RESOLVED to:- (a) note the Director of Law and Governance’s advice that the votes of each individual Committee Member should be recorded on those occasions when the Head of Planning Applications Group’s recommendation to grant permission or refuse an application is overturned; and (a) agree that this advice be reported to Selection and Member Services Committee and (subject to that Committee’s agreement) to the County Council for proposed adoption into the Constitution.
Word for word from the decision Kent published for this meeting.Source: democracy.kent.gov.uk
Report to Planning Applications Committee, 5 pages
By: Chairman of Planning Applications Committee Head of Democratic Services and Local Leadership
To: Planning Applications Committee – Tuesday, 12 April 2011
Subject: RECORDED VOTING AT PLANNING APPLICATIONS COMMITTEE MEETINGS AND RELATED ISSUES
Classification: Unrestricted
FOR INFORMATION
Introduction
1. The Committee considered a report at its meeting on 20 January 2011. This report is included at Appendix A to this report.
2. The Committee resolved that:
(a) Selection and Member Services be requested to not consider this matter at its next meeting; and (b) a further report be made to a future meeting of the Committee giving more detailed consideration of this and related issues.
3. During the meeting, [name removed] produced a document setting out concerns over the proposal to record the votes of each of the Committee Members whenever the Committee voted to overturn the Head of Planning Applications Group’s recommendations. [name removed] comments are included at Appendix B.
4. The “related issues” that were raised by Committee members were:
(a) Whether there should be a “Cooling Off period” following a vote to overturn the Head of Planning Applications Group’s recommendations. This would enable the head of Planning Applications Group to prepare a report, setting out the reasons given by members for doing so, enabling her to comment on them. This, second report would be considered at the next Committee meeting, enabling the original decision to be confirmed, revised or overturned.
(b) Whether abstention should be a permitted option if a Member was entitled to vote on a particular application.
(c) Whether a vote to overturn the Head of Planning Applications Group’s recommendations should be referred to the county Council.
(d) Whether the rules of “purdah” should be applied more rigorously during any election period (not just national or County Council elections) when deciding which applications should be reported to the Committee. The comments of [name removed]
5. [name removed] comments criticised the lack of clarity in the report, specifically the lack of clear grounds for recommending a change to the Constitution.
6. [name removed] also raised a concern that the effect of the change could be to inhibit members from voting against the Head of Planning Applications Group’s recommendations. In particular, he quoted the report and questioned why the way a Member voted could become “a matter of legal significance.”
7. [name removed] suggested that Members should be informed of the legal consequences of overturning a recommendation and that the best way to mitigate this might be for the Committee to prepare its detailed reasons during the meeting itself. If necessary, this should be done by adjourning the meeting whilst the formal wording was drafted before being brought back for approval or amendment.
Response by the Director of Law and Governance
8. The Director of Law and Governance has accepted [name removed] comments on the question of clarity and has made the following explanatory comments in response:
A decision which confirms the Head of Planning Applications Group’s recommendations is readily defendable in the courts or at a planning inquiry. This is because the grounds for the decision are detailed and open for all to see. Should the recommendation and decision be successfully challenged, the responsibility would naturally be borne by the head of Planning Applications Group. The Committee itself would have acted in a manner which could not be criticised as it would demonstrably have had regard to the best and most professional advice available to it.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Minutes of the Meeting Held on 17.6.2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the meeting held on 17 June 2026 were correctly recorded and that they be signed by the ...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.