RESOLVED – 1) That approval be given to introduce new parking charges and that a statutory consultation process in relation to new charges will be undertaken in order to do this. 2) That approval also be given to increase existing parking charges by inflation, retrospectively and that in addition a non-statutory engagement and consultation process in relation to increased charges will be undertaken. 3) Note that in accordance with usual procedures, on completion of the consultations, a report will be submitted to Cabinet Committee Local Issues for consideration in relation to the Traffic Regulation Order. 4) That authority be delegated to CCLI for the decision prior to implementation of revised charges. 5) That it be noted that any future annual revisions of car parking tariffs / charges may be delegated to the relevant Service Director responsible for the Parking Service, in accordance with the Financial Procedure Rules.
Word for word from the decision Kirklees published for this meeting.Source: democracy.kirklees.gov.uk
Comments below are in my role as Chair of Scrutiny
Grounds
In the Budget papers that went to Council in March 2023 there was a proposal to undertake a review of the current parking policy, strategy, charges and fees. How the current strategy aligns with local and regional policy and to benchmark fees and charges. The document that went to Council clearly states that a consultation will be held within the financial year commencing April 2023, which would include charges as well as strategy. It also states that a level 2 IIA is required but that until “consultation and engagement with key stakeholders takes place, we are unable to provide a comprehensive assessment”. Since this statement was made the Council have changed their approach to the IIA and it is now one document. This does not though negate the comments in the Budget papers about engagement and consultation.
Therefore, an assumption can be made that both consultation and engagement would take place. The budget document does not state that this is purely the 28-day statutory consultation period for changes to traffic orders as the cabinet report proposes nor does the item in the Budget papers give an indication that this would include changes to free car parks.
The report going to cabinet on 14th November clearly states that the only engagement has been with cabinet members and not the key stakeholders discussed in the Budget paperwork. In light of the amount of increase in charges and the changes from free to paid parking, there should have been engagement prior to this report with ward councillors, bodies representing businesses and other organisations that would be affected by the changes as well as with residents of Kirklees. From Budget Council to November there should have been sufficient time for this to take place.
Budget Book based on BUB v16.pdf (kirklees.gov.uk)
There are no finance implications for the council given in the report. Therefore, it is not apparent what the costs are for the changes proposed or what revenue will be brought into the council and whether any proposed income levels to the council are achievable.
In the Parking Income and Expenditure statements that are published on the Council’s website the income from off-street and on-street parking in 21/22 totalled: 22/23 21/22
On Street Parking Income 976,000 930,000
Off Street Parking Income 1,947,000 1,613,000
2,923,000 2,543,000 This is listed with other income and is offset against expenditure on Parking. In both years there was a capital charge under expenditure which meant in one year there was a deficit of income over expenditure and in another a small surplus. Both these years are down from figures in 2019/20. (It needs to be noted that these figures are labelled as “Not Full Certified Accounts”.) In September parking charges were listed in a cabinet report under income generation in these difficult times for the Council and this November cabinet report highlights that charges have not increased for some considerable time. However, there is no mention of a review, as mentioned in the budget papers, and whether there are any other factors involved in the narrowing gap between income and expenditure on existing car parking charges.
Since my conversation with officers the report has been changed to give more detail on the powers of the local authority on setting charges. As in the amended report, it states that the council “must keep a separate account of their income and expenditure in respect of designated parking places including the parking charges and this aids decision making on revising charges.” Therefore, it is reasonable to expect that information on the Council’s finances would have been present in the report. v7 FINAL Cabinet Report Parking Tariffs.pdf (kirklees.gov.uk) Open data sets | Kirklees Council
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.