Agreed that 1. the cost implications of recording meetings are noted 2. recording of voting and recording of meetings is implemented; and 3. residents and journalists/media wishing to film meetings are permitted to do so but asked to give advance notice and respect any concerns expressed by people on being filmed , as indicated in paragraph 14. Reason for decision To implement the Council motion
Word for word from the decision Kingston upon Thames published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.kingston.gov.uk
RECORDING OF MEETINGS – IMPLEMENTING THE COUNCIL MOTION
REPORT BY THE HEAD OF CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
SUMMARY To consider the financial and practical implications of implementing the motion on A Charter for democratic transparency’ agreed at the Council meeting on 31 October, subject to consideration of these implications by this Committee. The motion proposes
recording in the minutes of all meetings how Councillors voted,
making available for reference either the handwritten notes or a recording of the meeting
Options for making recordings available and minor adjustments to meetings procedures during recordings and recording voting are explained in paragraphs 3 and 8. The cost implications of changes to the Committee rooms, so that recordings are possible in all of them, together with arrangements for Neighbourhood meetings are set out in paragraph 9 . The report also considers whether the current view on filming at meetings appropriate given the emerging trend for blogging, tweeting or filming during meetings by the public or journalists and the Government view that public access to meetings should reflect the contribution that this sort of technology can make to transparency and democratic debate.
An e petition requesting the availability of recordings on the website on the same page as the minutes was withdrawn in view of the Council decision on this motion.
Action proposed by the Leader of the Council
It is proposed that
1. the cost implications of recording meetings are noted
2. recording of voting and recording of meetings is implemented; and
3. residents and journalists/media wishing to film meetings are permitted to do so but asked to give advance notice and respect any concerns expressed by people on being filmed , as indicated in paragraph 14.
Reason for action proposed
To implement the Council motion BACKGROUND
1. At the Council meeting on 31 October the following motion was agreed
A Charter for democratic transparency’ - Proposed by Councillor Howard Jones Seconded by Councillor Dennis Doe
2. ‘This Council supports proposals that will strengthen transparency, democracy and the accountability of its elected representatives by recording in the minutes of all meetings how Councillors voted, together with a summary of the debate and to have available either full handwritten contemporaneous notes or electronic recording for future reference purposes. 3. An e petition requesting the availability of recordings on the website with the minutes has been withdrawn in view of this motion. The petition has 67 valid signatures.
RECORDING HOW COUNCILLORS VOTE AND SUMMARY OF DEBATE
4. It is assumed from the motion that the intention is that the minutes will show for each decision which Councillors voted For, Against or Abstained. There are no problems in doing this, there will be a momentary pause in the ‘flow’ of the meeting while the Democratic Support officer makes a note of the voting. 5. A summary of the debate has resource and other implications which are difficult to quantify. This will add time to the production of the minutes. This current turnaround time is 3 days which is followed by the 5 day call in period before decisions can be implemented. How call in may operate under the Localism Act changes is unclear as the detail will be covered by the Regulations on committee models anticipated in summer 2012. This system of minuting will also remove the ability to use various features of the agenda software package which are relied upon to produce minutes drawing upon the report summary with additional editing where, for example, recommendations are amended or added to. The Democratic Support team has been reduced and the reductions assume the maximum use of technology as new ways of working are introduced.
NOTES OR RECORDINGS OF MEETINGS
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.