Resolved
That the Panel reviewed and acknowledged the principles within the guide to the approach to scrutiny for 2018/19.
Corporate Scrutiny Panel decided this item on Tuesday 3 July 2018. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
That the Panel reviewed and acknowledged the principles within the guide to the approach to scrutiny for 2018/19.
Overview and Scrutiny in 2018/19
Set out below is a brief guide to the approach to Overview and Scrutiny in Kirklees and some important messages about maximising the effectiveness of Scrutiny in the year ahead.
1. What is Overview and Scrutiny?
Overview and Scrutiny is an important council function which primarily acts as a check and balance to the work of the Cabinet (Executive). It is led by councillors who do not serve on the Cabinet. It should not be seen as adversarial but rather as an opportunity to enable a broader range of councillors to contribute to the organisation in a constructive way. The main elements of the Scrutiny role are:
To hold the Cabinet to account for the decisions it is making To monitor and where appropriate challenge, the performance and quality of services delivered by the council and other local agencies To carry out constructive reviews of issues, policies or services in areas where there are concerns or potential for improvement To contribute to the development or review of policy for recommendation to the Cabinet
In addition, there are specific powers of scrutiny in relation to proposals by local NHS bodies to significantly reconfigure health services in the district.
Scrutiny is not a decision making body, instead it has the power to make recommendations to the Cabinet and a range of external agencies and partners on issues that affect the citizens of Kirklees. There is a requirement for the Cabinet and other bodies to provide a written response to Scrutiny recommendations.
2. Underpinning principles of Overview and Scrutiny on Kirklees
The underpinning principles of Overview and Scrutiny in Kirklees are:
To leave the party politics at the door - Scrutiny has an important role in the political process but seeks to work in a non party political way. To be proactive and constructive in providing a “critical friend” challenge To maximise the use of pre decision scrutiny to influence important decisions before they are taken rather than criticising after the decision has been made. To be objective in considering a range of evidence and views to inform scrutiny work. To try wherever possible, to hold Scrutiny meetings in public. There will be times when Scrutiny is looking at proposals that are still at an early developmental stage when it may not possible to hold discussions in public. To ensure that the voice of the citizen is heard
1 The Dos and Don’ts of successful O&S
DO DON’T
Leave the party politics at the door Grandstand and use Scrutiny to make party political points Look at strategic issues where Scrutiny Use scrutiny to explore issues specific to can make a difference and add value your ward and personal “hobby horses”
Plan ahead where possible to give the Don’t try and catch someone out, it will lead witness time to prepare for the discussion. to a limited discussion and waste everyone’s Provide a clear brief / lines of enquiry to time. help your witness prepare
Prepare for meetings - read your papers Spring issues on the day and expect to get so you can fully contribute to discussions detailed answers
Treat the people invited to attend with Don’t be adversarial and confrontational respect and put them at their ease so you can have a constructive discussion
Stick to the terms of reference or agreed Don’t try to do too much … looking at a lines of enquiry for the issue under smaller number of issues, resulting in quality scrutiny. recommendations is preferable
Be prepared to listen to other people’s Don’t come with fixed views and dismiss views and base findings on what the anything that does not support your pre- evidence says determined view
Be proactive in contributing to decisions Don’t sit back then criticise after the decision before they are made is made
Extract from LGA – Dos and Don’ts for Effective Working
Do be: Don’t be:
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Approach to Scrutiny: Prioritising & PlanningReport | 80 KB | DownloadRead as text |
PDF |
Approach to Scrutiny: Prioritising & Planning: 5BReport | 45 KB | Download |
Follow Corporate Scrutiny Panel at Kirklees and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Jan 2020 | Membership of the CommitteeApologies were received from Councillors Mahmood Akhtar and John Lawson. | Decided | Open |
| 10 Jan 2020 | Minutes of the Previous MeetingThat the minutes of the meeting of the Committee held on 15 th November 2019 be agreed as a correct record. | Agreed | Open |
| 10 Jan 2020 | InterestsNo interests were declared. | Decided | Open |
| 10 Jan 2020 | Admission of the PublicAll items were considered in public session. | Decided | Open |
| 10 Jan 2020 | Deputations/PetitionsNo deputations or petitions were received. | Decided | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.