CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Huntingdonshire District Council
Development Management Committee, Monday 15 April 2019 at 6.00pm

Erection of 7 No. dwellinghouses and associated works following demolition of existing buildings - Land at Corner of Thrapston Road and Malting Lane, Ellington, PE28 0AA - 18/02756/FUL

Refused Committee 1 paper

Development Management Committee refused this item on Monday 15 April 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item96e

Resolved

RESOLVED that the application be refused because the development would, due to its incongruous layout, design detail, proportions, form and the inappropriate extent of the domestication of this prominent site (as set out in the report) fail to recognise the setting and character of the settlement and surrounding area, fail to create a well-designed place and would detract from the character and appearance of the area and harm the setting of the adjacent conservation area and the setting of the Grade II listed building, Grove Cottage. The proposal is therefore considered to fail to comply with the policies En2, En9, En25 of the Local Plan 1995, CS1 of the Adopted Core Strategy 2009, HL5 of the Local Plan Alteration and policies LP2, LP10c, LP12, LP13 (parts a, b, c and m) and LP18 and LP36 of Huntingdonshire's Local Plan to 2036: Proposed Submission 2017 (as amended March 2018 for submission) and the Place Making principles set out in Chapter 3 of the HDC Design Guide SPD 2017 (pages 56, 68 and 95) and implementation questions set out in Chapter 4 (Scenario Two infill and small groups – pages 218-222) of Huntingdonshire Design Guide 2017. The policies and guidance are consistent with the emphasis in the National Planning Policy Framework on the importance of good design and the protection of local distinctiveness and conserving and enhancing the historic environment and the requirements of S.66 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 to have special regard to the desirability of preserving the setting of a listed building. At 8.05pm the meeting was adjourned. At 8.14pm the meeting resumed.
Word for word from the decision Huntingdonshire published for this meeting. Source: democracy.huntingdonshire.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Huntingdonshire's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Management Committee

DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE 15 APRIL 2019

Case No: 18/02756/FUL (FULL PLANNING APPLICATION)

Proposal: ERECTION OF 7 NO. DWELLINGHOUSES AND ASSOCIATED WORKS FOLLOWING DEMOLITION OF EXISTING BUILDINGS

Location: LAND AT CORNER OF THRAPSTON ROAD AND MALTING LANE ELLINGTON PE28 0AA

Applicant: MR R BURROW

Grid Ref: 516178 271968

Date of Registration: 15.01.2019

Parish: ELLINGTON

RECOMMENDATION - REFUSE

The application has been referred to Development Management Committee (DMC) as the recommendation of Ellington Parish Council to approve the application is contrary to the officer recommendation to refuse the application and the proposal is also a departure from the development plan.

1. DESCRIPTION OF SITE AND APPLICATION

1.1The site lies north of the village of Ellington, between Thrapston Road and a landscape belt adjoining the A14 with Malting Lane to the east and a field to the west. There is a small Anglian Water pumping station towards the north-east corner of the site and a sewer pipe is understood to cross the site from the pumping station in a south- westerly direction.

1.2On the opposite/east side of Malting Lane is Grove Cottage, a Grade II listed timber framed thatched cottage and its garden and a site with permission for a dwelling (application 18/01712/FUL refers).

1.3The site includes four buildings of varying age, bulk and design in a former farm yard. There is a large brick-paved parking area with other areas of hardstanding, some of which are overgrown and there is a small open area of grass to the south-east by the junction of Thrapston Road and Malting Lane.

1.4The site is understood to have been last used for industrial racking storage and maintenance for resale (Class B8) with an office (Class B1a). The northerly building is single-storey, flat roofed and part timber clad. The other buildings are higher and have pitched roofs. The building nearest the middle of the site is open sided, the south- eastern building is of brick with timber cladding and the building to the south-west is of more modern design with light coloured cladding.

1.5On the southern side there are high enclosures constructed of railway sleepers to the east and a gate and railings to the west. The enclosures are part obscured by vegetation to the south. There is a high palisade fence to the west and part of the northern boundary. There are high perimeter walls, gates and temporary fences on the eastern boundary.

1.6The proposal is to erect 7 dwellings (to include 3, 4, 5 and 6 bed units) and two outbuildings and provide a new access to Thrapston Road together with associated works following demolition of the existing buildings. The proposal entails providing a path on the road frontages south and east of the site and erecting new perimeter enclosures including an acoustic screen approximately 2m high although the position of the acoustic screen has not been specified and revised acoustic screen details are being discussed with HDC’s Environmental Health Officer. Plots 1 and 7 are to be self-build plots.

1.7Site levels reduce from the village south of the site down towards the A14 and north. Thrapston Road is higher than the hardstanding on the site.

1.8The northern part of Ellington conservation area lies south of the site (and includes the Thrapston Road’s southern highway verge). There is a Grade II listed building, Yew Tree farm, on the south side of Thrapston Road.

1.9A public right of way (Ellington Public Footpath No. 13) crosses the site in an approximately west/east direction.

1.10The site is understood to be in an area at low risk of flooding (zone 1) according to the Huntingdonshire Strategic Flood Risk Assessment 2017 (although the northern part was previously considered to be at medium flood risk and the northern part of site is in the Environment Agency's flood alert service area and the land around the brook north of the A14 appears to be at high risk of flooding).

