a) That planning permission for planning application 00371/74/P5 for the extension of a basement floor incorporating a rear lightwell with a glass balustrade and erection of a side roof extension to the house at 74 Dukes Avenue, Chiswick be refused on the following grounds: i) That the overly large basement and lightwells together, particularly the one in the rear garden, would fail to respect the character and appearance of the site and the area and are not considered to be subservient additions to the property in line with the Local Plan, specifically SC7 point (g). That the overall scale of the basement is considered to require excessive amounts of spoil to be removed from the site, which would take a considerable amount of time and excavation. ii) That this construction is likely to result in significant disturbance of neighbours’ amenity in relation to noise and pollution and there would be significant impact from traffic movements on the site while the spoil is removed and the basement constructed. b) That the Planning Committee recommend that a planning policy, specifically for basements be produced as soon as possible.
Word for word from the decision Hounslow published for this meeting.Source: democraticservices.hounslow.gov.uk
1.1The application proposes to create a basement under the footprint of the house and under part of the rear garden, with one rear lightwell along with the erection of a side roof extension.
1.2Given the scale and design of the proposal, it is considered that no harm would be caused to neighbouring amenities. The proposed rear lightwell would not be visible from the street or appear incongruous in its context, preserving the character of the streetscene.
1.3The application was submitted to Planning Committee on 04 August 2016 where Members expressed concerns about the impact of the extension on neighbouring trees, the size of the proposed basement in respect to the house and the reason why amendments have not been asked on the current application. It was decided to defer the application to allow more information to be presented in order to make an informed decision. The full report that was submitted to the 04 August 2016 Planning Committee is attached as Appendix A. 1.4 The application is recommended for approval.
2.0RESPONSES TO REASON FOR DEFERRAL
Changes from the deferred application
2.1There have been no changes to the proposed drawings or relevant policy since the application was deferred in August 2016. As such, the principle of the development, its appearance and the effect on neighbours which were assessed in the original Committee report (attached as Appendix A) are still pertinent.
Impact of the proposal on neighbouring trees
2.2Point 6.10 of the original Committee report (attached as Appendix A) indicates that the application included an arboricultural report and tree protection plan prepared by Brian G. Crane & Associates. This report indicates that one small cherry tree would need to be removed from the rear garden of the house in order to allow the basement excavation. The loss of this tree is not considered detrimental to the appearance of the area and therefore is deemed appropriate.
2.3The report also concludes that all other trees within the site and in neighbouring properties would be retained. This includes a Magnolia Tree and a Silver Birch tree located at No. 76 Dukes Avenue. The report further includes appropriate mitigation measures that would be required in order to avoid harm to existing trees.
2.4It is worth noting that the property is not located within a Conservation Area and that there is no Tree Protection Order in any of the adjacent trees. An application requiring the imposition of a Tree Preservation Order on a Silver Birch tree located at No. 76 Dukes Avenue has been received and is currently pending consideration.
2.5Based on the information provided with the application, the proposal is not considered to alter the visual amenity provided by trees in the area.
The size of the extension compared to the house and existing basement
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.