That Officers be authorised to transfer the freehold of Mirfield Community Centre, Water Royd Lane, to Mirfield Community Trust for no premium/nil consideration, subject to a restrictive covenant that will prevent the premises from being used for any other purpose than community use.
Word for word from the decision Kirklees published for this meeting.Source: democracy.kirklees.gov.uk
To advise the Cabinet of the decision and recommendations of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee following its consideration of a Call-In in respect of the decision made by Cabinet on 20th October 2015 on ‘Mirfield Community Centre – Asset Transfer’.
2. Key points
2.1On 18th November 2015, the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee met to consider a Call-In in respect of the decision made by Cabinet on 20 October 2015 on ‘Mirfield Community Centre – Asset Transfer’.
2.2The Committee considered evidence from Councillors who were signatories to the Call-In, the Cabinet Member for Resources and Community Safety, the Assistant Director for Physical Resources and Procurement, and members of the public. The Committee also considered all relevant background information used in the decision- making process and determined if the decision had been made in accordance with the Council’s decision-making principles.
2.3According to the Overview and Scrutiny Procedure Rules, the Committee had three options available to it:
(1) To take no further action and free the decision for implementation. (2) To refer it back to Cabinet with recommendations for amendment. (3) To refer it back to the next Council, if the Panel considered that the decision was not made in accordance with the budget or policy framework.
2.4Prior to the meeting the Committee had sought advice from the Assistant Director for Legal, Governance & Monitoring and was satisfied that the third option did not apply in this instance.
2.5It is noted that Cabinet is also considering a report elsewhere on this agenda which sets out information to assist the Cabinet in making a decision about the action it wishes to take in response to the call in.
2.6The Committee’s Findings:
i. Grounds of call in i: The Cabinet’s decision to review the previous decision of Cabinet in 2002 in relation to Mirfield Community Centre and to demand new terms form the Mirfield Community Trust failed to take full account of the Asset Advancement Policy set by Cabinet on 08 Oct 2013.
After considering all the evidence presented the Committee concluded that it shared the concern. The cabinet report of 20 October 2015 stated that the current Asset Advancement Policy required asset transfers to be approved with restrictive covenants for community use. However, the Committee came to the view that the Asset Advancement Policy did not specify that it was a requirement to have a covenant.
The Committee noted that within the basis for transfer set out in the Asset Advancement Policy the text states “ ….restrictions (called covenants) would normally ensure property remained available to local people ….”. The Committee interpreted the word “normally” to mean that there may be exceptions. There was no mention of a covenant being a requirement, in the legal sense, of every decision made under the Asset Advancement Policy.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.