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Erection of 7 No. dwellinghouses and associated works following demolition of existing buildings: Land at Corner of Thrapston Road and Malting Lane, Ellington, PE28 0AA: 18/02756/FULReport 7.1 MB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
92MINUTESOn the agenda 94Development Management - Deferred Item - Erection of a new 3 bedroom dwelling – Lye house, Bedford Road, Pertenhall, Bedford, MK44 2AL - 18/01102/FULApproved 95Application Requiring Reference to the Development Management Committee - Erection of portal building extension - Cotton Farm, Offord Road, Graveley, St Neots, PE19 6PU - 18/02240/FULApproved 96aSingle storey rear sunroom - 50 Mill Road, Stilton, Peterborough, PE7 3XY - 19/00541/HHFULApproved 96bPermission in Principle for up to 5 dwellings - Land Adjacent to 15 Mill Lane, Bluntisham, PE28 3LR - 19/00313/PIPApproved 96cOutline application for a development of up to 83 homes, 150sqm of commercial floor space, landscaping, open space, associated ancillary works and creation of new access following the demolition of 22 Buryfield.Refused 96dPermission in principle application for a single residential dwelling Land East of 1 The Lane, Easton, PE28 0TY - 19/00392/PIPApproved
96eErection of 7 No. dwellinghouses and associated works following demolition of existing buildings - Land at Corner of Thrapston Road and Malting Lane, Ellington, PE28 0AA - 18/02756/FULThis decision
96fErection of a single family dwelling with attendant landscaping and bin and cycle storage - Land Between 33 and 43 Meadow Road, Great Gransden, SG19 3BD - 18/02645/FULApproved 96gResidential development for up to two dwellings - Land West of Barley Croft, Back Lane, Holywell - 19/00253/PIPApproved 96hErection of two dwellinghouses - Land North of East View, Warboys Road, Pidley, PE28 3DA - 18/02739/FULApproved 96iPermission Principle for up to 2 dwellings at Lot 1 Avenue Farm, Padgetts Lane, Fenton, PE28 2FT - 19/00175/PIPApproved 96jPermission in Principle for 1 Dwelling - Land North West of Almans House, Fenton Road, Fenton, PE28 2SN - 19/00347/PIPApproved 96k70 residential dwellings, together with the provision of a new access from High St, open space and new footpaths/cycle ways and doctors surgery - Land West of 26 to 34 High Street, Stilton, PE7 3RA - 18/02192/OUTApproved 96lPermission in Principle for 6 Dwellings - Land South East of 26 New Road, Warboys, PE28 2SS - 19/00356/PIPApproved 97aReserved Matters, including appearance, landscaping, layout and scale details, for the erection of 222 dwellings pursuant to Outline Planning Permission 17/02308/OUT and a signed S106 legal agreement dated 6.11.18. - Wintringham Park, Cambridge Road, St Neots - 18/02719/REMOn the agenda 97bResidential dwelling with garage – Land North of 2 and 4 Mill Lane, Alwalton, PE7 3UZ - 18/02560/FULOn the agenda 97cChange of use and extension from bank to residential (4 flats) - 67 High Street, Ramsey, PE26 1YU - 18/02098/FULOn the agenda

Who was there

12 of 16 attended
JD
Councillor Jason David AblewhiteVice-Chair, present
LA
Councillor Lewis Adam BesleyMember, apologies
SM
Councillor Shaun Mark BurtonMember, present
ER
Councillor Eric Richard ButlerChair, present
MS
Councillor Mrs Sarah Joanne ConboyMember, present
DB
Councillor Douglas Bernard DewMember, apologies
RF
Councillor Ryan FullerMember, present
KP
Councillor Kevin Paul GulsonMember, present
MH
Councillor Mike HumphreyMember, apologies
DN
Councillor Dr Nik JohnsonMember, present
CJ
Councillor Colin John MaslenMember, present
JN
Councillor Jon NeishMember, present

All 16 on the meeting page

On this subject at Huntingdonshire

Search all
  1. Erection of 7 No. dwellinghouses and associated works following demolition of existing buildings - Land at Corner of Thrapston Road and Malting Lane, Ellington, PE28 0AA - 18/02756/FULThis decision
  2. Erection of two dwellinghouses - Land North of East View, Warboys Road, Pidley, PE28 3DA - 18/02739/FULApproved

More from Huntingdonshire Development Management Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
21 Sep 2026 Appeal decisionsRESOLVED that the contents of the report be noted. Noted Open
17 Aug 2026 Appeal decisionsRESOLVED that the contents of the report be noted. Noted Open
20 Jul 2026 Application requiring reference to the development management committee - change of use of site to coach depot and workshop and erection of security fencing - wansford railway station, old great north road, stibbington, peterborough - 25/01775/fulRESOLVED that the application be not determined. Decided Open
20 Jul 2026 Appeal decisionsRESOLVED that the contents of the report be noted. Noted Open
22 Jun 2026 Appeal decisionsRESOLVED that the contents of the report be noted. Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies