Resolved
Please see the report of the Licensing Officer (agenda item 2). This application was heard by Cllrs Shantanu Rajawat (Chair), Samia Chaudhary and Tina Howe. The applicant was represented by [name removed] and [name removed] , directors of An Business Ltd and [name removed] , solicitor. [name removed], Blenheim Centre manager and [name removed] attended as witnesses. Several other persons attended to speak to their representations. Lewis Aldous, Licensing Manager presented the report which was agreed to be correct. [name removed], Reflexion Building Manager, spoke for the objectors. He stated that residents found the possibility of the premises gaining an alcohol licence running until 1:00 am to be unacceptable. They understood that the current licence ran until 1:00 am but felt that the great expansion in the size of the premises was a very significant change to the nature of the business. A larger clientele would mean longer dispersal times at closing and it was highly likely that the crowds would be a source of anti-social behaviour (ASB) or even crime. The proposed addition of a mezzanine floor would cause noise nuisance to flats above and any soundproofing would be negated by doors being opened to the outside seating area. The latter was in line with the entrance to the flats, which would place drinkers close to families with young children passing by. The building’s concierge service had documentation of a number of complaints about late night parties. The restaurant had had to be asked repeatedly to turn the music down at each event. Noise nuisance was exacerbated by the acoustics of the Blenheim Centre, which caused sound to echo around the building. There were further concerns about smokers gathering in the outside seating area and littering. There were no measures proposed to promote the public safety licensing objective, a particular concern given that the complex contained 334 apartments. [name removed] expressed concern that the late night refreshment licence would mean people using the outside area until the early hours of the morning, causing noise nuisance and possibly ASB and he was also worried about cooking odours permeating the building. Following questions from the Panel [name removed] confirmed that he managed the building and was not the owner. He had no evidence of previous noise nuisance but could ask the concierge service to supply it if needed; there had been two incidents, not enough, he felt, to justify calling a review of the premises licence but he was very concerned that expansion of the restaurant would make things much worse. Further concerns were raised by other persons present, some of whom had been unaware that the premises were already licensed. There were fears that noise and ASB would escalate causing tenants to move out; in such circumstances they would be difficult to replace, devaluing the block. People, particularly women, children and the elderly, could feel threatened by drinkers in the outside area, or hanging around at closing time. [name removed] spoke for the applicants. ...