Resolved
RESOLVED that the application be refused for the following reasons: 1. The application site comprises agricultural land to the west of the built up area of Ramsey Market Town. In addition, the site is not allocated for development within the Huntingdonshire Local Plan 1995, Alteration 2002 or the Huntingdonshire Core Strategy 2009, and as such it is considered to be in the countryside for the purposes of these plans. Being within the countryside, development of the site is contrary to policies H23 and En17 and CS3 of the Huntingdonshire Local Plan 1995, Policy CS3 the Huntingdonshire Core Strategy 2009 and policy LP8 of the Draft Local Plan to 2036. Further the Local Planning Authority consider that there are no material consideration that indicate that the application should be approved as a departure from the Development Plan. 2. It is accepted (regardless of whether the development was to deliver 40% affordable housing) that the delivery of market housing and the financial benefits attributed to construction spend, future resident spend and future local tax receipts would provide moderate social and economic gains. Notwithstanding this, the proposal, when assessed against the three dimensions of sustainable development fails to deliver sustainable development because it fails to fulfil the environmental dimension for a number of reasons: - Ramsey is relatively remote as it lies off the main road network and this restricts the opportunities for sustainable development; - That the site has limited sustainable access to local employment opportunities, services and facilities; - That the proposal fails to prioritise use of previously developed land, being a wholly unallocated greenfield site; - That the proposal is over intensive for an edge of town development with little variation across the site and devoid of individual character areas that would contribute to place making and an attractive built environment; - That little, if any thought has been given as to how the scheme will integrate into the surrounding rural landscape and positively relate to the existing built-up area to the east; - That it has not been demonstrated that the grant of planning permission would not result in the destruction of remains that would otherwise justify preservation in situ if the planning permission is ultimately implemented; - That in the absence of a signed S106 it would fail to deliver the required infrastructure and social benefits (affordable housing, a highway mitigation package, outdoor sport provision, the cost of maintaining open space and a wheeled bins contribution for refuse, recycling and ... view the full minutes text for item 45.