Resolved
That the Committee note the report.
Licensing Committee noted this item on Tuesday 8 January 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
That the Committee note the report.
That the Committee note the report.
SUPPORTING INFORMATION
London Borough of Lambeth v Ashu
[name removed] operated a 24-hour convenience store within Lambeth. The Premises Licence authorised the sale of alcohol for consumption off the premises on Monday to Saturday from 08:00 - 23:00 and on Sunday from 10:00 - 22: 30.
In January 2016 the Metropolitan Police applied for a review of the Premises Licence because there had been a number of sales of alcohol outside of these permitted hours.
The Licensing Sub Committee of the London Borough of Lambeth held a Review Hearing, and on 12 April 2016, revoked the Premises Licence. It its reasons the Sub-Committee stated that they had no confidence in [name removed] willingness to abide by the licence conditions. In particular, they were greatly concerned that sale of alcohol had taken place at 1.30AM on 10 April 2016 - being 2 days before the Sub Committee’s meeting and considered that the Licence Holder could not provide any assurance that she would abide by her Licence Conditions in the future.
[name removed] appealed this decision and in February 2017 Camberwell Green Magistrates Court upheld her appeal and imposed an additional condition on her licence (that have been proposed by [name removed]) to require the premises to close at 23:00 on Monday - Saturday and at 22:30 on a Sunday. In addition, the Magistrates Court ordered the London Borough of Lambeth to pay [name removed] legal costs.
The London Borough of Lambeth subsequently appealed the decision of Camberwell Green Magistrates Court to the High Court.
The High Court, in late 2017, upheld Lambeth's appeal and held as follows:
Classification: Public Licensing Committee: 8 January 2019 An appeal to the Magistrates Court operates as a rehearing, but the magistrates must be satisfied that the Council's decision was wrong before it can uphold an appeal. The burden of proof is on the appellant to show that the Council’s decision was wrong.
The Magistrates Court is under a duty to give full and proper reasons for its decision so that all parties can understand the basis of the decision.
If there has been a change of circumstances between the original decision of the Council and the date of the hearing in the Magistrates Court that change does not necessarily entitle the Court to substitute its decision for that of the Council.
On reviewing the decision of Camberwell Green Magistrates Court, it was clear that the reasons given were inadequate. The Magistrates Court had merely stated that they had read the minutes of the Sub Committee and that they understood its concerns, but did not give any further reasons for its decision to uphold the appeal. In particular, the magistrates did not state whether they considered that Lambeth’s original decision had been wrong.
Further, the Magistrates should not have substituted their view for that of Lambeth when the appellant proposed to change her opening hours. The Magistrates should have remitted the case back to the Licensing Sub Committee in view of this change of circumstances.
The High Court concluded: “the absence of any adequate explanation of the Magistrates Court’s reasons is in stark contrast to the record of the Sub Committee deliberations which makes plain that they had considered lesser alternatives to revocation and the reasons why they had rejected them. This is not a mere technicality. The court's reasons do not show any competent consideration of the matters that gave rise to the Sub Committee's concerns. Those were material concerns in November 2016 just as they had been in April 2017 and the failure to address them vitiates the purported exercise of their discretion”.
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Legislative and Industry UpdateReport | 75 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Licensing Committee at Hillingdon and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 Oct 2026 | To agree the minutes from the meeting on 8 October 2025That the minutes from the meeting on 8 October 2025 be approved as an accurate record. | Approved | Open |
| 8 Oct 2026 | To agree the minutes from the meeting on 14 May 2026That the minutes from the meeting on 14 May 2026 be approved as accurate record. | Approved | Open |
| 8 Oct 2026 | Legislative and Industry UpdateThat the Committee noted the report. | Noted | Open |
| 14 May 2026 | Election of ChairThat Councillor Darran Davies be elected as Chair of the Licensing Committee for the 2026/27 municipal year. | Decided | Open |
| 14 May 2026 | Election of Vice ChairThat Councillor Kelly Martin be elected as Vice Chair of the Licensing Committee for the 2026/27 municipal year. | Decided | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.