Resolved
That the mover and seconder of the budget motion and the principal speaker / mover and seconder of the principal amendment from the Labour Group be allowed unlimited speaking time on this item. Councillor Goddard moved, and Councillor Edwards seconded, the budget recommendations as set out on the Order of Business. Councillor Mathers moved, and Councillor Curling seconded, the following amendment: Proposal to be moved: a) That the Cabinet be invited to consider the Labour Group's amendments to the Cabinet's budget proposals set out in the Council Tax Resolution and report back to the Council; b) In relation to the General Fund Revenue Budget the proposals are based on the budget proposals approved by Cabinet on 15 February 2024, subject to the following amendments; c) In relation to the General Fund Capital Budget, the proposals are based on the budget proposals approved by Cabinet on 15 February 2024, subject to the following amendments; d) In relation to the Housing Revenue Account Revenue Budget, the proposals are based on the budget proposals approved by Cabinet on 15 February 2024, subject to the following amendments; e) In relation to the Housing Revenue Account Capital Budget, the proposals are based on the budget proposals approved by Cabinet on 15 February 2024, subject to the following amendments; Supporting Information for the above proposals: Council Tax Levels and Medium-Term Impact The following amendments to Cabinet’s budget proposals have been developed in the context of the cost-of-living crisis, with the amendment including the creation of a Local Household Support Fund and reductions in a number of the proposed uplifts to fees and charges and a number of additional service priorities being funded by additional savings proposals, with the most material being digitalisation of Hillingdon People and carrying out a BID Review of the Communications Team. Amendments to the Capital Programme outlined later in this document would result in a minor increase in prudential borrowing of £17k for invest to save schemes, increasing prudential borrowing to £63,099k over the next five years to 2028/29, with amendments based on commercial opportunities. These budget amendments include increasing General Balances by £503k, with £500k of this funded by a transfer from Member-led Earmarked Reserves and increases the total balances on reserves in 2024/25 by £3k to £38,887k. With an increased investment in the HRA aimed at increasing Housing Stock numbers to secure an additional £150k per annum benefit from 2026/27 by reducing the pressure on Looked After Children’s budgets from a lack of General Needs properties, with this benefit to increase General Balances by a further £450k by 2028/29. A further proposal based on running heritage sites on a trust basis is forecast to increase the contribution to General Balances by £1,260k by 2027/28. Changes to 2024/25 Revenue Budget Specific amendments to the 2024/25 budget proposals have been developed and set out in table 1 below. These proposals include: Reserves Earmarked Reserve Repurposing : It is proposed that Earmarked Reserves controlled by Members are reduced by £700k, with £500k of this being contributed to General Balances to accelerate the rate at which the Council will meet the minimum reserves level, with a further £200k being used to create a new Digital Disaster Reserve to enable the Council to quickly respond to any new and emerging issues that could arise from the new Digital Strategy. Services to Residents Scale Back the Street Cleaning Saving: With a 2023/24 saving of £400k, this budget amendment proposes reducing the saving by £144k to increase the number of street cleaning operatives by 4 to continue to offer a more personalised service and maintain a presence on the high streets. Local Household Support Fund: With the Government set to close the nationally funded Household Support Fund, it is proposed that £110k is set aside to support households facing financial difficulty with the purchase of white good and school uniforms to offset the impact of the fund closing on 31 March 2024. Reverse the Fortnightly Garden Waste Collections in Winter Months saving: The budget amendment includes the reversal of this saving a cost of £105k to ensure that residents have a consistent service throughout the year on all waste services, including garden waste. Remove the increase proposed for 1 st permits: To support Local Residents during the cost-of-living crisis following the introduction of charges for 1 st permits, it is proposed that the uplift in this charge for 2024/25 is reversed from the budget proposals at a minor cost of £5k. Make Tennis Courts free to book: To support families during the cost-of-living crisis and support local residents with their physical and mental wellbeing, it is proposed that Council tennis courts are made free to use through an online booking system. To support this bid, it is also proposed that one site is used as a