Resolved
See the report of the Licensing Officer (Agenda Item 5) PC Simon Lawrence, Metropolitan Police Licensing Officer for Hounslow, attended accompanied by [name removed], counsel for the police. Raja Superstores were represented by [name removed] , counsel, and [name removed] , Licensing Agent. Both parties requested an adjournment to a later date. The Chair asked the reasons for this request. [name removed] advised that he had spoken to [name removed] and the interested parties but had no intention of undermining the Panel’s discretion to decide whether or not to adjourn. He stated that having reviewed evidence including CCTV footage the police would like to amend their application from a request to restrict closing time to 11 pm, to a request for revocation of the licence. In the event of the Panel deciding not to amend or revoke, the police had supplied a document listing suggested conditions. [name removed] stated that the documentation had not been disclosed to the Panel as it had been passed to [name removed] late, which meant that it required his consent for the papers to be submitted at the hearing. As he had not had time to fully review the additional evidence [name removed] had not been able to give such consent. Additionally [name removed] advised that [name removed] had disclosed a table of his concerns regarding the new police documents along with a statement from an expert witness and [name removed] had not had time to obtain instruction regarding these additional papers. Given that there were now a number of documents that could not be disclosed to the Panel, [name removed] stated that he believed that an adjournment would be in the public interest as it would enable both parties to present their case in full. [name removed] advised that he had been served additional documents on Monday and that rather than immediately ask for an adjournment he had read them and set down his objections to the police’s evidence. He stated that he felt that if the counsels spoke to papers that hadn’t been put before the Panel the hearing could not be fairly conducted. [name removed] added that he also felt that there was a possible conflict of interest as the Licensing Officer present, who had written the report, had acted in a professional capacity for one of the interested parties. He stressed that he did not impugn the Officer’s integrity or professionalism but asked that the report should be produced by another Licensing Officer. It was confirmed that prior to his employment at the Council the Officer had once advised the father of one of the people who had made a representation. [name removed] stated that he believed it to be in the interest of all parties that the police should be given a chance to present all their evidence and that his client should likewise be permitted to fully defend himself. He advised that the new date, should the Panel agree to adjourn, should be at least ten working ...