RESOLVED that:- (a) the report be noted and support be given to the ongoing development of the Select Committee Topic Review process which had achieved excellent outcomes for the County Council and the residents of Kent; and (b) Policy Overview Co-ordinating Committee be requested to monitor the outcomes of Topic Review reports published prior to the formal adoption of a monitoring process in March 2006 on a systematic basis.
Word for word from the decision Kent published for this meeting.Source: democracy.kent.gov.uk
1. In the summer of 2007 a questionnaire which was circulated to all Members of the existing Policy Overview Committees on the effectiveness of the Policy Overview Committees. The outcomes of this questionnaire were reported to the County Council on 18 October 2007. One of the issues which was raised in debate at the Council meeting was the need for a comprehensive report on the Select Committee recommendations for each of the reports and topic reviews which have been undertaken since 2001.
Rules applying to Select Committee Topic Reviews
2. (1) Appendix 1 sets out extracts from the County Council’s Constitution applying to Select Committees including the process for monitoring the outcomes arising from the Select Committee Topic Review process.
(2) Attention is drawn to the paragraphs relating to Review Reports in Appendix 1 (paragraphs 5.8 – 5.14)
(3) Relevant Cabinet Members and Managing Directors (depending on the subject of the Topic Review) are invited to comment at the start, middle and end of the review.
(4) Cabinet Members and Managing Directors are also invited to contribute to the Topic Review Proposal Form (see Appendix 2) which the Policy Overview Co- ordinating Committee uses to determine the Topic Review programme.
Monitoring of Select Committee Recommendations
3. (1) In March 2006 the County Council agreed to a formal procedure whereby:-
(a) Select Committee recommendations require an action plan to be prepared within three months and for this action plan to be made available to the host Policy Overview Committee; and
(b) for the Select Committee to be reconvened to monitor the recommendations one year on after the endorsement of the Select Committee report by the Cabinet. Appendix 1 sets out the monitoring process. (2) The Overview and Scrutiny function continues to evolve and develop as does the Topic Review process. The Policy Overview Co-ordinating Committee is continuing to explore how the effectiveness of the process can be improved so that the outcomes and recommendations of the Select Committee add value to the residents of Kent.
Impact and Outcomes of the Select Committee Process
4. (1) Select Committees are seen as one of the successes of Cabinet and Overview and Scrutiny. Members who have served on a Select Committee often comment that this is a rewarding process. This was borne out by the responses to the questionnaire on the effectiveness of the Policy Overview Committees.
(2) The Cabinet acknowledges that the Select Committee Topic Reviews have added value and made a significant impact and contribution to targets set out in Towards 2010 (formerly the Next Four Years) and a number of the County Council’s Policy Framework documents.
(3) It is worth recording that this is not a new phenomenon. Select Committees have been achieving successful outcomes since the inception of Cabinet and Overview and Scrutiny Government. Here are a few of the highlights:-
Looked After Children - 2001
This report raised the profile of Looked After Children within Kent and the need to improve outcomes and services for this group of children. Recommendations from the review have been progressed and further developed in subsequent work, the most significant of which are:-
(a) the Looked After Children s52 Action Plan; (b) the Looked After Children Review 2006, and (c) the Kent Pledge.
Pattern of the School Year - 2002
The Select Committee recommended that Kent adopts a six-term year (or six half terms). The County Council adopted the six half terms and the fixed Easter break in 2005.
Financing of the Health Economy – 2003.
This piece of work has provided a foundation stone for the engagement of the Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee with Health Organisations within the Kent and Medway Health Economy.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.