CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
London Borough of Hillingdon
Licensing Committee, Tuesday 9 January 2018 at 10.00am

Legislative and Industry Update

Noted Licensing 1 paper

Licensing Committee noted this item on Tuesday 9 January 2018. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item24

Resolved

That the Committee note the information.
Word for word from the decision Hillingdon published for this meeting. Source: modgov.hillingdon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Hillingdon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Licensing Committee

Recommendations

That the Licensing Committee note the report.

SUPPORTING INFORMATION

1. Caselaw Update:

a. Scotch Whisky Association and others v The Lord Advocate and another (Scotland)[2017] UKSC76

The Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Act was passed in May 2012 by the Scottish Parliament. It prohibits the sale of alcohol below a minimum price, calculated on the basis of the drink's alcoholic content. The Scottish ministers proposed a minimum pricing unit of 50p, subject to consultation and an up-to-date business and regulatory impact assessment.

The Scotch Whisky Association, along with other European wine and spirits trade bodies, began a legal challenge against the minimum alcohol pricing in 2012. Their arguments were based on:  The lawfulness of the legislation; and  Whether or not minimum pricing was disproportionate under European Union Law. Scottish Ministers agreed not to bring the legislation into force or make any order setting a minimum price until determination of the legal challenge.

The Outer House of the Court of Session rejected the arguments in May 2013. However, the Inner House, which is Scotland's highest civil court, referred the case to the Court of Justice of the European Union (referred to as "CJEU") on appeal after finding that it "raised questions of European law". The CJEU ruled in 2015 that the policy was incompatible with EU law "if less restrictive tax measures can be introduced", but left this final test to the Scottish courts.

Classification: Public Licensing Committee 9th January 2018 The Inner House backed the planned policy in its ruling of October 2016. The Scotch Whisky Association appealed the matter to the Supreme Court. By this stage, all parties had agreed that minimum alcohol pricing would affect the market and EU trade in alcohol. The issue for the Supreme Court was whether there was justification for the market interference or whether less restrictive measures such as excise or tax could provide the same results.

The Supreme Court said that it was "ready to accept" that a general increase in excise duties or VAT across narrowly defined bands of alcoholic strength was permitted by EU law as an alternative. However, tax increases would not be as effective at targeting the health hazards of cheap alcohol in particular, as intended by the policy.

"Taxation would impose an unintended and unacceptable burden on sectors of the drinking population, whose drinking habits and health do not represent a significant problem in societal terms in the same way as the drinking habits and health of in particular the deprived, whose use and abuse of cheap alcohol the Scottish parliament and government wish to target," said Lord Mance, giving the judgment of the court. "In contrast, minimum alcohol pricing will much better target the really problematic drinking to which the government's objectives were always directed."

The Judge also pointed out that minimum alcohol pricing was easier to understand and simpler to enforce.

The Judge cited new research by the University of Sheffield, published in April 2016, which indicated that tax increases by as much as 36% in some cases would be needed to deliver the same beneficial impacts as a 50p minimum alcohol pricing.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Legislative and Industry UpdateReport 123 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

6 of 10 attended
DG
Councillor Dominic GilhamChair, apologies
DY
Councillor David YarrowVice-Chair, present
LA
Councillor Lynne AllenCommittee Member, apologies
TB
Councillor Teji BarnesCommittee Member, present
RC
Councillor Roy ChamdalCommittee Member, present
JD
Councillor Jazz DhillonCommittee Member, apologies
AK
Councillor Allan KauffmanCommittee Member, present
JG
Councillor Janet GardnerCommittee Member, apologies
PJ
Councillor Patricia JacksonCommittee Member, present
JM
Councillor John MorseCommittee Member, present

On this subject at Hillingdon

Search all
  1. Legislative and Industry UpdateThis decision
  2. Legislative and Industry UpdateNoted
  3. Legislative and Industry UpdateNoted
  4. Legislative and Industry UpdateNoted
  5. Legislative and Industry UpdateNoted
  6. Legislative & Industry Update- April 2023Decided

More from Hillingdon Licensing Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
8 Oct 2026 To agree the minutes from the meeting on 8 October 2025That the minutes from the meeting on 8 October 2025 be approved as an accurate record. Approved Open
8 Oct 2026 To agree the minutes from the meeting on 14 May 2026That the minutes from the meeting on 14 May 2026 be approved as accurate record. Approved Open
8 Oct 2026 Legislative and Industry UpdateThat the Committee noted the report. Noted Open
14 May 2026 Election of ChairThat Councillor Darran Davies be elected as Chair of the Licensing Committee for the 2026/27 municipal year. Decided Open
14 May 2026 Election of Vice ChairThat Councillor Kelly Martin be elected as Vice Chair of the Licensing Committee for the 2026/27 municipal year. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies