It was agreed that the planning application at 34 Chiswick Quay be determined by officers under delegated powers. The motion was proposed by Councillor Oulds and seconded by Councillor Lee. Councillors Davies, Oulds, Lee, Lynch, and Todd voted in favour of the motion, whilst Councillor McGregor voted against it. Councillor Hearn abstained from the vote.
Word for word from the decision Hounslow published for this meeting.Source: democraticservices.hounslow.gov.uk
1. Advise of planning applications that members have asked be discussed in public at the Area Forum
2. That members determine whether the application outlined within this report should be
1. determined by members at Planning Committee, or
2. determined by officers under delegated authority
3. That members make relevant comments on the planning issues raised by the applications and that these issues be reported as part of the decision making process
1.0APPLICATIONS
1.1Details of the following planning applications have been made public on the Council website and circulated to members and amenity groups as part of the council’s Pending List, in accordance with the procedure agreed by members at Borough Council on 19 June 2012 for planning decision making. Reference Address Proposal Reason for call in Member 1. 01385/34/P1 34 Chiswick Erection of an external To discuss the planning Councillor Lynch Quay, disabled access lift on the issues relating to the Chiswick, side of a three storey house application further. London, W4 3UR Summary of objections - Chiswick Quay Freeholds Limited has not provided prior consent to the alteration on common land and given a majority of residents have objected, is not minded to do so. - Proposals do not comply with Policies ENV-B.1.1 (New Development), ENV-B.2.2 (Conservation Areas) and IMP.5.2 (Thames Policy Area) of the LBH Unitary Development Plan. - The development would damage the consistent architectural rhythm of the estate - The infill of land surrounding buildings would reduce the prevailing characteristic of spaciousness present within the Grove Park Conservation Area - The development would cause harm to the Grove Park Conservation Area - The development would set a precedent for future development at a largely unaltered estate - The lift shaft would reduce sunlight and daylight received by windows at 16 Chiswick Quay, consequently harming living conditions at this neighbouring property - The development would block views of the Thames from public spaces such as Chiswick Quay, the Thames Path and the river itself where the development would be directly visible - Emergency vehicles would be unable to access the riverside - The applicant has not demonstrated that internal solutions have been completely exhausted and it is suggested that stair lifts have been installed providing a successful alternative elsewhere on the estate – Previously at Number 47 and as recently as in October 2014 at Number 31. - Other properties have also been successfully reconfigured to provide living accommodation at lower levels – For example 7 Chiswick Quay. - Residents assert that only a single floor between the ground and first level is cast concrete, contrary to the 3 concrete floors asserted by the Design and Access Statement. - Bay windows to the sides of 33 and 16 Chiswick Quay are noted as original features and not later additions as asserted by the Design and Access Statement. As such these features are suggested not to constitute precedent for the development. Officer Comments
The proposed application is recommended for refusal for the following reasons:
It is felt that the lift shaft would appear incongruous to the dwelling by means of its location and height which would be of detriment of the form of the building contrary to Policy ENV-B.1.1 of the Unitary Development Plan
Further to this, it is noted that Chiswick Quay is of distinct architectural merit due to its uniformity and intentionally maintains a largely unaltered form
The location and height of the proposed development would also reduce a prevailing character of spaciousness referenced within the Grove Park Conservation Area Character Appraisal approved by Planning Committee in January 2006
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.