RESOLVED (a)that with effect from 2005, the annual appraisal process be concluded in May instead of February; and (b)that the following appraisal score bands and their corresponding links to incremental progression be approved with effect from the May, 2005 appraisals:- Scores Band (increments) 0% - less than 40% 0 40% - less than 50% 1 50% - less than 60% 2 60% - less than 70% 3 70% - 100% 4
Word for word from the decision Huntingdonshire published for this meeting.Source: democracy.huntingdonshire.gov.uk
2.1The appraisal scheme scores an employee’s performance on his/her key performance areas. This produces an overall percentage score which places the employee in a scoring band as follows:
Scores Band 0% - 20% 0 over 20% - 40% 1 over 40% - 60% 2 over 60% - 80% 3 over 80% - 100% 4
A link is then applied to the number of increments by which the employee progresses through his/her grade.
2.2For many years, the average appraisal percentage has been higher than the expected 50% - in the last full year of analysis available (2001) it was 59.3%, and this is unlikely to have changed in the subsequent years. This has meant the whole distribution has been skewed, giving far more “3” scores than expected. However, this is not necessarily wrong, if it can be demonstrated that the organisation as a whole is performing well and meeting its challenging objectives.
2.3However, the main employee and management criticism of our current arrangements, which has prevailed since 1989, is the “2” band which, although is a similar width to all other bands, in practice covers a wide variation in actual performance because of the way the appraisal scoring mechanism works. This mechanism also makes it almost impossible for someone to score a “0” on performance alone. 2.4 The Balanced Scorecard is a tool to prioritise objectives, measure performance and target resources. As an integral piece of our performance management framework, it will help the operation of the Council and its services to be effectively monitored, and the information used will improve the allocation of resources in order to develop services and increase customer satisfaction. The framework will provide for performance measures to be cascaded to individual employees’ key performance areas. Thus, in order to ensure that the information and data are available to appraise an employee’s performance, the timing of the appraisal will need to be changed.
3. PROPOSALS FOR CHANGE
3.1For the appraisal score bands and the link to incremental progression, it is considered that the best option is to alter the score bands. There are several permutations, but the Management Team considers the following produces the best outcome for everyone:
Scores Band 0% - 40% 0 over 40% - 50% 1 over 50% - 60% 2 over 60% - 70% 3 over 70% - 100% 4
in that it increases the incentive for employees to achieve 4 increments (if this had applied in 2001, there would have been 29 employees achieving this), and the previous “2” band is split . Also, the distribution of scores will be a better match to the expected normal distribution. There will, however, still be the temptation for appraisers to manipulate the scores for individual KPA’s to achieve a desired result, except that KPA’s will be better able to be scored against results achieved because of the introduction of the performance management framework and Balanced Scorecard.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.