Resolved
See the report of the Licensing Officer (Agenda Item 2) The applicant, [name removed] , attended the meeting accompanied by [name removed] who assisted with translation. Michael Fish, Licensing Officer, stated that the licence had originally been issued under the terms of the Licensing Act 1964 and converted in 2005 following the adoption of the Licensing Act 2003. He advised that Trading Standards had withdrawn their representation as the applicant had verbally agreed to accept the conditions set out by Trading Standards (see Appendix 1.) The applicant agreed that the Licensing Officer’s report was correct. Following questions from the Panel it was confirmed that the premises had voluntarily installed CCTV which was operational 24 hours a day. The Chair expressed reservations about the proposal to sell alcohol from 6 am. Through [name removed] Singh Gulati stated that customer demand had led to the premises wishing to open at 6 am as a newsagent, and that he only asked for the variation to avoid the expense of providing secure covers for the alcohol before 8 am. Simon Jones, Legal Adviser to the Panel, quoted guidance given under Section 182 of the Licensing Act 2003: “Shops stores and supermarkets should normally be free to provide sales of alcohol for consumption off the premises at any times when the retail outlet is open for shopping unless there are good reasons, based on the licensing objectives, for restricting those hours. For example, a limitation may be appropriate following police representation in the case of some shops known to be a focus of disorder and disturbance because youths gather there.” Cllr Mammatt expressed concerns about the very early availability of alcohol close to a school as it could lead to public drinking in the area. She asked if the shop served many children. [name removed] advised that it did, but that they came to the shop on their way to school after 8 am when alcohol was already on sale and that there was no problem with street drinkers in the vicinity. Having fully considered the written and oral representations from the applicant and the written representations from the objectors, and questioned those present, following discussion the Panel came to a two to one majority decision to grant the licence application in full with the addition of the conditions proposed by Trading Standards. Cllr Liz Mammatt remained concerned that street drinkers might be attracted to the premises by the very early start to licensed hours. Given the close proximity of a school Cllr Mammatt believed that the proposed hours would not promote the protection of children from harm licensing objective and so she voted to refuse the application.