commercial tennis site, with a capital investment of £250k required to build a club house, with year 1 forecast to breakeven, with the income forecast to cover both the lost fees and charges income and the capital financing cost associated with the borrowing required to build the clubhouse. Introduce a Landlord Licensing Scheme: A breakeven proposal is included to introduce a Landlord Licensing Scheme aimed at improving standards within the private rented sector, with the investment to be offset through fees and charges. Ultimately it is anticipated that this will also support the physical and mental wellbeing of residents, whilst also reducing demand on the Council’s own housing stock in the Housing Revenue Account (HRA). Introduce Regulatory Officer for Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs): Employing an officer to monitor HMOs and reduce the negative impact of HMOs on neighbours and costs on the Council. Including waste management, anti-social behaviour and energy meter disputes information to tenants. This officer will also investigate the feasibility of a HMO landlord standards registration. The cost of this officer will be charged back through HMO application fees through the full cost recovery model. This post will contribute to future council savings through early prevention. Finance & Corporate Items Set up a Trust to run the Council's heritage sites : With the Council now running the Battle of Britain Bunker on a Trust basis, it is proposed that this approach is broadened across other heritage sites, with the year 1 impact forecast to be a £19k saving, with this forecast to increase to £1,260k by 2027/28, with this additional benefit in later years to be used to increase General Balances. Capital Financing Impact from Updates to the Capital Programme: With two invest to save additions proposed to be added to the capital programme, the capital financing impact is forecast to add £17k to 2024/25, with this cost ultimately being over recovered by the saving proposals. Transformation – Investment in cross cutting bid writing team: It is proposed that the Council invest in a team with the primary focus of securing additional funding from external sources, with one officer focused on General Fund activities and another focused on supporting the Schools Budget Safety Valve Agreement. The officer focused on the General Fund is expected to generate income sufficient to cover the expenditure in year 1 but is expected to exceed this level of the medium-term. The post supporting the DSG can be funded from capital receipts under Government direction, with a view to the team becoming self-financing and generating a net benefit for the Council from 2025/26 onwards. Savings Proposals : The budget amendment includes a number of savings proposals including the repurposing of Hillingdon People to a more digital offer to make a saving against the printing and distribution costs saving £156k, a BID review of the communications team to save £100k, a reduction in the Mayor’s Expenses budget of £9k, with proposals to lease out a site as a café in Ruislip generating £15k and a further proposal to lease out an area of the Civic Centre to the Home Officer for a further £15k, with these saving initiatives reducing spend by £292k per annum. Table 1: Changes to 2023/24 General Fund Revenue Budget 2024/25 2024/25 £'000 £'000 Council Tax Requirement based on Cabinet Proposals 145,751 Earmarked Reserve Repurposing 0 Create a Digital Disaster Reserve 200 Transfer Earmarked Reserves to General Balances 500 Reduce the Balance on Member Driven Earmarked Reserves (700) Services to Residents 294 Scale back the Street Cleansing saving 144 Local Household Support Fund Scheme 110 Local Household Support Fund Scheme - Centralise Council Functions (60) Reverse the Fortnightly Garden Waste Collections in Winter Months saving 105 Remove the increase proposed for 1 st permits 5 Make Tennis Courts free to book 20 Commercialise One Tennis Court Site (30) Introduce a Landlord Licensing Scheme 100 Generate Fees & Charges from the Landlord Licensing Scheme (100) Introduce Regulatory Officer for HMOs 60 Increase HMO Licence Fee (60) Finance & Corporate items (2) Set up a Trust to run the Council's heritage sites (19) Capital Financing Impact from Updates to the Capital Programme 17 Transformation: Investment in cross cutting bid writing teams 60 Transformation: Funding Obtained from Bid Writing (60) Transformation: Investment in DSG bid writing team 60 Transformation Capitalisation Funding (60) Savings Proposals (1,041) Repurposing of Hillingdon People (156) BID Review of Communications (100) Reduction to Mayors Expenses Budget (9) Generate Income from the Middlesex Suite 0 Generate Lease Income from a Café by Cow Byre, Ruislip (15) Generate Lease Income from the Home Office in the Civic (15) General Balances (3) Increase in General Balances (3) Change in Council Tax Requirement 0 Council Tax Requirement based on Labour Group Proposals 