AI summaryLancaster City Council Cabinet adopts a Pre-Decision Scrutiny Protocol to formalise how scrutiny feeds into cabinet decisions, with a review after one year.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedPre-Decision Scrutiny Protocol approved by Cabinet
MoneyNoneNo direct financial implications
What happens nextReview after a yearOverview and Scrutiny Committee to assess effectiveness
Who it affectsCabinet and Scrutiny working arrangementsAims to improve joint working across the district
What was decided
Cabinet adopted the Pre-Decision Scrutiny Protocol appended to the report, with 8 members in favour and 1 against. Report P4
The Overview and Scrutiny Committee will be asked to consider the effectiveness of the adoption after a year.
Why
There is no legal requirement for a scrutiny protocol, but it is considered best practice in the MHCLG Overview and Scrutiny Statutory Guidance published in April 2024. Report P24
The protocol is intended to help Cabinet and Scrutiny work together more effectively for the good of the district, mirroring arrangements in other authorities. Report 1.1
A working group was set up in January 2026 to recommend the draft after a previous version was withdrawn from the Cabinet agenda to allow further discussion. Report 1.2, 1.3, 2.1
What happens next
The Chief Executive is responsible for effecting the decision.
The Overview and Scrutiny Committee will review the effectiveness of the protocol after one year of operation.
Options considered
Chosen: Adopt the Pre-Decision Scrutiny Protocol. Enables effective scrutiny, follows Statutory Guidance and addresses the Peer Review, with no identified disadvantages or risks. Report P13, P14
Rejected: Do not adopt the Pre-Decision Scrutiny Protocol. Would hamper effective scrutiny and provide no definitive framework, and would not follow the Statutory Guidance. Report P13
Implications
Legal: No legal requirement to have a scrutiny protocol, but adopting one aligns with MHCLG Statutory Guidance of April 2024. The Overview and Scrutiny Committee has overall responsibility for scrutiny under the Local Government Act 2000. Report P24
Financial: No direct financial implications arising from the report; Section 151 Officer has no further comments. Report P21, P22, P23
Other: No direct implications for policy framework, diversity, human rights, community safety or sustainability. Report P18, P20
21st January 2026: Overview and Scrutiny Committee met with the Leader and agreed to set up a Working Group on the draft protocol. Report 1.2, 1.3
24th February 2026: Working Group met and considered a draft Protocol. Report 2.1
1st April 2026: Overview and Scrutiny Committee considered the draft Protocol and recommended it to Cabinet for adoption. Report 2.2
9th June 2026: Cabinet adopted the Pre-Decision Scrutiny Protocol.
Plain English for the jargon
Pre-Decision Scrutiny Protocol: A formal arrangement allowing the Overview and Scrutiny Committee to feed into Cabinet decisions before they are taken.
MHCLG: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, the UK government department that issued the Statutory Guidance on Overview and Scrutiny in April 2024.
Section 151 Officer: The local authority officer with statutory responsibility for the proper administration of the council's financial affairs.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item5
Resolved
(8 Members (Councillors Bannon, Bottoms, Hart, Caroline Jackson, Peter Jackson, Riches, Stubbins & Tyldesley) voted in favour, and 1 Member (Councillor Hamilton-Cox) voted against). That the Pre-decision Scrutiny Protocol be adopted and the Overview & Scrutiny Committee be asked to consider the effectiveness of the adoption after a year. Officer responsible for effecting the decision: Chief Executive Reasons for making the decision: Whilst there is no legal requirement for the Council to have a Scrutiny Protocol it is considered best practice in the ‘Overview and Scrutiny: Statutory Guidance for Councils and Combined Authorities (MHCLG)’ document published in April 2024. Such arrangements are in place in other authorities with the aim of assisting both Cabinet and Scrutiny to work together more effectively for the good of the district.
Word for word from the decision Lancaster published for this meeting.Source: committeeadmin.lancaster.gov.uk
To consider a report of Overview and Scrutiny Committee on the introduction of a Pre-Decision Scrutiny Protocol.
This report is public.
RECOMMENDATIONS OF OVERVIEW AND SCRUTINY COMMITTEE
Cabinet is requested to adopt a Pre-Decision Scrutiny Protocol appended to this report.
1. Introduction
1.1The Overview and Scrutiny Committee has previously asked to consider the introduction of a Pre-Decision Scrutiny Protocol. Such arrangements are in place in other authorities with the aim of assisting both Cabinet and Scrutiny to work together more effectively for the good of the district.
1.2At its meeting, held on 21st January 2026 (Minute 50 refers), the Overview and Scrutiny Committee welcomed the Leader of the Council, Councillor Caroline Jackson to the meeting. The Committee was reminded that consideration of the draft Pre-Decision Scrutiny Protocol had been withdrawn from the Cabinet agenda to allow further discussions to take place between Scrutiny and Cabinet Members. The Leader explained to the Committee the difficulties of scheduling Scrutiny’s input into reports in the timescales that were in place.
1.3The Group discussed the way forward and agreed to set up a Working Group to make recommendations on the draft Protocol.
2. Draft Protocol
2.1The Working Group met on 24th February 2026 and considered a draft Protocol.
2.2The Overview and Scrutiny Committee considered the draft Protocol at its meeting on 1st April 2026 and recommended the Protocol to Cabinet for adoption.
2.3A Protocol is now attached for Cabinet to adopt. 3.0 Options and Options Analysis (including Risk Assessment)
Option 1: To adopt the Pre- Option 2: Not to adopt the Pre- Decision Scrutiny Protocol Decision Scrutiny Protocol Advantages To enable effective scrutiny No benefits. This would not to be undertaken to improve follow the Statutory Guidance on the Scrutiny function as Scrutiny. highlighted in the Peer Review and the Statutory Guidance for Overview and Scrutiny. Disadvantages There are no disadvantages. To hamper effective scrutiny with no definitive framework for scrutiny to work within. Risks None. None.
The preferred option is Option 1 – to adopt the Pre-decision Scrutiny Protocol.
4.0Conclusion
4.1Cabinet is requested to adopt the Pre-Decision Scrutiny Protocol appended to this report.
RELATIONSHIP TO POLICY FRAMEWORK
There are no direct implications as a result of this report.
CONCLUSION OF IMPACT ASSESSMENT (including Diversity, Human Rights, Community Safety, Sustainability etc)
There are no direct implications as a result of this report.
Financial implications
There are no financial implications as a direct result of this report.
SECTION 151 OFFICER’S COMMENTS
The Section 151 Officer has been consulted and has no further comments.
Legal implications
The Overview and Scrutiny Committee has overall responsibility for the performance of all Overview and Scrutiny functions (under the Local Government Act 2000) on behalf of the Council and ensuring its effectiveness. There is no legal requirement for the Council to have a Scrutiny Protocol although it is considered best practice in the ‘Overview and Scrutiny: Statutory Guidance for Councils and Combined Authorities (MHCLG)’ document published in April 2024.
MONITORING OFFICER’S COMMENTS
The Monitoring Officer has been consulted and has no further comments. BACKGROUND PAPERS Contact Officer: Stephen Metcalfe, Principal Democratic Support DLUHC Overview and Scrutiny: statutory Officer. guidance for councils, combined authorities and Telephone: 01524 582000 combined county authorities – 22.04.24. To view E-mail: [email protected] please click here
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Exclusion of the Press and PublicResolved unanimously: That in accordance with Section 100 A( 4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the press and publi...
Projects and Performance: Q4 2025-26That the report be noted. Reasons for making the decision: Monitoring of strategic projects and key performance indic...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.