CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
London Borough of Hillingdon
CABINET, Thursday 25 September 2014 at 7.00pm

HS2 - Hillingdon's response to the Property Consultation 2014

Approved Executive 2 papers

CABINET approved this item on Thursday 25 September 2014. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item1008

Resolved

That Cabinet: 1. Approves the Council's response to Property Consultation 2014 for the London West Midlands HS2 route. 2. Requests that the Chairman of the Executive Scrutiny Committee waives the scrutiny call-in on this decision to ensure that the consultation response can be completed within the required deadline. Reasons for decision Cabinet endorsed the Council's response to the HS2 Property Consultation 2014, the latest in a series of consultation exercises by the Government in relation to compensation payments for property owners who would suffer blight and a loss in the value of their properties as a direct consequence of Phase One of the HS2 Scheme. The response sought the best outcome for those residents affected and Cabinet expressed its unequivocal commitment to continue to oppose the proposed route, which would likely to be the most significant development proposal in the Borough since the 3rd Runway. Alternative options considered and rejected Cabinet could have decided not to respond to the consultation, but this was considered to be inappropriate due to the adverse impacts that HS2 would have upon the Borough. Officers to action: Jales Tippell , Residents Services Rajesh Alagh , Borough Solicitor
Word for word from the decision Hillingdon published for this meeting. Source: modgov.hillingdon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Hillingdon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to CABINET, 4 pages

Recommendations

That Cabinet:

1. Approves the Council's response to Property Consultation 2014 for the London West Midlands HS2 route.

2. Requests that the Chairman of the Executive Scrutiny Committee waives the scrutiny call-in if Cabinet approves the above recommendation so as to ensure that the consultation response can be completed within the required deadline.

Cabinet – 25 September 2014 INFORMATION

Reasons for recommendation

The Council, in responding to the consultation, is seeking the best outcome for those residents whose properties will be blighted by the HS2 Scheme.

Alternative options considered

The alternative option would be for the Cabinet to decide not to respond to the consultation. This is not considered to be an appropriate option due to the adverse impacts that HS2 will have upon residents of the Borough.

Comments of Policy Overview Committee

None at this stage.

Supporting Information

Background

1. The HS2 Property Consultation 2014 is the latest in a series of consultation exercises which the Government has undertaken in relation to proposing compensation payments for property owners who will suffer blight and a loss in the value of their properties as a direct consequence of Phase One of the HS2 Scheme.

2. The first consultation was launched in October 2012 and the Council sent a robust response in January 2013. The opportunity was taken to reinforce the Council's concerns about the inadequacy and unfairness of the consultation, including the lack of adequate information on which to fully understand the impacts of HS2. It was highlighted that the HS2 project itself should fully compensate the real costs to individuals and communities impacted and that suitable compensation schemes should be devised to achieve this. The Council drew particular attention to the need to have the same schemes offered in both urban and rural areas and not attempt to minimise the compensation schemes for urban areas on the basis that the costs, due to the number of properties impacted, would be greater.

3. HS2 Action Alliance went further and brought a judicial review claim against the Government on the grounds that the 2012 consultation was unfair and unlawful. This claim was heard by the High Court at the same time as 51M's judicial review challenge i.e. December 2012.

4. The High Court ruled in March 2013 that the Government's property compensation consultation proposals were unlawful which forced the Government to re-consult.

5. In September 2013, the Government launched a fresh consultation exercise on property compensation. Once again, the Council sent a robust response to the consultation proposals.

Cabinet – 25 September 2014 6. On 9 April 2014, the Government announced a package of measures to assist property owners affected by HS2. These measures can be summarised as follows:

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
HS2: Hillingdon's response to the Property Consultation 2014Report 4 pages DownloadRead as text
PDF
Hillingdon's responseReport 3 pages Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

7 of 17 attended
SO
Councillor Susan O'BrienIndependent Chair (Co-opted Member), in attendance
WB
Councillor Wayne BridgesCompany Director, in attendance
JC
Councillor Judith CooperCompany Director, in attendance
BC
Councillor Brian CroweCompany Director, in attendance
PC
Councillor Peter CurlingCompany Director, in attendance
JH
Councillor John HensleyCompany Director, in attendance
AK
Councillor Allan KauffmanCompany Director, in attendance
MK
Councillor Mo KhursheedCompany Director, in attendance
LA
Councillor Lynne AllenCompany Director, in attendance
RP
Councillor Raymond Puddifoot MBEChair, present
DS
Councillor David SimmondsVice-Chair, present
KB
Councillor Keith BurrowsCommittee Member, present

All 17 on the meeting page

On this subject at Hillingdon

Search all
  1. HS2 - Hillingdon's response to the Property Consultation 2014This decision
  2. Hillingdon Council's Response to CoronavirusNoted
  3. Hillingdon Air Quality Action Plan Consultation ResponseNoted
  4. Hillingdon's response to the draft National Planning Policy Framework and Developer Contributions ReformsAgreed
  5. Hillingdon's response to the draft London PlanAgreed
  6. Hillingdon's response to the Airports Commission's consultation: Appraisal of Short-Listed Airport Expansion OptionsAgreed

More from Hillingdon CABINET

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
19 Nov 2026 Corporate Peer Review & Action PlanThat Cabinet: 1) Welcomes the findings of the LGA Corporate Peer Challenge undertaken June 2026 and notes the strengt... Approved Open
19 Nov 2026 Strategic Review of Library Services and Future Delivery ModelThat Cabinet: 1) Approves the launch of the Strategic Review of Library Services and Future Delivery Model, the devel... Approved Open
19 Nov 2026 Hayes Town Centre Regeneration FrameworkThat Cabinet agrees to adopt the as the Council’s strategic vision and delivery framework for improvements to Hayes T... Agreed Open
19 Nov 2026 Old Vinyl Factory, Hayes: Conservation Area AppraisalThat Cabinet: 1) Duly considers the public consultation responses to the draft Appraisal for The Old Vinyl Factory Co... Approved Open
19 Nov 2026 Carers Strategy UpdateThat Cabinet: 1) Note the report and agree that officers bring forward an annual progress report to Cabinet on suppor... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies