CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Royal Borough of Kingston upon Thames
Executive, Tuesday 5 April 2011 at 7.30pm

CONSTITUTIONAL REVIEW: PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE COUNCIL'S DECISION MAKING PROCESS

Approved Executive 6 papers

Executive approved this item on Tuesday 5 April 2011. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item126

Resolved

RESOLVED that 1. the Council be recommended to adopt the following changes to the Council’s formal decision making processes, to take effect from the beginning of the Municipal Year 2011/12: a) the creation of three Strategic Committees with the remits and membership set out in this report. b) the Executive to continue to meet to ratify decisions of the Strategic Committees during the transitional phase. c) the size of the Scrutiny Panel be reduced from 16 to 9 members, recognising the likely reduction in its role under the new arrangements. d) the Health Overview Panel continue in existence, with further consideration being given to its precise role as the changes proposed by the Health and Social Care Bill become clear. e) the Overview Commission be discontinued. f) no change be made in relation to Neighbourhood or Regulatory Committees, but further consideration be given to the precise role of the Standards Committee in the light of the changes nationally to the standards regime. g) the enhanced role for full Council, through the potential for more issues to be referred there for debate and “decision” be noted. 2. further consideration be given at a future meeting to how best to improve the links between the Council’s formal decision making processes, the Kingston Strategic Partnership and its partnership machinery; 3. the potential resource implications of the new arrangements be noted; 4. the proposed detailed changes to the Council’s Constitution be developed for submission to the Council meeting on 27 April for approval; and 5. the timetable of meetings circulated as Annex 5 to the report be approved. Reason for the decision To revitalise the Council’s formal decision making processes and provide a greater role for backbench Members.
Word for word from the decision Kingston upon Thames published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.kingston.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Kingston upon Thames's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive

ANNEX 4

Opportunities and Risks of Proposed Committee Structure in Meeting the Principles of Governance1 Principle and Description Opportunities Risks Accountability – is the process whereby local • All members would feel some • Single line of accountability for policy areas authorities, and the members and staff within accountability for decisions and engagement with partners/stakeholders them, are responsible for their decisions and having been a part of making is removed actions, including their stewardship of public them • Collective responsibility is weakened the funds and all aspects of performance, and larger the decision-making group submit themselves to appropriate external • Committee structures can cause confusion scrutiny. It is achieved by all parties having a with partners and the public over how clear understanding of those responsibilities, decisions are made and who is running the and having clearly defined roles through a Council – and therefore who to complain to robust structure (faceless bureaucracy) • Could blur the line between the roles of members and officers in decision-making (if officers get drawn into debates) Effectiveness – is the extent to which an • Could improve outcomes • Could lead to compromises and therefore activity fulfils its intended objective, purpose or through greater debate less effective decisions function • Could enable more difficult • Could focus on details rather than essentials decisions to be made through (operational and/or thematic rather than sharing decision-making strategic and/or Borough-wide) • Could improve member level performance monitoring and scrutiny Integrity – comprises both straightforward • Allows more scrutiny of • Could be openly adversarial dealing and completeness. It is based upon decisions before and at the • Committee structures generally consume far honesty, selflessness and objectivity, and high time they are made more time and resources standards of propriety and probity in the • Could build more resilience into • Potential for agenda overload/mismatch stewardship of public funds and the decision-making between committees management of an authority’s affairs. It is • Could slow down decision-making dependent on the effectiveness of the control • Could lead to decisions being made late in 1 Ignores transitional phase which could exacerbate the threats and make the governance arrangements more complex and opaque ANNEX 4

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
8 Annex 4Appendix 51 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
8 KSP structure chart+housing Annex2Appendix 55 KB Download
PDF
8 Partnership Bodies Annex 3Appendix 31 KB Download
PDF
8 Potential Remits of New Strategic Committees 2010 Annex 1Appendix 58 KB Download
PDF
8 Timetable Draft Annex 5Appendix 55 KB Download
PDF
CONSTITUTIONAL REVIEW: PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE COUNCIL'S DECISION MAKING PROCESSDecisions 95 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

7 of 7 attended
DO
Councillor Derek OsbourneChair, present
PB
Councillor Patricia BamfordMember, present
RD
Councillor Rolson DaviesMember, present
LG
Councillor Liz GreenMember, present
SJ
Councillor Simon JamesMember, present
FM
Councillor Frances MoseleyMember, present
PS
Councillor Penny SheltonMember, present

On this subject at Kingston upon Thames

Search all
  1. CONSTITUTIONAL REVIEW: PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE COUNCIL'S DECISION MAKING PROCESSThis decision
  2. Review of Constitutional Arrangements - Recommendations of the Response and Recovery Committee 25.03.21Approved
  3. Review of Constitutional ArrangementsApproved
  4. Constitutional review: proposed changes to the council's decision making process (executive - 5 april 2011 - appendix h)Approved
  5. Taking forward the outcome of the constitutional reviewNoted
  6. Constitutional reviewApproved

More from Kingston upon Thames Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
27 Mar 2012 MINUTESRESOLVED that the minutes of the meeting held on 20 March 2012 are confirmed as a correct record. Decided Open
27 Mar 2012 Decisions of the policy and resources committee to be ratifiedRESOLVED that the following decisions of the Policy and Resources Committee on 27 March 2012 are ratified. Decided Open
27 Mar 2012 Grants to voluntary organisations: project grants 2012/13Agreed that 1. the amounts of Project Grant aid to be offered to the voluntary organisations for 2012/13 as set out i... Agreed Open
27 Mar 2012 One kingstonAgreed that the progress report concerning the One Kingston Programme is noted and reports continue to be submitted a... Agreed Open
27 Mar 2012 Capital programme 2012/13Agreed that 1. the forecast capital outturn for 2011/12 is noted 2. the proposed approach to developing and reporting... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies