Apologies for absence were received from Councillor Rajinder Bath and Councillor Samantha Davies. There were no declarations of interest. All members had received written representations in respect of: Agenda Item 3 – 14 Ivanhoe Road Agenda Item 5 – 103 Wentworth Road Agenda Item 9 – 57 Spring Grove Crescent Agenda Item 11 – 12 Meadowbank Gardens There were also two Addendum reports.
Word for word from the decision Hounslow published for this meeting.Source: democraticservices.hounslow.gov.uk
Following a recent site visit it appears that the development has changed and that it is not now a roofed extension and is in a state of flux.
As such it would not be accurate or precise to request that approval be given for the demolition of an extension. The structure currently in place is incomplete and cannot be reasonably described as an extension at this point. It has also not been in place for a long enough period to be considered substantially complete.
As such we respectfully ask that this item is withdrawn from the agenda.
The owner will be questioned as to his future plans with regard to the current structure and the site will be monitored in conjunction with any further complaints.
Agenda Item 9 Pages 93 - 102 57 Spring Grove Crescent, TW3 4DA
Comment by owner
The owner emailed the council on 1st May 2014 stating that there are no kitchen or cooking facilities within the outbuilding. He states that the outbuilding is not being used as a self-contained residential unit nor is it being rented out as one. He states that it is being used as storage and as a communal room for tenants.
Comment by officer
The outbuilding that has been constructed has been built incorporating primary living facilities such as a shower area, toilet and kitchen area. Whilst there wasn’t a cooker in place during our pre-arranged site visit there were clearly high level sockets fitted to the kitchen area and drainage pipes installed. There is also a full bathroom with shower facilities in place. As such it cannot be argued that the layout and provision installed to the outbuilding are ancillary to its use as a class C4 House of Multiple Occupation. As such there are no permitted development rights for the construction of the outbuilding as a non-incidental residential unit and its construction is contrary to the council’s Residential Extension Guidelines.
During a previous unannounced site visit from 18th February 2014, which was accompanied by the Metropolitan Police, full access was not gained to the outbuilding however a photograph was taken of the bathroom facilities from an open window. This photograph shows used bathroom products such as toothpaste, toothbrushes, ear buds, an open make up bag, moisturiser and other beauty
1 products. This arrangement would strongly suggest that the outbuilding was being used as primary residential accommodation and not as a communal room for the tenants. During this visit the officers were able to talk to the residents of the main dwelling. These residents stated that the outbuilding was used by a couple however they had no access to the outbuilding. It is reasonable to inference that tenants of the main dwelling would be able to access an outbuilding that is used as communal and storage space. Their lack of access to the outbuilding strongly suggests an non- incidental usage of the outbuilding and the display of used bathroom and beauty products also suggest an ongoing primary usage of the outbuilding.
This information gathered makes it unlikely and improbable that the outbuilding has not been constructed as a non-incidental residential unit and as such we recommend that the formal enforcement action as prescribed is approved by committee.
The committee is reminded that the owner does have the right of appeal against any enforcement notice served against the property should he maintain that the unauthorised development is acceptable under any of the applicable grounds of appeal under section 174 (2) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended). Any enforcement notice served will not come into effect provided a valid appeal is made beforehand.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.