(1) the proposed Monitoring Officer Protocol be adopted by the Committee subject to the following alterations: (a) the word “shall” in the second line of paragraph 3.2 to be replaced with the word “may” (b) Paragraph 3.2 to be further amended to make it clear that the complainant should be approached first to establish what sort of resolution they were seeking; then approach the subject Member to establish their views on the resolution being sought (c) Paragraph 5.2 be amended to read “…and this may include another appropriately experienced senior officer of the Authority, a senior officer of another Authority, or a consultant.” (2) The Head of Democratic Services and Local Leadership be requested to make these amendments and communicate the protocol to Members and members of the public ([name removed] asked for it to be recorded in the Minutes that he did not consider that the section of the Protocol dealing with Local Resolution was necessary).
Word for word from the decision Kent published for this meeting.Source: democracy.kent.gov.uk
1. The locally managed framework for dealing with complaints that a Member is alleged to have breached the Code of Conduct has been in place for over a year and KCC has dealt with some 8 complaints during that period. The Committee has developed assessment criteria for sifting complaints and all Members of the Committee have served on at least one Assessment Sub Committee. There has also been one meeting of the Review Sub Committee.
2. The experience of having dealt with a number of complaints offers the Committee an opportunity to reflect on the overall process to see if any improvements can be made. In particular, there are two areas of contention, which a number of Members (including some of those who have been the subject of complaints) have mentioned are worthy of discussion.
(a) The process for informing the subject Member that a complaint has been made about him/her and providing a summary of the complaint; and (b) Whether the opportunity exists for local resolution prior to the meeting of the Assessment Sub Committee
3. With regard to (a) above, the guidance from the Standards Board states that the subject Member can only be provided with a summary of the complaint if the Assessment Sub Committee agrees to issue such a summary. Since May 2008, this guidance has been followed and has led to some difficulties and inconsistencies:
(a) Once a Member has been informed that a complaint has been made against them, he/she is then often left not knowing exactly what they are alleged to have done, which in one or two cases in the last 12 months, has caused stress and anxiety amongst Members, which is not conducive to effective working relationships between Members and the Monitoring Officer and his staff; (b) Without details of the complaint, a Member might inadvertently interfere with a potential witness or make matters more complicated, prior to a meeting of the Assessment Sub Committee (c) Some complainants are completely open with the subject Member that they are submitting a complaint to the Standards Committee, resulting in an inconsistency, compared to those complaints that are submitted without the Member’s knowledge
4. With regard to 2(b) above, whilst the Monitoring Officer must submit all appropriate complaints to the Assessment Sub Committee, a number of local authorities are choosing to seek to achieve a local resolution in appropriate cases. In these cases, both the original complaint, together with the outcome of the Monitoring Officer’s attempts at local resolution are referred to and considered by the Assessment Sub Committee. Experience elsewhere suggests that this can avoid the necessity of a formal investigation.
5. Accordingly, in order to address these issues and following the attendance of [name removed], [name removed] and [name removed] at a seminar held in London during May, hosted by Bevan Brittan, a draft Monitoring Officer Protocol has been produced (see Appendix 1) and the Committee is invited to consider the adoption of the protocol.
Recommendation
6. The Committee is recommended to adopt the proposed Monitoring Officer Protocol in relation to the receipt, initial assessment and review of complaints that a Member is alleged to have breached the Code of Conduct (Appendix 1)
Peter Sass – Head of Democratic Services and Local Leadership July 2009
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.