CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Huntingdonshire District Council

DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT

Refused Committee 2 papers

Development Management Panel (Decommissioned 18/05/2016) refused this item on Monday 19 March 2012. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item64

Resolved

RESOLVED in the light of the personal and prejudicial interests declared by the Chairman, Councillor D B Dew, Councillor P L E Bucknell, Vice-Chairman acted as Chairman of the Panel for the ensuing application. Councillor P L E Bucknell in the Chair. (a) Erection of 2 proposed “Eco-Homes”, to be constructed to level 5, land north of Hillside View, Somersham Road, St. Ives – 12/00210/FUL (See Minute No. 63 for Members’ interests.) (Councillor K Reynolds, applicant addressed the Panel on the application.) that the application be refused for the following reasons:- there is no essential functional rural need to justify the provision of the proposed dwellings within this countryside location. The sustainability credentials of the design of the proposed dwellings combined with the cessation of the existing storage use of the site would fail to outweigh the inherently unsustainable location of the site for housing where opportunities to make necessary journeys by foot, cycle or public transport are severely limited and where future occupiers would be wholly reliant on private transport to access nearly all services, employment and facilities. As such the proposal would constitute an unsustainable form of residential development and would lead to an unjustifiable increase in new housing development within the countryside which would be incongruous in this location and detrimental to the rural character and appearance of the countryside which should be preserved for its own sake. For these reasons, the proposal would be contrary to Planning Policy Statement Nos 1, 3, and 7 and policies ENV7 and SS1 of the East of England Plan – Revision to the Regional Spatial Strategy, May 2008, policies En25, H23 and En17 of the Huntingdonshire Local Plan, 1995, policies CS1 and CS3 of the adopted Huntingdonshire Local Development Framework Core Strategy 2009 and policies E1, E8 and P7 of the Proposed Submission 2010. Councillor D B Dew in the Chair (b) Demolition of existing entrance and proposed extension to include new entrance, party room, office, restaurant and fitness suite for St. Ives Leisure Centre, St. Ivo Recreation Centre, Westwood Road, St. Ives – 12/00019/FUL (Councillor J J Dutton declared a personal interest in the application as a Member of the District Council’s Leisure Forum.) ([name removed], objector and [name removed], applicant addressed the Panel on the application.) that the recommendation be approved subject to conditions to be determined by the Head of Planning Services to include those listed in paragraph 8 of the report now submitted to include time limit (3 years), material samples and hard and soft landscaping. (c) Residential development with access road, open space and balancing pond, including demolition of existing buildings, Houghton Grange, Houghton ... view the full minutes text for item 64.
Word for word from the decision Huntingdonshire published for this meeting. Source: democracy.huntingdonshire.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Huntingdonshire's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Management Panel (Decommissioned 18/05/2016)

DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT PANEL 19 MARCH 2012

Case No: 1200210FUL (FULL PLANNING APPLICATION)

Proposal: ERECTION OF 2 PROPOSED 'ECO HOMES' - TO BE CONSTRUCTED TO LEVEL 5

Location: LAND NORTH OF HILLSIDE VIEW SOMERSHAM ROAD ST IVES

Applicant: MR AND MRS K REYNOLDS

Grid Ref: 532368 273447

Date of Registration: 06.02.2012

Parish: HOLYWELL-CUM-NEEDINGWORTH

RECOMMENDATION - REFUSAL

1. DESCRIPTION OF SITE AND APPLICATION

1.1This application is presented to the Panel because one of the applicants, [name removed], is a Member of the District Council. It follows a proposal for two ‘eco houses’ designed to achieve Level 4 of the Code for Sustainable Homes (CSH), submitted under ref. 1101038FUL that was refused planning permission by the Panel at the meeting held on 19th September 2011.

1.2The Panel will recall that the application site is located on the eastern side of Somersham Road, on rising ground approximately 300m north-east of St Ives and is currently in use – albeit unauthorised - for the storage and repair of vehicles from a small workshop that stands close to the southern boundary.

1.3The authorised use of the site is for storage and there is an extant planning permission for the erection of a large 510 square metre storage building for B8 storage use, approved in September 2009, which has yet to be implemented reportedly because there are vacant unit in St Ives and reportedly because the site remains unsold.

1.4As with the previous refused application, planning permission is sought for the erection of two dwellings, described as ‘eco houses’ from the Potton Zenit range, that would be served by a new 5m wide vehicle access constructed in the centre of the site frontage. Each dwelling would have a footprint of approx. 10.4m x 11.5m at their maximum extents and a ridge height of approx. 7.4m. 2 vehicle parking spaces per dwelling are proposed along with cycle parking. Additional soft landscaping is proposed.

