CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Royal Borough of Kingston upon Thames
Scrutiny Panel, Tuesday 22 May 2007 at 7.30pm

REVIEW OF THE WORKING OF THE PANEL

Agreed Scrutiny 1 paper

Scrutiny Panel agreed this item on Tuesday 22 May 2007. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item3

Resolved

It was agreed that this point should be looked at by the Head of Democratic Services and Partnership in the wider context of making meetings more accessible. The workload of the Panel is considerable and meetings are, unavoidably, longer than average. To provide more capacity and at the same time provide opportunities for Member development and developing knowledge in particular areas, a system of Sub Groups was proposed. Issues, including member call-ins could initially be investigated by a small cross party Sub Group led by the appropriate Shadow Executive Member, members of the sub group need not be restricted to panel members, although an adjustment to the Constitution to cater for this may be necessary. This group would not have any decision making powers but could research the issue and hear evidence and then report to the full Panel. This could avoid the need for additional meetings of the Panel, with the associated problems of finding dates etc and provide a more informal meeting arrangement for witnesses. Councillor Mama commented that there was a risk that this could lead to too many Sub-groups being set up and Members having less time at the end of the day. RESOLVED that 1 the public participation arrangements should continue unchanged 2 for community call ins the order of speakers/witnesses to be a. representatives of residents/others who have called in the item to present their reasons and respond to questions b. Decision makers – relevant Executive Member/ Chair/Vice Chair/Co Chairs of Neighbourhoods c. Appropriate officers 3 to enable detailed preliminary work to be done on various topics the Panel have the ability to set up cross party Sub-Groups , led by the appropriate ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Word for word from the decision Kingston upon Thames published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.kingston.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Kingston upon Thames's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Scrutiny Panel

APPENDIX B SCRUTINY PANEL

22 May 2007

REVIEW OF THE WORKING OF THE PANEL

DISCUSSION PAPER BY

Councillor Howard Jones – Chair of the Scrutiny Panel and the Head of Democratic Services and Partnership

PURPOSE

This paper looks at the work of the Panel over the past year, reflects on changes made in the light of experience and considers other changes that may be introduced, drawing on this experience and comments from Members over the year. In agreeing the arrangements for public participation it was agreed that these would be reviewed at the end of the year.

The outline work programme for the year ahead is included at paragraph 14 and Members are invited to suggest any additional areas of interest to be considered for inclusion. Reference is also made to forthcoming extensions of Overview and Scrutiny powers on crime and disorder and actions by key public local service providers.

At the close of discussion the intention is that the Panel will have • confirmed or made changes to its arrangements for

Public participation

Handling call ins and performance reviews

• agreed topics for the work programme

SUMMARY OF WORK OVER THE PAST YEAR

1. The role of the Panel is to

a. call in Executive and Neighbourhood Committees decisions –and to deal with the call in of decisions made by other Councillors or the wider community.

b. review and scrutinise the performance of the Council in relation to its policy objectives, performance targets and/or particular service areas

c. review and scrutinise the performance of other public bodies in the area and invite reports from them by requesting them to address the Panel and local people about their activities and performance B2

d. carry out selective pre-decision scrutiny of items to be considered by the Executive

2. The Panel has dealt with 5 call-ins – 2 of which were community call ins – and reviewed decisions/performance in 7 areas. The areas covered are in Annex 1 and 2. The timetabling of issues, and the volume of work for the Panel has not allowed the opportunity for pre-decision scrutiny. The Medium Term Financial Plan – Changing Kingston – Choosing our Future was however discussed in advance of the Executive’s consideration and comments submitted.

Comments from the Corporate Assessment Report on the operation of Scrutiny

3. The Corporate Assessment report, following the inspection during July – September 2006, includes the following comments on the Scrutiny function

Early indications from the first Scrutiny Committee are that the new arrangements provide a sound foundation to build on in holding the Executive to account. ……. The role of scrutiny in reviewing performance management was limited under previous arrangements. Following the external review, revised arrangements are in place, with scrutiny now chaired by the opposition. This demonstrates a constructive use of external evaluation in order to learn and reflects a high degree of self awareness.

Public participation

4. Over the course of its 10 meetings, 21 members of the public attended, excluding witnesses and others contributing to reviews and call-ins.

5. In September and November the panel considered arrangements for public participation, within the framework in which the Panel works. In essence any member of the public can indicate 4 days before the meeting if they wish to be a witness and the areas on which they will be contributing particular knowledge. At or before the meeting questions can be put in writing on issues on the agenda - the Chair reserving the right not to take any questions which are viewed as irrelevant.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
REVIEW OF THE WORKING OF THE PANELReport 28 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
1MINUTESDecided 2MANAGING COMPLAINTSOn the agenda
3REVIEW OF THE WORKING OF THE PANELThis decision

Who was there

12 of 14 attended
JW
Josephine WillowsNon-elected, voting, absent
JB
Councillor Janet Bowen-HitchingsMember, present
FC
Former Councillor David CunninghamMember, present
DD
DOE DennisMember, present
CH
Councillor Chrissie HitchcockMember, present
PJ
Councillor Paul JohnstonVice-Chair, present
HJ
Councillor Howard JonesChair, present
NK
Councillor Nick KilbyMember, present
SM
Councillor Steve MamaMember, present
IM
Councillor Ian McDonaldMember, present
JR
John RussellNon-elected, voting, absent
FC
Former Councillor Dave Ryder-MillsMember, present

All 14 on the meeting page

On this subject at Kingston upon Thames

Search all
  1. REVIEW OF THE WORKING OF THE PANELThis decision
  2. Review of home to school transport working groupApproved

More from Kingston upon Thames Scrutiny Panel

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
15 Mar 2023 Scrutiny Panel ProcedureRESOLVED that the proposed form of procedure on Appendix A of the agenda pack be agreed. Voting - Unanimous Agreed Open
26 Jan 2021 Scrutiny Panel ProcedureRESOLVED that the proposed procedure outlined on page 2 of the agenda was agreed by the Committee. Voting: Unanimous. Agreed Open
26 Jan 2021 Call In of Decision by Culture, Housing, Environment & Planning Committee on 18 November 2020 (Cashless Parking)RESOLVED that the request for the call-in, be rejected, in which instance the original decision of the Culture, Housi... Refused Open
8 Jan 2020 Scrutiny Panel ProcedureResolved to permit parents to speak, if they lived within the 745 metre catchment area of the Burlington infant schoo... Decided Open
8 Jan 2020 Call in of proposal to consult upon the expansion of Burlington Junior School to five forms of entryResolved that the request for the call-in, be rejected, in which instance the original decision of the Childrens’ and... Refused Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies