CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
London Borough of Hillingdon
CABINET, Thursday 28 July 2011 at 7.00pm

Hillingdon's response to the Government's consultation on High Speed Rail

Agreed Executive 6 papers

CABINET agreed this item on Thursday 28 July 2011. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item356

Resolved

That the Cabinet: Welcomes the Council’s resolution on 7 July 2011 reaffirming the London Borough of Hillingdon’s full opposition to HS2; Recognises the extensive resident consultation campaign led by the Leader of the Council and notes the overwhelming support against the proposed HS2 route from residents and local action groups across the Borough; Notes the contents of the report and agrees the response to the Government’s Consultation for submission to the Department for Transport as set out in Appendix 1; Agrees to grant delegated authority to the Deputy Chief Executive and Corporate Director of Planning, Environment, Education and Community Services in consultation with the Leader of the Council and the Cabinet Member for Planning, Transportation and Recycling to agree any further changes required to the Council’s consultation response; Notes the response to the London Assembly Transport Committee as set out in Appendix 2; Notes that in addition to residential properties, that there will be a number of council-owned properties that will be affected by the proposed route as set out in Appendix 3; Endorses the 51M Group’s response to the Government’s High Speed Rail Consultation as set out in Appendix 4; Instructs officers to continue work on opposing the Government’s current proposals for High Speed Rail, including joint working with the 51M Group, and to report back to Cabinet on any significant issues and; Agrees the urgency of this matter so that the Council's response can be sent to the Government by the consultation deadline and therefore requests the call-in procedures be waived on the above recommendations so that any decisions take immediate effect. Reasons for decision Cabinet noted that the proposed High Speed 2 rail line was likely to be the most significant development proposal in Hillingdon since the 3rd Runway at Heathrow. Its adverse impacts were considered to be far in excess of the benefits that would ensue from the proposal. Cabinet agreed an effective and robust response to the Government’s consultation on High Speed Rail to protect the interests of residents and businesses in the Borough. This had followed significant consultation with residents from across the whole Borough. Cabinet thanked the local residents groups for their efforts to-date and in particular, paid tribute to the professional team of Council Officers who had worked on pulling the detailed response together. Alternative options considered and rejected None. Officer to action: Jales Tippell - Planning, Environment, Education and Community Services
Word for word from the decision Hillingdon published for this meeting. Source: modgov.hillingdon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Hillingdon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to CABINET, 78 pages

Appendix 1: Hillingdon’s High Speed Rail Appraisal of Carbon Impacts High Speed Rail

Appraisal of Carbon Impacts

Report Author: Ian Thynne

Report Date: 08 July 2011

Revision: Final Contents 1. Executive Summary................................................................... 5 1.1. Executive Summary ............................................................................5

2. Introduction .............................................................................. 11 2.1. Background .......................................................................................11 2.2. Purpose of this Paper........................................................................11

3. Assessment of Report.............................................................. 13 3.1. Report Deficiencies ..........................................................................13

4. What is the Report Assessing? ............................................... 18 4.1. Introduction .......................................................................................18 4.2. If Proposed Route/Scheme = London to Birmingham.................20 4.3. If Proposed Route/Scheme = London to Manchester and Leeds 22

5. Unlikely HS2 Report Conclusions............................................ 23 5.1. Modal Shift from Air to Rail...............................................................23 5.2. Shift from Domestic to International Flights ...................................29 5.3. Emissions from Extra HS2 Journeys may outweigh the Modal Shift 32 5.4. Lack of Consideration of Additional Impacts...............................33 5.5. Conclusions on Impacts on Emissions ............................................36

6. No Consideration of Carbon Costs ...................................... 38 6.1. Carbon Costs Assessment................................................................38

7. Phillip Hammond Letter .......................................................... 40 7.1. Critical Appraisal...............................................................................40

8. Conclusions .............................................................................. 42 8.1. Conclusions........................................................................................42 9. Appendix 1: Phillip Hammond Letter.................................... 45 1. Executive Summary 1.1. Executive Summary

1.1.1. HS2 LTD claim that the multi billion pound HS2 will be broadly carbon neutral. In a letter dated 9 February to a colleague, Phillip Hammond reiterates the claim, but goes one stage further and says that the first phase of HS2 will be broadly carbon neutral.

1.1.2. HS2 Ltd claims that HS2 will instigate a significant shift away from more carbon intensive flights and in turn helping to reduce the transport sector’s 25% of the UK emissions. Unfortunately, these claims are based on an inaccurate set of assumptions and a highly inadequate report.

