Resolved
Please see the report by the Director of Regeneration, Economic Development and Environment (agenda item 2). This item was heard by Cllrs Tony Louki (Chair), Adrian Lee and John Todd. The applicant, [name removed], attended accompanied by licensing agent [name removed] . Ward Councillor Gurpal Virdi attended to speak to his representation. Council Licensing Manager Lewis Aldous advised that the applicant had accepted all ten of [name removed] proposed conditions (pages 15 and 16) but had not accepted the change to the commencement time from 08:00 to 11:00; following negotiation both parties had agreed that licensed hours would commence at 09:30. [name removed] had withdrawn his representation as a result. The report was presented by Lewis Aldous. He advised that following his acceptance of [name removed] proposed conditions the applicant had agreed to amend the licensed hours applied for from 08:00 until 23:00 to 09:30 until 23:00 Monday to Sunday. The report was agreed to be otherwise correct. Cllr Virdi advised that he had made his representation on the grounds of the prevention of crime & disorder, public safety and public nuisance licensing objectives. Drugs and alcohol and the associated crime and anti-social behaviour (ASB) were serious concerns in Cranford; there were large numbers of street drinkers, particularly in the summer months. There were two licensed restaurants, a betting shop and a pub in the vicinity and another off-licence next door to the applicant’s business, all of which Cllr Virdi felt were contributing to problems. Street drinkers congregated in a nearby subway, which they also used as a toilet, as well as causing problems in the public library by demanding to use the toilets there. People, especially children, avoided the subway because of the smell; guests at the nearby hotel and attendees of the British Airways training centre that attracted people from all over the world were given a very poor impression of the area. There was also a mosque nearby. The shop would increase the workload of the police and there was no local need for it. The Panel asked about the relevance of the mosque being nearby and Cllr Virdi advised that worshippers challenged street drinkers, resulting in friction. Incidents had been reported to police. He believed that an additional off-licence would lead to an increase in ASB; there was nothing to indicate this shop would be different. Cllr Virdi did not have a moral objection to alcohol sales but did feel that the shop would increase ASB by further encouraging street drinkers to congregate. He was unable to supply evidence that customers of the pub and restaurants contributed to ASB in the area in any way. Legal adviser to the Panel Richard Gruet stated that any need or otherwise for the premises was a commercial consideration and not something the Licensing Panel was empowered to decide; Cllr Virdi stood by his objection. He did not have hard evidence that the application would lead to increased crime and ASB if granted but believed there was a direct and ...