145,751 Changes to the General Fund Capital Programme There are two proposed changes to the General Fund Capital Programme, with both these being invest to save additions, with the details being: Cow Byre Café Development : It is proposed that a café is introduced on a vacant site by the Cow Byre site in Ruislip, with an investment of £150k required to deliver the site. The lease income from the site will generate £15k per annum, more than covering the £6k capital financing cost and generating an ongoing net benefit for the General Fund. Build Club House at one Tennis Court Site for Commercial Offer : It is proposed that the Council changes one of the tennis court sites to operate on a commercial basis, with an investment of £250k being required to build a club house for the operating to run the venue from, which can also include a café and shop. The investment is expected to breakeven in year 1, with the lease income of £30k covering both the capital financing costs and also funding the removal of the tennis court booking fee. The investment will further support the physical and mental wellbeing of residents, offering a pay-as-you-go tennis offer in the borough, for adults and children, with an increased children’s offer in school holidays. Table 2: Capital Programme Changes Project Budget Grants and Contributions CIL Capital Receipts Prudential Borrowing £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 Capital Programme 377,109 145,380 23,463 103,950 104,316 Cow Byre site, Ruislip Café Development 150 150 Build Club House at one Tennis Court Site for Commercial Offer 250 250 Total Updates 400 0 0 0 400 Revised Capital Programme 377,509 145,380 23,463 103,950 104,716 HRA Budget Changes Housing Revenue Account (HRA) revenue budget amendments include a proposal to double the repairs growth in the budget proposals over a three-year period, increasing the 2024/25 growth by £350k, with this growth item to scale up to £1,000k by 2026/27, before unwinding the additional investment at £500k per annum in 2027/28 and 2028/29, with a forecast reduction in the revenue impact of repairs of £500k by year-five from the upfront investment, with the objective of the investment to be an acceleration of the work required to improve the Council’s housing stock and avoid disrepair claims . Included in the HRA Amendment is a capital proposal to increase the Council’s housing stock above the current budget proposals by a net 100 homes in 2025/26 and 2026/27, effectively increasing the stock growth to compensate for the Right-To-Buy sales of 40 per annum in those two years, with a total capital investment of £35,200k. This investment will yield additional rental income of £1,031k per annum by the end of the five-year budget cycle. It is then proposed that a BID Review is carried out on both tenancy management and the repairs service, ensuring that efficiency gains from the upfront investment in repairs are maximised, securing an additional £382k saving that will support the additional capital financing cost above the rental income yield, with this saving being less than 1% of these two service areas. The increase in the Council’s housing stock will also benefit the General Fund and can be used to either support the growing homelessness pressure or address the lack of General Needs properties for Looked After Children, with an estimated benefit on the General Fund of £150k per annum by 2027/28. Table 3: HRA Revenue Changes 2024/25 2024/25 2025/26-2028/29 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 HRA Planned Use of Balances (101) 0 Double the growth item in the budget for repairs work 350 0 Repairs saving from early investment 0 (500) Increase the stock numbers by a net 100 in 2025/26 and 2026/27 0 (1,031) Capital Financing Impact 0 1,913 Carry out a BID Review of Tenancy Management & The Repairs Service 0 (382) HRA Planned Use of Balances from Labour Group Proposals 249 0 Table 3: HRA Capital Changes 2024/25 2024/25 2025/26-2028/29 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 HRA Capital Budget 550,150 550,150 Increase the stock numbers by 100 in the medium-term 35,200 HRA Capital Budget from Labour Group Proposals 550,150 585,350 Table 4: HRA Stock Numbers Tenanted Stock 2023/24 2024/25 2025/26 2026/27 2027/28 2028/29 Change Projected Opening Stock 10,253 10,295 10,518 10,603 10,714 10,694 N/A Forecast Right-to-Buy Sales (50) (40) (40) (40) (40) (25) (235) New Units 114 300 100 100 20 20 654 Housing Regeneration voids (22) (37) (66) 0 (79) (94) (298) Housing Regeneration new build 0 0 91 51 79 53 274 Projected Closing Stock 10,295 10,518 10,603 10,714 10,694 10,648 395 Budget Amendment 40 40 80 Revised Closing Stock 10,295 10,518 10,643 10,754 10,694 10,648 475 Those speaking in support of the amendment suggested that the proposed budget was not fit for purpose and would result in an increase of £18m in the funding gap. The budget was becoming more of a challenge but the administration’s lack of forethought