1.5The submitted drawings are identical to those submitted with the previous application, save for the Proposed Site Layout Plan, which has been revised to delete the proposed wind turbine (which would have been the subject of a separate application) and to include a note reporting to achieve a higher rating of the Code for Sustainable Homes (CSH) of Level 5.

1.6The applicants’ agent has submitted an addendum to the planning statement, responding to the reasons for the refusal of the previous application. It gives a commentary on the issue of sustainability and reiterates much of the information provided with the refused application of 2011, such as the proposed dwelling types have a high thermal performance, will incorporate solar PV, ground source heat pumps, rainwater harvesting systems, electric vehicle charging points and possibly a reed bed sewerage system.

2. NATIONAL GUIDANCE

2.1PPS1 – Delivering Sustainable Development (2005) contains advice on the operation of the plan-led system.

2.2PPS3: “Housing” (2011) sets out how the planning system supports the growth in housing completions needed in England.

2.3PPS7: “Sustainable Development in Rural Areas” (2004) sets out the Government's planning policies for rural areas, including country towns and villages and the wider, largely undeveloped countryside up to the fringes of larger urban areas.

2.4PPG13: “Transport” (2011) sets out the objectives to integrate planning and transport at the national, strategic and local level and to promote more sustainable transport choices both for carrying people and for moving freight.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
1200210FULReport 16 MB DownloadRead as text
PDF
DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENTReport 11 MB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
62MINUTESOn the agenda
64DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENTThis decision
65APPEAL DECISIONSOn the agenda

Who was there

18 of 21 attended
MB
Councillor Mrs Barbara Elizabeth BoddingtonMember, present
PL
Councillor Peter Leonard Ernest BucknellVice-Chair, present
GJ
Councillor Graham John BullMember, present
ER
Councillor Eric Richard ButlerMember, present
BS
Councillor Barry Stephen ChapmanMember, present
WT
Councillor William Terence CloughMember, present
IJ
Councillor Ian James CurtisMember, present
JW
Councillor John Winston DaviesMember, present
DB
Councillor Douglas Bernard DewChair, present
JD
Councillor Jeff DuttonMember, present
RS
Councillor Rodney Samuel FarrerMember, present
NG
Councillor Nick GuyattMember, present

All 21 on the meeting page

On this subject at Huntingdonshire

Search all
  1. DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENTThis decision
  2. Application requiring reference to the development management committee - change of use of site to coach depot and workshop and erection of security fencing - wansford railway station, old great north road, stibbington, peterborough - 25/01775/fulDecided
  3. Development management - outline planning application with all matters reserved except for site access for construction of storage and distribution (use class b8), general employment (use class b2), bus depot (sui generis) floorspace with aApproved
  4. Application requiring reference to development management committee - two-storey extension and refurbishment of leisure centre to include new swimming pools, fitness suites, the relocation of an artificial pitch, new racket courts, car parkApproved
  5. Application requiring reference to the development management committee - outline application with all matters reserved except for access via peterborough road for the demolition of 107 peterborough road, and the development of up to 185 dwDecided
  6. Application requiring reference to the development management committee - proposed 2 no. replacement dwellings and 1 no. detached double garage - 3 sheepwalk cottages, oundle road, elton, peterborough - 25/01436/fulDecided

More from Huntingdonshire Development Management Panel (Decommissioned 18/05/2016)

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
18 Apr 2016 The use of land as a private gypsy and traveller caravan site consisting of 4 pitches each of which would comprise of 1 No. Mobile home, 1 No. Touring caravan, one small amenity building, hardstandings, foul drainage; creation of new access and track way - Kym Stables, Kimbolton Road, Hail Weston.RESOLVED that the application be approved subject to conditions set out in section 8 of the December 2014 report but ... Approved Open
18 Apr 2016 Proposed Amendment to the Scheme of Delegation in relation to the making and confirming Tree Preservation Orders. Objection to Tree Preservation Order L/TPO/381 - 15 Hunts End, Buckden.RESOLVED that the contents of the report be noted and the Scheme of Delegation amended as follows: (a) the Head of De... Noted Open
18 Apr 2016 Appeal decisionsRESOLVED that the contents of the report be noted. Noted Open
14 Mar 2016 Removal of Condition 3 of Planning Permission 15/00417/FUL, variation of Condition 4 for hours of Cafe opening to be from 7:00 a.m.RESOLVED that, the application be approved and the Planning Service Manager (Development Management) be authorised to... Approved Open
14 Mar 2016 Appeal decisionsRESOLVED that the contents of the report be noted. Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies