Resolved
Please see report by the Licensing Officer (agenda item 2) The application was heard by Councillors Tom Bruce, Brad Fisher and Darshan Grewal. [name removed] , the solicitor representing the applicant attended the hearing accompanied by [name removed], a manager from Malthurst Ltd. [name removed] , who had submitted a representation against the application attended. The Licensing Officer Michael Fish presented the report and advised that the application had been varied. It now asked for a licence to sell alcohol for consumption off the premises between the hours of 6.00 am and 11.30 pm and late night refreshment between 11.00 pm and 11.30 pm, both seven days a week. As a result the police representation had been withdrawn. The report was agreed to be otherwise correct. [name removed] advised that S176 was not relevant to the application as no representation had been received that would trigger S176. He added that it was not necessary to establish primary use as part of the application although it was necessary to trade under any licence granted. [name removed] suggested that the guidance to the Licensing Act 2003 (the Act) was wrong on this point. Legal Advisor to the Panel, [name removed], stated that the guidance was not law but should be complied with unless there was a very good reason not to and said that the representation by [name removed] addressed potential crime and disorder and so could trigger S176. [name removed] stated that S182 of the Act set out that primary use could be examined but he advised that guidance could not supersede legislation. S17 stated what the applicant must do to obtain a licence and S18 set out the Panel’s role. There was nothing on proving that the primary use was as a garage or otherwise. The previous Act (1964) had set out that if primary use was as a garage a licence could not be issued at all but under the 2003 Act a licence could be issued but not used. Part of [name removed] role was to establish primary use in all 179 premises run by Malthurst and ensure that any that were primarily garages did not sell alcohol. [name removed] suggested the possibility of imposing a condition specifying that primary use data be provided on request; that would avoid the hearing becoming bogged down with unnecessary arguments. [name removed] referred to case law regarding Murco and others and advised that Murco had established that representations engaging the crime & disorder and public safety licensing objectives were sufficient cause to ask questions about trading data. [name removed] disagreed on the ground that Murco had submitted trading data although they had not needed to and the appeal had found the Panel had been right to ask for more because of the police representation. He did not believe that a court would find the representation against his client enough to trigger S176.The police had withdrawn their own representation as they were satisfied with the amended application. Following advice ...