Resolved
RESOLVED – That the Motion not be carried.
Council decided this item on Wednesday 14 July 2021. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
RESOLVED – That the Motion not be carried.
To set out proposed changes to the Council’s constitution, namely CPR 35, as described in paragraph 2 below and recommended by the Corporate Governance and Audit Committee, for consideration by the Council.
Key Decision - Is it likely to result in No spending or saving £250k or more, or to have a significant effect on two or more electoral wards? Key Decision - Is it in the Council’s Forward No Plan (key decisions and private reports)?
The Decision - Is it eligible for call in by No Scrutiny?
Date signed off by Strategic Director & name Rachel Spencer-Henshall – 5th July 2021
Is it also signed off by the Service Director Eamonn Croston – 5th July 2021 for Finance?
Is it also signed off by the Service Director for Legal Governance and Commissioning? Julie Muscroft – 5th July 2021 Cabinet member portfolio Cllr Paul Davies
Electoral wards affected: All
Ward councillors consulted: No
Public or private: Public
Has GDPR been considered? YES
1.1At Annual Council an amendment to item 10 on the agenda was proposed by Cllr Bolt and Cllr D Hall.
1.2The effect of the amendment, if approved, would be to exclude certain members from sitting on Strategic Planning Committee as well as any of the Planning Sub-Committees. 1.3 The amendment was referred to the Corporate Governance and Audit Committee (CGA), before going on to Council.
1.4A report on the proposed changes was put before CGA on 25th June 2021 and the Committee voted in favour of recommending the changes to Council. That report is attached at Appendix A for reference and sets out some further background including what other Councils say in their Constitution on this matter and some of the existing checks and balances that exist in the current planning decision making process.
2. Information required to take a decision
2.01The full text of the recommended amendment is as follows:
Addendum to CPR35: rule2: section 3 (in italics)
(2) The Council subject to any statutory provision:-
(iii) shall not appoint the Leader, the Deputy Leader of the Council or any Members of the Cabinet as members of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee or its Panels or the Strategic Planning Committee or Sub-Committee thereof.
2.02The amendment that was proposed and subsequently recommended by CGA is highlighted above and consists of extending the provisions of CPR 35, rule 2.
2.03For information the discussion at CGA focused on a number of points, listed below:
i. The view that Kirklees is not bound by what other authorities do and are free to choose their own rules;
ii. It was suggested that the issue was one of perception, with some decisions being made on a strategic level and then being later considered at a subsequent Planning Sub-Committee by the same members;
iii. The perception could be that the matter had been pre-determined by Cabinet members, with an example given as a decision by Cabinet to dispose of Kirklees owned land, with the same members or members making a subsequent decision on a planning application made by the purchaser;
iv. It was suggested that, in such a situation, a member would declare their involvement in the decision making at strategic level, and withdraw from the planning decision making;
v. A belief that there was a lack of understanding of and therefore a lack of confidence in the planning process by members of the public and that members of the public could perceive there to be conflicts of interest;
vi. It was suggested that the proposed amendment didn’t deal with the wider issues around public confidence;
vii. There was some acceptance that the issues around planning were wider than just the subject of the proposed amendment, but it was put that, failing to vote for the amendment could send the wrong message, that members were unwilling to address public perceptions about planning, or to address wider problems;
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Proposed Amendment to Constitution (Reference from Corporate Governance Audit Committee)Report | 515 KB | DownloadRead as text |
PDF |
Proposed amendments to Council Procedure Rule 35 :Report | 513 KB | Download |
Follow Council at Kirklees and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 18 Nov 2026 | 8RESOLVED – That the 2025/2026 Overview and Scrutiny Annual Report be received and noted. | Noted | Open |
| 18 Nov 2026 | 9RESOLVED – That Council note; 1) the key risks to the delivery of the budget in 2026/27 outlined in the Quarter 1 Fin... | Noted | Open |
| 18 Nov 2026 | 10RESOLVED – 1) That the recommendations of the West Yorkshire Mass Transit Spatial Development Framework Joint Committ... | Approved | Open |
| 18 Nov 2026 | 11RESOLVED – That approval be given to absence from attendance at meetings for Councillor Masood Ahmed until 26 May 202... | Approved | Open |
| 18 Nov 2026 | 14RESOLVED – That the Motion be approved as amended; “This Council notes that Motor neurone disease (MND) and other rap... | Approved | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.