Resolved
Please see the report of the Licensing Officer (agenda item 4). This application was heard by Cllrs Corinna Smart (Chair), Brad Fisher and Liz Mammatt. The hearing was attended by [name removed], counsel, and [name removed], McDonalds Business Manager, on behalf of the applicant. Michael Fish , Licensing Officer, presented the report which was agreed to be correct. Simon Jones, legal adviser to the Panel, asked for clarification regarding the objection from a local resident which was primarily concerned with the sale of alcohol. As no alcohol licence had been applied for the objection was clearly based on a misunderstanding. [name removed] advised that a licensing officer had spoken to the resident to make him aware that no alcohol would be sold; he nonetheless had not withdrawn his objection which still had to be considered on the ground of public nuisance, with regard to litter. [name removed] advised that the application was a very modest one requesting a further hour of trading, with no change to the nature of the business. A nearby Burger King was open 24 hours a day as was a Tesco and a local pub was open until midnight. No representations had been received from ward Councillors, the police or any other responsible authorities and only one resident had objected. That representation was primarily about the sale of alcohol, leaving three lines about litter. [name removed] acknowledged that there was a small stream between the premises and the objector’s house which suffered from considerable littering along its banks. Most of the litter was not connected to McDonalds but more importantly it was on land that was fenced off; McDonalds staff had no access to it. The restaurant’s management were very concerned about littering and as well as providing bins took a very proactive approach, with staff conducting patrols to clear all litter (not just their own packaging) between 07:00 and 08:00, 14:00 and 15:00 and 19:00 and 20:00 seven days a week. A map of the route taken by these patrols was shown to the Panel and it was seen that the route passed close to the objector’s address. [name removed] advised that one extra hour of trading would generate very little extra litter but McDonalds were willing to make a later patrol if required; however the problem of the river bank could not be addressed due to there being no public access. Following questions from the Panel [name removed] advised that the premises had five or six bins inside and outside. Management helped to assist police with the enforcement of the Controlled Drinking Zone in the area and had a very good relationship with the police Safer Neighbourhood Team; there had been local problems with anti-social behaviour but thanks to effective management the restaurant did not suffer from this. The Panel asked for the evening litter patrol to be moved back one hour as it was accepted that it would not be practical for staff to carry out such duties late at night. ...