Resolved
Please see the report by the Director of Regeneration, Economic Development and Environment (agenda item 3). This item was heard by Cllrs Tina Howe, Mukesh Malhotra and Shantanu Rajawat (Chair). The applicant, [name removed], attended accompanied by [name removed] and [name removed], managers of the club and [name removed] , club captain. [name removed] and [name removed] attended to speak to their representations and act as spokespersons for the objectors. [name removed] , [name removed] and [name removed], local residents who had submitted objections, also attended. The report was presented by Council Licensing Manager Lewis Aldous. The report was agreed to be correct. [name removed] advised that the primary concern of the objectors was public nuisance engendered by noise, particularly late on Friday and Saturday nights. Neighbours had experienced excessive noise levels from the venue when it had hosted events in the past and whilst they were prepared to tolerate one or two such events a year a regular business caused great concern. Residents were also worried about anti-social behaviour (ASB) from people leaving late at night. There were a lot of children and young families in the area and there were public safety concerns; there had been issues with drunks in the past. [name removed] stated that there were three schools close by and additional traffic created by the club could pose a safety risk. Residents were very supportive of the sports club but not of a late night alcohol licence which they felt contradicted the sporting ethos of the club. There were a lot of young people who used the facilities and the presence of a bar would send the wrong message and may even encourage underage drinking. Regarding noise nuisance there were no trees, hedge, or other barrier to buffer sound between the premises and nearby homes, only a concrete wall which could actually exacerbate the problem. Even when the club kept its doors closed noise levels could be very disturbing as sound carried into neighbouring homes very clearly; there were several families with young children who needed to be in bed by 8 pm and they would be kept awake until after midnight if the licence was granted. There had been incidents of shouting and swearing in the street from drunks, including one occasion when police had to be called following an assault. There was little public transport and so there was also a worry that people may be tempted to drive after drinking as well as the inevitable increase in late night traffic. Questioned by the Panel, [name removed] stated that she was only aware of one incident when the police had been called but had seen and heard drunken ASB in the street on occasion and residents were deeply worried that what was a close, family friendly community could be damaged by noise and ASB if the club sold alcohol and played music until late at night. She had not called the police ...