RESOLVED that the Head of Law be authorised to pursue judicial review proceedings in relation to: (i) the recommendations of Matthew Kershaw, TSA of SLHT dated 8 January 2013; (ii) the decision of the Secretary of State for Health dated 31 January 2013; in so far as both relate to Lewisham Hospital if, following receipt of any response to the pre-action protocol letters sent to both on 7 February, she is of the opinion that the Council has a reasonable prospect of success in such proceedings. (iii) the setting up of a Legal Challenge Fund be endorsed and that in the event any monies received in that Fund are not required for legal costs, they be donated to Children First Lewisham.
Word for word from the decision Lewisham published for this meeting.Source: councilmeetings.lewisham.gov.uk
This report sets out the decision of the Secretary of State for Health in relation to Lewisham Hospital, following the recommendations of the Trust Special Administrator (“TSA”) to the South London Healthcare Trust (SLHT). It seeks authority, subject to the responses received from the Secretary of State and the TSA to the Council’s pre-action protocol letters, to issue judicial review proceedings to ask the court to quash the recommendations of the TSA dated 8 January 2013 and the decision of the Secretary of State dated 31 January 2013 in so far as they relate to Lewisham Hospital.
2. Purpose
To ask the Mayor’s approval to pursue legal proceedings to overturn the recommendations of the TSA on 8 January 2013 and the decision of the Secretary of State for Health made on 31 January 2013 in so far as they relate to Lewisham Hospital.
Recommendations
To authorise the Head of Law to pursue judicial review proceedings in relation to:
(i) the recommendations of Matthew Kershaw, TSA of SLHT dated 8 January 2013;
(ii) the decision of the Secretary of State for Health dated 31 January 2013;
in so far as both relate to Lewisham Hospital if, following receipt of any response to the pre-action protocol letters sent to both on 7 February, she is of the opinion that the Council has a reasonable prospect of success in such proceedings.
(iii) to note and endorse the setting up of a Legal Challenge Fund as set out in paragraph 4.13 of this report and to agree that in the event any monies received in that Fund are not required for legal costs, they be donated to Children First Lewisham. 4 Background
4.1SLHT consists of 3 hospitals:
• Queen Mary’s Hospital, Sidcup • Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Woolwich • Princess Royal University Hospital, Bromley
The Trust is in severe financial difficulty and according to the TSA is losing in excess of £1m per week, part of which losses are related, according to the TSA, to the excessive costs of Private Finance Initiative contract payments being made by the Trust.
4.2By statutory instrument (SI 2012 No 1806) Matthew Kershaw was appointed as TSA to SLHT with effect from 16 July this year. The appointment of a TSA to SLHT was the first time a TSA has ever been appointed. Matthew Kershaw was appointed under Chapter 5A Part 2 NHS Act 2006 (as amended in 2009). This regime is known as the ‘Unsustainable Provider Regime’ (U.P.R.), and a TSA is appointed to carry out those functions bestowed upon him/her by the statutory framework.
4.3The powers of a TSA are clearly defined in law. They are to exercise the functions of the chairman and directors of the trust to which he/she is appointed. He/she is required within a timescale set out in statutory instrument to prepare and publish a draft report stating the action which he/she recommends that the Secretary of State should take in relation to the trust to which he is appointed.
4.4Before making recommendations to the Secretary of State, the TSA is required to follow a tight statutory timetable and framework for consultation. Following that procedure, the TSA made his recommendations to the Secretary of State on 8 January 2013. It was made clear by the TSA throughout the consultation process and in his report addressed to the Secretary of State that he did not consider his remit limited to the trust to which he was appointed. He rather purported also to address the “financial and clinical state of the whole health economy in South East London”. The Council disputed the legal power of the TSA to make any recommendation in relation to Lewisham Hospital and set out its legal and other concerns to the TSA in December 2012. A copy of the Council’s submission to the TSA now appears at Appendix 1.
4.5Notwithstanding the Council’s representations, the recommendations of the TSA to the Secretary of State on 8 January 2013 appear at pages 47 et seq. of his report and include the following:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Changes to Committee MembershipIt was MOVED by Councillor Roberts and SECONDED by Councillor Persian and it was RESOLVED to approve: (i) the appoint...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.