that (1) Procedure Rule 2.20 (4) be amended as recommended by the Director of Governance and Law (and set out in paragraphs 5 and 6 of the report) in relation to recorded votes at meetings of the Planning Applications Committee; (2) the Adult Social Services and Public Health Policy Overview and Scrutiny Committee be re-named as the Adult Social Care and Public Health Policy Overview and Scrutiny Committee with immediate effect, for the reasons set out in the report; (3) the designation of individual officers as statutory and proper officers of the Kent County Council be approved as set out in the attached table and that a new Article 11.10 be approved as set out in paragraph 13 of the report; and (4) Article 13.3 of the Constitution (Finance, Contracts, Resource Management and Legal Matters) be amended as set out in paragraph 14 of the report.
Word for word from the decision Kent published for this meeting.Source: democracy.kent.gov.uk
Subject: Proposed Changes to the Council’s Constitution
Classification: Unrestricted
Summary: This report contains the details of three separate matters, which if approved, will involve changes to the Council’s Constitution.
FOR DECISION
Recorded Votes at meetings of the Planning Applications Committee
1. Procedure Rule 2.20 of the County Council’s Constitution sets out the rules for recording voting at committee meetings as follows:-
(1) If any Member requests, the Chairman will call a vote on any recommendation or motion or amendment. The vote will be by a show of hands by Members of the Committee present, including substitute Members.
(2) If the votes for and against are equal, the Chairman shall immediately declare if he is using his casting vote and, if so, whether for or against the proposal.
(3) Immediately after a vote has been taken, an individual Member may ask that the way he cast his vote either for or against the proposal or to abstain be recorded in the minutes.
(4) One-third of the voting Members present may require that the way all Members cast their vote for or against or to abstain shall be recorded in the Minutes: such a request must be made before the vote is taken.
The need to vary the procedure for the Planning Applications Committee
2. The determination of each planning application is a legal decision which is open to challenge either through an appeal to the Secretary of State or Judicial Review. On those occasions where the recommendations of the Head of Planning Applications Group have been agreed, the decision is readily defendable through reference to the professional advice given in the report and at the meeting.
3. The situation becomes more complex on those occasions when the Committee overturns the Head of Planning Applications Group’s recommendations. Under such circumstances, the way in which each individual Member voted can become a matter of legal significance. 4. The Director of Governance and Law has clarified that the term “legal significance” relates to the need to be able to demonstrate that the voting was accurately recorded and that any necessary declarations of personal and prejudicial interests had been made. Individual Members are not personally liable for the actual way in which they cast their votes.
5. Consequently, the Director of Governance and Law has advised that the votes of each individual Committee Member (whether for, against or in abstention) should be recorded whenever the Committee votes against the Head of Planning Applications Group’s recommendation for permission or refusal.
6. This provision (underlined below) would supplement Procedure Rule 2.20 and would not replace it. Procedure Rule 2.20 (4) would be amended to read:
“One-third of the voting Members present may require that the way all members cast their vote for or against or to abstain shall be recorded in the Minutes; such a request must be made before the vote is taken. Additionally, the votes of each individual Member of the Planning Applications Committee (whether for, against or in abstention) will be recorded whenever the Committee votes against the Head of Planning Applications Group’s recommendation for permission or refusal of a planning application, together with the grounds and reasons for overturning the recommendation.”
7. This proposed provision has been reported to Planning Applications Committee on 12 April 2011 and (with its agreement) to Selection and Member Services Committee on 7 June 2011. Selection and Member Services Committee agreed that the Director of Governance and Law’s advice should be reported to the County Council for proposed adoption into the Constitution.
Proposed change of name of the Adult Social Services and Public Health Policy Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.