and lack of ideas would lead the Council to financial ruin. The amendment provided a more pragmatic approach to the budget and would rebuild general balance reserves, which were currently under the recommended threshold. The administration had failed to generate income from its existing assets, with only £1,100 raised from the Middlesex Suite in the previous year, and the lack of reserves would lead the authority down the path to bankruptcy. The amendment looked to support public health initiatives, retain the weekly waste collection and build more Council homes whilst remaining financially responsible. Although in July 2023 Cabinet Members had stated during a Council meeting that green waste was a vital part of waste management and that it would continue to be collected weekly, the budget proposed that green waste be collected fortnightly during the winter months. It was suggested that the bid writing team included in the amendment would pay for itself, whilst also reducing the deficit. This initiative had been introduced in Lewisham and had unlocked significant funding in relation to things like the Pupil Premium. Transferring the Battle of Britain Bunker to a Charitable Trust would also save the Council money and secure the heritage site’s future. The Household Support Fund, which had provided help to residents with the cost of living, would shortly be coming to an end and the administration had not been lobbying Government to stop it from disappearing. The amendment would look to freeze the increase in parking permit fees to reduce the financial impact on residents and invest in housing stock to compensate for Right To Buy sales. The administration should have been ensuring that social housing had been included in developments that were being approved by the Council. The Housing Revenue Account budget had been broken and there had been an increase in the number of residents who were unable to afford to rent a property – the Council had been depriving residents of a decent home. Affordable social housing would be key. A BID review would also be undertaken into tenancy management and repairs to improve the Council housing stock and avoid repair costs. A landlord licensing scheme would also improve standards in the private rented sector. It was recognised that voting for the amendment would not assume that there was agreement with everything that had been suggested, but it would ask the Cabinet to rethink its proposals. Those speaking against the amendment suggested that it had not been properly thought through and, despite having previously expressed concerned about digital exclusion, the opposition was now proposing that Hillingdon People be distributed electronically. The amendment had not included capital investment in early years nurseries or provided any capital support for Uxbridge Library. It had also included a budget for repairs when it actually needed to be looking at a budget for planned maintenance. The amendment had included proposals that the administration had already been investigating as well as ideas that were not feasible. The Council already provided tennis courts and did not need to provide a new pavilion when the money could be better spent elsewhere. Many of the suggestions being made in the amendment should have been issues raised in the relevant Select Committee before now. The amendment was put to a recorded vote: Those voting for: Councillors Abby, Basit, Burles, Curling, Farley, Gardner, Garelick, Garg, Gill, Islam, Judge, Kaur, Lakhmana , Mand, Mathers, Money, Nelson, Nelson-West, Punja, Sansarpuri , Singh and Sweeting. Those voting against: The Mayor (Councillor Ahmad-Wallana), the Deputy Mayor (Councillor Sullivan), Councillors Banerjee, Bennett, Bhatt, Bianco, Bridges, Burrows, Reeta Chamdal, Choubedar, Corthorne , Davies, Denys, Edwards, Goddard, Gohil, Haggar, Higgins, Lavery, Lewis, Makwana, D Mills, R Mills, O’Brien, Palmer, Riley, Smallwood and Tuckwell. Those abstaining: None. The amendment was lost. Those speaking in support of the original motion noted that the budget had been formulated in the face of challenging worldwide and domestic issues as well as fundamental changes in public sector finance. Following the consultation on the budget in December 2023, which had received positive support overall, a few changes had been made and set out in the Cabinet report. It had been recognised that changes might need to be made to service delivery to be able to continue to meet increased demand. It was likely that the cost increases associated with social care would exceed the prevailing rate as the demand for these services continued to increase (social care accounted for approximately 66% of service expenditure). Although the administration had invested in front line services rather than cutting them, the reality was that there would inevitably be some cost escalation. Work had been undertaken to maintain the savings programme by creating service efficiencies and reducing a