1.1.3. In reality HS2 is likely to result in an increase in the UK emissions. HS2 Ltd is relying on an increase in domestic aviation to justify bold carbon claims. However, a significant modal shift from domestic flights to rail has already begun. HS2 will reduce the amount of domestic flights, but by the time this happens, the modal shift will be vastly less than HS2 Ltd has claimed. Furthermore, HS2 will attract customers from far less carbon intensive existing lines on to a brand new network. This new network will have a considerable carbon deficit long before any impacts on domestic aviation are realised. This makes HS2 a highly expensive transport intervention that will only have a negative impact on UK transport emissions.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Appendicies to Hillingdon's response to the Government consultationReport 78 pages DownloadRead as text
PDF
Appendicies to Hillingdon's response to the Greater London Assembly ExaminationReport 13 pages Download
PDF
Hillingdon's response to the Government's consultationAppendix 1 134 pages Download
PDF
Hillingdon's Response to the Greater London Assembly ExaminationAppendix 2 56 pages Download
PDF
51MGroup response: minus appendiciesAppendix 4 65 pages Download
PDF
Hillingdon's response to the Government's consultation on High Speed RailReport 18 pages Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
354To approve the minutes of the last Cabinet meetingOn the agenda 355To confirm that the items of business marked Part 1 will be considered in public and that the items of business marked Part 2 in privateAgreed
356Hillingdon's response to the Government's consultation on High Speed RailThis decision
357Rural Activities Garden Centre - project plan for its modernisation and sustainable futureNoted 358Hillingdon's Local Development Framework: Pre-submission draft Core StrategyApproved 359Primary Schools Capital Programme - updateAgreed 360Consultation response to BAA Heathrow's review of noise mitigation schemesNoted 361Street Trading and Markets PolicyApproved 362Hillingdon's Children and Families Trust Plan 2011-14Approved 363Priorities and Key issues for Hillingdon's Housing Strategy 2011/15Approved 364Voluntary Sector Leasing PolicyAgreed 365Acceptance of Homes and Community Agency funding for Hillingdon's Supported Housing ProgrammeApproved 366Council Budget - 2010/12 Revenue and Capital OutturnApproved 367Council Budget - Month 2 2011/12 Revenue and Capital Monitoring ReportNoted 369Highgrove Pool Refurbishment - revised proposals for the provision of project management and design servicesPrivate 370Award of contract: supply of telecare productsPrivate 372Pan-London Energy Scheme: RE:NEWPrivate 373Acceptance of tender for the supply of recycling bags and garden waste sacksPrivate 374Support and development of the Customer Relationship System - contract extensionPrivate 375Extra Care Housing: contract award for the provision of personal carePrivate 376Extension of IP network and IP telephony support contractsPrivate 377Provision of a Temporary Ice Rink 2011Private 378Review of the Council's fleet holdingsPrivate 379West London Framework Agreement for private sector accommodation procurement and managementPrivate 380Manor Farm - The Stables refurbishment & acceptance of tenderPrivate 381Adaptations to Council dwellings - extension to contactPrivate 382Extension of electrical repairs contract for support to Hillingdon Housing Repairs ServicePrivate 383Selection of Preferred Partners for Affordable Housing ProvisionPrivate 384Barnhill Community High School - Academy ConversionPrivate 385Any other items the Chairman agrees are relevant or urgentAgreed

On this subject at Hillingdon

Search all
  1. Hillingdon's response to the Government's consultation on High Speed RailThis decision
  2. Hillingdon Council's Response to CoronavirusNoted
  3. Hillingdon Air Quality Action Plan Consultation ResponseNoted
  4. Hillingdon's response to the draft National Planning Policy Framework and Developer Contributions ReformsAgreed
  5. Hillingdon's response to the draft London PlanAgreed
  6. Hillingdon's response to the Airports Commission's consultation: Appraisal of Short-Listed Airport Expansion OptionsAgreed

More from Hillingdon CABINET

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
19 Nov 2026 Corporate Peer Review & Action PlanThat Cabinet: 1) Welcomes the findings of the LGA Corporate Peer Challenge undertaken June 2026 and notes the strengt... Approved Open
19 Nov 2026 Strategic Review of Library Services and Future Delivery ModelThat Cabinet: 1) Approves the launch of the Strategic Review of Library Services and Future Delivery Model, the devel... Approved Open
19 Nov 2026 Hayes Town Centre Regeneration FrameworkThat Cabinet agrees to adopt the as the Council’s strategic vision and delivery framework for improvements to Hayes T... Agreed Open
19 Nov 2026 Old Vinyl Factory, Hayes: Conservation Area AppraisalThat Cabinet: 1) Duly considers the public consultation responses to the draft Appraisal for The Old Vinyl Factory Co... Approved Open
19 Nov 2026 Carers Strategy UpdateThat Cabinet: 1) Note the report and agree that officers bring forward an annual progress report to Cabinet on suppor... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies