shared by both the Council and those involved in the Hillingdon Music Service.

The Working Group met on four occasions where it tasked officers from across the Council to provide it with a forensic overview of the Music Service, received information reports, sought valuable evidence from external witnesses involved in the music service and reviewed in detail interim proposals. Members understood the uncertainty caused by their review and sought to ensure that it would be remembered positively as having been a milestone in both shaping the future direction of the Music Service and putting it on a firmer financial footing.

Members agreed to put forward the following 12 recommendations to Cabinet:

Operation

1. The Working Group endorses the decision made to move the Music Service to Adult and Community Learning, within Education Services, and the synergies that can be made therein;

2. The Working Group endorses actions to implement a more flexible service structure and staff contracts for the benefit of service users, in particular a high rate of pay for advanced practitioners;

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
appendicesAppendix 3 3.6 MB Download
PDF
information reportAppendix 3 111 KB Download
PDF
Terms of ReferenceAppendix 4 31 KB Download
PDF
Review of Support for Music Tuition in Hillingdon: Interim Report of the Working GroupReport 98 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Working Group Interim Report including appendicies 1 & 2 v5 FINALReport 127 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 8 attended
RP
Councillor Raymond PuddifootChair, present
DS
Councillor David SimmondsVice-Chair, present
JB
Councillor Jonathan BiancoCommittee Member, present
KB
Councillor Keith BurrowsCommittee Member, present
PC
Councillor Philip Corthorne MIPDCommittee Member, present
HH
Councillor Henry HigginsCommittee Member, present
DM
Councillor Douglas MillsCommittee Member, present
SS
Councillor Scott Seaman-DigbyCommittee Member, present

On this subject at Hillingdon

Search all
  1. Review of Support for Music Tuition in Hillingdon: Interim Report of the Working GroupThis decision
  2. Closure of Retail Operations and Review of Support Services from the Rural Activities Garden CentreAgreed
  3. Review of Charging for Social Care and Support PolicyApproved
  4. Major Review - Supporting children with Special Needs and Disabilities in their early years - Witness Session 1Noted
  5. Children, Young People and Learning Policy Overview & Scrutiny Committee - Review into Supporting Educational Aspiration for Disadvantaged ChildrenAgreed
  6. Minor Review - Supporting Educational Aspiration for Disadvantaged ChildrenDecided

More from Hillingdon CABINET

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
19 Nov 2026 Corporate Peer Review & Action PlanThat Cabinet: 1) Welcomes the findings of the LGA Corporate Peer Challenge undertaken June 2026 and notes the strengt... Approved Open
19 Nov 2026 Strategic Review of Library Services and Future Delivery ModelThat Cabinet: 1) Approves the launch of the Strategic Review of Library Services and Future Delivery Model, the devel... Approved Open
19 Nov 2026 Hayes Town Centre Regeneration FrameworkThat Cabinet agrees to adopt the as the Council’s strategic vision and delivery framework for improvements to Hayes T... Agreed Open
19 Nov 2026 Old Vinyl Factory, Hayes: Conservation Area AppraisalThat Cabinet: 1) Duly considers the public consultation responses to the draft Appraisal for The Old Vinyl Factory Co... Approved Open
19 Nov 2026 Carers Strategy UpdateThat Cabinet: 1) Note the report and agree that officers bring forward an annual progress report to Cabinet on suppor... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies