Resolved
RESOLVED (a) Erection of Poultry Unit, Lodge Farm, Low Road, Little Stukeley – 06/00240/FUL (Councillors M Monk, The Stukeleys Parish Council and M Shellens, Brampton Parish Council addressed the Panel on the application). that the application be refused for the following reasons:- ¨ the Environmental Statement is inaccurate and contains inadequate information to enable a complete assessment to be made of the environmental effects of the proposal. In particular – § the Environmental Statement lacks a robust and detailed assessment of the potential effects of the facility on the water environment. Without this it is not possible to assess whether the proposal would result in an unacceptable risk of pollution and would have an unacceptable effect on the Port Holme SSSI/SAC which relies upon seasonal flooding. It is unclear therefore whether the proposal accords with advice contained within Planning Policy Statement 23 (Pollution) and Planning Policy Statement 9 (Nature Conservation) and policies P1/2, P7/2 and P7/8 in the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Structure Plan, 2003, policies En22 and En23 in the Huntingdonshire Local Plan, 1995 and policies G4 and G7 in the Local Development Framework Core Strategy, 2006; § the Environmental Statement has not adequately assessed the effect of odour. The odour model and meteorological data which have been used are inappropriate and it is likely that they will have under-predicted the effect of emissions from the proposal. It is not therefore possible to reach any conclusions regarding the effect that the proposal would have on amenity, including the effects experienced by users of the public rights of way network and visitors to the racecourse which is an important local tourist facility and whether the proposal complies with policy P8/9 in the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Structure Plan, 2003, policy R15 in the Huntingdonshire Local Plan, 1995 and policies B4 and T3 in the Local Development Framework Core Strategy; § the Environmental Statement has not adequately assessed the effect of ammonia emissions. The model which has been used to predict ammonia levels has assumed incorrect emissions from the buildings and has used inappropriate meteorological data and it is therefore likely that the model under predicts the effects of the emissions. It is not therefore possible to reach any conclusions regarding the effect that the proposal would have on the Brampton SSSI and therefore whether the proposal complies with advice contained within Planning Policy Statement 9 (Nature Conservation) and policies P1/2, P7/2 and P7/8 in the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Structure Plan 2003, policies En22 and En23 in the Huntingdonshire Local Plan and policies G4 and G7 in the Local Development Framework Strategy; § the Environmental Statement has not adequately assessed ... view the full minutes text for item 19.