RESOLVED that the outcome of the scrutiny of the community call in of the decisions on a proposed new Primary School for the Surbiton Hospital site be noted. Reason for the decision To receive the report of the Scrutiny Panel on its consideration of a community call in. [Councillors Derek Osbourne and Penny Shelton declared a prejudicial interest in this report and withdrew from the meeting during its consideration. Reason: Councillors Osbourne and Shelton are on the NHS Kingston Board. Councillor Simon James took the Chair for this item.]
Word for word from the decision Kingston upon Thames published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.kingston.gov.uk
OUTCOME OF COMMUNITY CALL IN ON PROPOSED NEW PRIMARY SCHOOL SURBITON HOSPITAL SITE SCRUTINY PANEL 24 FEBRUARY 2011
Purpose To note the outcome of the call in by 109 members of the community of the following decisions made at Executive 11 January – Minutes 86 and 92 – in Parts 1 and 2 of the meeting 1 approving the programme for the School Competition and the issuing of a school competition notice 2 noting the statutory route for progressing the development of the site in respect to restrictive land covenants 3 approving the conditions relating to the purchase of the school site; 4 acknowledging the risk and mitigation measures to be implemented relating to land covenants on the school site;: 5 approving the proposed strategy for procuring the construction works for the school buildings.
Scrutiny Panel Conclusions and Decision We are extremely sympathetic to the petitioners in this case and understand the claim that there has been a failure to consider alternative sites although officers have described an outline of the review of sites process carried out by the Council and consultants. It is clear to the Panel that there have been consultations although there are some question marks and flaws on some aspects of this which were explained by the officers; it seems also that there has been some haste in this matter. The Panel has heard of the deadlines to be met if the School is to be provided on the site and open for September 2012. Whilst not convinced that the project was started early enough, the Panel understands why this date has to be achieved for the school to be provided in good time. The issue of the gold pages and confidential information is unsatisfactory. The NHS is a public body spending public money and its processes should be transparent. This could be cited as a good example of why the NHS should come under local authorities. However on the basis of what we have heard this evening and have read in the gold pages, we cannot and should not argue with the advice in these pages and the proposed arrangements associated with this advice. We regret that information has had to be hidden in the gold pages and understand why residents feel that the issues of risk have not been properly conveyed to them. Having considered the reasons for the call in which apply to the Executive decisions we believe there are not sufficient grounds to refer the matter back to the Executive or to refer it to Council. The main issue in contention is a planning matter and it is a matter for the Development Control Committee to deliberate on the planning considerations and on whether the site is appropriate for development of a school and health facility as set out in the planning application. These matters have been aired at a Neighbourhood Planning Meeting, at the Executive and now in Scrutiny, our view is that a further referral to Executive or the Council would not have a meaningful impact on the decisions made and it is with some regret that we uphold the decisions of the Executive of 11 January 2011.
Reasons for the Call In The reasons for the call in were (a) concerns at the unsuitability of the site for such a school, whilst recognising the need for additional primary school provision in Surbiton (b) the Council’s failure to consider alternative sites despite the frequent requests of local residents that they should do so. (c) the Council’s attempt to push through this decision with undue haste and inadequate consultation with local residents. (d) the brushing aside of the environmental concerns of residents (e) the demolition of buildings of townscape merit in a conservation area. (f) the fact that RBK does not own the site and will have to purchase it when other sites within its ownership might be used.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.