CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Huntingdonshire District Council

DEVELOPMENT CONTROL

Refused Planning 7 papers

Development Control Panel: changed to Development Management Panel - May 2009 refused this item on Monday 19 June 2006. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item19

Resolved

RESOLVED (a) Erection of Poultry Unit, Lodge Farm, Low Road, Little Stukeley – 06/00240/FUL (Councillors M Monk, The Stukeleys Parish Council and M Shellens, Brampton Parish Council addressed the Panel on the application). that the application be refused for the following reasons:- ¨ the Environmental Statement is inaccurate and contains inadequate information to enable a complete assessment to be made of the environmental effects of the proposal. In particular – § the Environmental Statement lacks a robust and detailed assessment of the potential effects of the facility on the water environment. Without this it is not possible to assess whether the proposal would result in an unacceptable risk of pollution and would have an unacceptable effect on the Port Holme SSSI/SAC which relies upon seasonal flooding. It is unclear therefore whether the proposal accords with advice contained within Planning Policy Statement 23 (Pollution) and Planning Policy Statement 9 (Nature Conservation) and policies P1/2, P7/2 and P7/8 in the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Structure Plan, 2003, policies En22 and En23 in the Huntingdonshire Local Plan, 1995 and policies G4 and G7 in the Local Development Framework Core Strategy, 2006; § the Environmental Statement has not adequately assessed the effect of odour. The odour model and meteorological data which have been used are inappropriate and it is likely that they will have under-predicted the effect of emissions from the proposal. It is not therefore possible to reach any conclusions regarding the effect that the proposal would have on amenity, including the effects experienced by users of the public rights of way network and visitors to the racecourse which is an important local tourist facility and whether the proposal complies with policy P8/9 in the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Structure Plan, 2003, policy R15 in the Huntingdonshire Local Plan, 1995 and policies B4 and T3 in the Local Development Framework Core Strategy; § the Environmental Statement has not adequately assessed the effect of ammonia emissions. The model which has been used to predict ammonia levels has assumed incorrect emissions from the buildings and has used inappropriate meteorological data and it is therefore likely that the model under predicts the effects of the emissions. It is not therefore possible to reach any conclusions regarding the effect that the proposal would have on the Brampton SSSI and therefore whether the proposal complies with advice contained within Planning Policy Statement 9 (Nature Conservation) and policies P1/2, P7/2 and P7/8 in the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Structure Plan 2003, policies En22 and En23 in the Huntingdonshire Local Plan and policies G4 and G7 in the Local Development Framework Strategy; § the Environmental Statement has not adequately assessed ... view the full minutes text for item 19.
Word for word from the decision Huntingdonshire published for this meeting. Source: democracy.huntingdonshire.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Huntingdonshire's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Control Panel: changed to Development Management Panel - May 2009

AGENDA ITEM NO.

DEVELOPMENT CONTROL PANEL 19 JUNE 2006

APPLICATIONS REQUIRING REFERENCE TO DEVELOPMENT CONTROL PANEL (Reports by Development Control Manager)

Case No: 0503400FUL (FULL PLANNING APPLICATION)

Proposal: ERECTION OF 22 FLATS

Location: 23 NORTH ROAD PE27 5PR

Applicant: CRESTEL HOMES LTD

Grid Ref: 531172 271595

Date of Registration: 21.11.2005

Parish: ST IVES

RECOMMENDATION - APPROVE

1. DESCRIPTION OF SITE AND APPLICATION

1.1Proposed erection of 22 flats following demolition of existing dwellinghouse and warehouse building.

1.2This is a site of 0.27ha located on south side of North Road and comprising a warehouse building, last used on a temporary basis for car sales and a detached two storey dwelling house. The site is within the built-up area of the Town but outside the defined Town Centre. It abuts the St Ives Conservation Area.

1.3The proposal is to demolish the two buildings and to erect a comprehensive scheme of 22 flats contained in 5 mainly 2 storey blocks around a square layout with dwellings fronting North Road and Nicholas lane. 22 car parking spaces (inc 2 disabled spaces) are provided. This is an amendment to the initial submission of 24 flats.

2. NATIONAL GUIDANCE

2.1PPS1 - ‘Delivering Sustainable Development’ (2005)

2.2PPG3 - ‘Housing’ (2000)

2.3PPG15 - ‘Planning and the Historic Environment’ (1994)

3. PLANNING POLICIES

3.1Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Structure Plan 2003 (CS)

• P1/1 – Approach to development, • P1/3 – Sustainable design in built development. • P6/1 – Development related provision • P6/3 – Flood defence

3.2Huntingdonshire Local Plan 1995 as altered by the Local Plan Alteration 2002 (HLP)

• STR1 – settlement hierarchy • HL5 - good design and layout • HL6 – housing densities • HL7 – re-using brownfield land and buildings • R7 – play space provision standards in new housing schemes. • En5 – Conservation Areas Character • H31 - Residential privacy and amenity standards • AH4 – site targets for affordable housing • CS9 – Flood water management • OB1 - Nature and scale of Obligations (for planning obligations)

3.3Emerging Core Strategy 2006 (eCS)

• P5 – Settlement hierarchy – Market Towns • P10 – Flood Risk • P11 – Infrastructure requirements • B1 – Design Quality • B2 – street scene • B4 – Amenity • B8 – Conservation Areas • H1 – location of housing development • H2 – Housing density • H6 – Affordable housing

4. PLANNING HISTORY

4.1Commercial development approvals for the warehouse site and a refusal for demolition of the house.

4.2A previous scheme of 8 dwellings and 16 flats was refused on design grounds with the subsequent appeal being dismissed. The Inspector supported all the design objections raised by the LPA in the grounds of appeal and added some in terms of amenity/living conditions for occupants.

5. CONSULTATIONS

5.1St Ives Town Council – OBJECTION (Copy attached).

5.2Local Highways Authority – made several comments concerning the site layout and access including reference to increasing North Road to a 5.5m carriageway to facilitate guided bus route. All aspects bar the road widening have been incorporated into amendments. It is entirely unreasonable and unjustified for this request. There are no published plans for road widening and case law indicates that requests on this basis cannot be supported.

5.3County Fire and Rescue Service - request fire hydrants.

2 5.4 Environmental Health Officer – recommends a scheme for decontamination.

5.5Environment Agency – NO OBJECTION subject to minimum floor levels and no ground raising. There were issues on flood risk assessment but following discussions these have been resolved – it was question of footprint over and above previous refused scheme – the footprint is no greater and in fact is less!

5.6Education – request contribution to education infrastructure of £2,700:00 per dwelling of two or more bedrooms.

6. REPRESENTATIONS

6.1Three representations relating to traffic implications including widening of North Road, loss of amenity, design unacceptable.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
0503400FULReport 24 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
0601073OUTReport 20 KB Download
PDF
0601124 jun06Report 23 KB Download
PDF
0601170 jun06Report 23 KB Download
PDF
0601179OUTReport 19 KB Download
PDF
0601330FULReport 18 KB Download
PDF
DEVELOPMENT CONTROLReport 70 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

15 of 17 attended
MM
Councillor Mrs Madhabi BanerjeeMember, present
MB
Councillor Mrs Barbara Elizabeth BoddingtonMember, present
PL
Councillor Peter Leonard Ernest BucknellMember, present
ER
Councillor Eric Richard ButlerMember, present
SC
Councillor Steve CriswellMember, present
DB
Councillor Douglas Bernard DewVice-Chair, present
PJ
Councillor Peter James Downes OBEMember, present
JD
Councillor Jeff DuttonMember, present
JA
Councillor John Ackerly Penhall EddyMember, apologies
JD
Councillor James Dudley FellMember, present
CR
Councillor Colin Richard HyamsMember, present
PG
Councillor Peter Gerald MitchellChair, present

All 17 on the meeting page

On this subject at Huntingdonshire

Search all
  1. DEVELOPMENT CONTROLThis decision
  2. The transformation from development control to development management - changes to job titlesDecided
  3. Development Control PanelApproved
  4. Development controlApproved
  5. Development controlApproved
  6. Proposed service enhancements - the transformation from development control to development managementDecided

More from Huntingdonshire Development Control Panel: changed to Development Management Panel - May 2009

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
20 Apr 2009 Development controlRESOLVED (a) Erection of four floodlight columns and floodlights, informal open space, north-east of 46 High Street ,... Approved Open
16 Mar 2009 Development controlRESOLVED (a) Removal of Condition 9 of Reserved Matters Approval 07/02174/REM to allow floodlighting, land at Gifford... Approved Open
16 Mar 2009 S106 agreement advisory groupRESOLVED that Councillor J S Watt be appointed to the vacancy in the membership of the Section 106 Agreement Advisory... Agreed Open
16 Mar 2009 Exclusion of press and publicRESOLVED that the public be excluded from the meeting because the business to be transacted contains exempt informati... Agreed Open
16 Mar 2009 Change of use to gypsy site without planning permission, land 800 metres east of woodwalton nature reserve and south of harpers drove, ramsey heights, huntingdon - 09/00038/encaraRESOLVED that the approach outlined in the report now submitted be endorsed, namely the issuing of an enforcement not... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies