(1) That with effect from the 2015/16 municipal year, it be a requirement that the Vice-Chairman of the Standards Committee be from a different group from the Chairman and that Council be requested to amend the Constitution accordingly. (2) That with effect from the 2015/16 municipal year, where a complaint was received about the conduct of a City Councillor who was of the same group as the Chairman of the Committee, the Monitoring Officer consult with the Vice-Chairman rather than the Chairman at all relevant stages of the complaints procedure, and that the Committee’s arrangements be amended accordingly.
Word for word from the decision Lancaster published for this meeting.Source: committeeadmin.lancaster.gov.uk
To enable the Committee to review its arrangements for dealing with complaints.
This report is public
Recommendations
(1) That with effect from the next municipal year, it be a requirement that the Vice-Chairman of the Committee be from a different group from the Chairman, and that Council be requested to amend the Constitution accordingly. (2) That with effect from the next municipal year, where a complaint is received about the conduct of a city councillor who is of the same group as the Chairman of the Committee, the Monitoring Officer consult with the Vice-Chairman rather than the Chairman at all relevant stages of the complaints procedure, and that the Committee’s arrangements be amended accordingly.
1.0Introduction
1.1Members may recall that under the previous standards regime prior to the Localism Act 2011, complaints were assessed initially by an ad hoc sub- committee of three, chaired by an independent member of the Committee and that the protocol was that such a sub-committee would not include an elected member of the same group as the member complained of or the complainant. 1.2 When the procedures changed following the implementation of the Localism Act 2011, the new arrangements approved by the Committee provided for decisions at a number of stages of the procedure to be taken by the Monitoring Officer in consultation with the Chairman, the Independent Person and the Chief Executive. There has always been an understanding that if the Chairman has a conflict of interest, consultation will be with the Vice- Chairman rather than the Chairman. 1.3 This has worked well, because, fortuitously, since 2012, the Committee has in each year appointed a Vice-Chairman who has not been of the same group as the Chairman. However, there is no guarantee that this will always be the case. 2.0 Proposal Details
2.1In order to ensure the continuation of the current practice of consulting with the Vice-Chairman when the Chairman may be perceived to have a conflict of interest, it is recommended that Council be requested to amend the Constitution to require that with effect from the next municipal year the Vice- Chairman of the Standards Committee be from a different group from the Chairman.
2.2The greatest likelihood of a perception of a conflict of interest arises where the Chairman is a member of the same group as a member complained of. It is recommended therefore that the Committee’s arrangements for dealing with complaints be amended to provide that, in those circumstances, the Monitoring Officer will consult with the Vice-Chairman rather than the Chairman at all relevant stages of the complaints procedure.
2.3Where a complaint is made by a city councillor about another city councillor, there could also be a perception of a conflict of interest where the Chairman (or Vice–Chairman) is consulted and is of the same group as the complainant. It is impossible to cover all the possible scenarios, but it is anticipated that in such circumstances the Monitoring Officer would discuss with both the Chairman and the Vice-Chairman any possible perceived conflicts of interest so that the procedure is as transparent as possible.
4.0Options and Options Analysis (including risk assessment)
4.1The Monitoring Officer has reviewed the arrangements for dealing with complaints, and is proposing the changes set out in this report in order to formalise the good practice that has developed since the implementation of the new standards regime. There is no legal requirement to make the changes, but it is felt that to do so would be helpful for providing a transparent process for dealing with future complaints.
CONCLUSION OF IMPACT ASSESSMENT (including Health & Safety, Equality & Diversity, Human Rights, Community Safety, Sustainability and Rural Proofing)
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Exclusion of the Press and PublicThat, in accordance with Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the press and public be excluded from the ...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.