Resolved
See the report of the Licensing Officer (Agenda Item 3.) Cllr Tom Bruce was present for this item giving a full Panel of three members. [name removed], who had lodged the review, [name removed] , Premises Licence Holder and [name removed], Counsel for the Quantus Restaurant, attended the meeting along with Philip Bownds from the Council’s Environmental Health Team. Michael Fish, Licensing Officer, advised that the Panel should disregard Appendix F as the representations did not come from recognised interested parties. Both parties agreed that the Licensing Officer’s report was correct. [name removed] described Quantus as having turned his life upside down since its opening. He asked the Panel to consider paragraph 8.1 of the Council’s Statement of Licensing Policy which states that “Licensed premises have a significant potential to adversely impact upon communities through public nuisances that arise from their operation. This Authority wishes to maintain and protect the amenity of residents and businesses from the potential consequence of the operation of a licensed premise whilst balancing this with the recognition of the valuable cultural, social and economic importance that such premises provide.” He added that the Independent Adjudicator had decided that the premises were unsuitable, there was no evidence that the restaurant’s management had taken any noise mitigation measures and as they were neither owners nor leaseholders they were unable to make physical alterations to the premises. [name removed] also stated that the acoustic report commissioned by the restaurant had found maximum average noise levels in the restaurant to be 79dB, just one decibel below that requiring hearing protection in the workplace. [name removed] called for the licence conditions to be modified to stipulate that music could not be heard outside the premises after 7.30 pm, and advised that he was supported by Val Wheedon , who was appointed Noise Tsar for Noisedirect in March 2011. He confirmed that his complaints were in regard to recorded music only. [name removed] advised that Quantus was a small restaurant of forty covers whose customers chose it for its quietness. He described the noise levels as very modest and stated that management were sorry that [name removed] had been distressed by them. He said that music was only played on an iPod docking station and was just background, which is not licensable. [name removed] advised that his clients could not agree to closing at 7.30pm as their livelihood depended on opening in the evening, and reminded the Panel that planning issues could not be considered in a licensing review. He stated that the restaurant would be happy to surrender the recorded music and facilities for dance licence as it was never used, and that speakers had now been removed from the ceiling and the cavities filled in. The iPod dock had been placed in the bar area, ceiling lights were to be fitted with acoustic domes and the following conditions were offered: 1) Alcoholic beverages to be served only to customers taking a meal at the premises. 2) ...