Sustainable Development Select Committee decided this item on Wednesday 8 March 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
that the Committee refer its views to Mayor and Cabinet, as follows- · The Committee notes the Council's decision in February 2017 to oppose the closure of New Cross crown post office and for the same reasons outlined in that decision the Committee opposes the closure of Sydenham crown post office. The Committee believes the loss of skilled jobs, skilled staff and the economic impact on the high street would be a serious blow to the local economy and to consumers. · The Committee asks that the Mayor write to the government minister responsible, and the Chief Executive of the Post Office, about the potential loss of Sydenham crown post office. · The Committee requests that Council officers be tasked with investigating how lease arrangements might be negotiated to retain the crown post office in Sydenham for the benefit of the local community. · The Chair of Committee intends to write to Jim Dowd about the potential closure Sydenham crown post office and asks that the Mayor do the same. · The Committee recommends that the Council should request further information from the Post Office about its strategy to preserve the full range of post office services for Lewisham residents.
Word for word from the decision Lewisham published for this meeting.Source: councilmeetings.lewisham.gov.uk
Report to Sustainable Development Select Committee
Briefing from the CWU – Post Office closure and franchising programme Overview
Over the past four years the Post Office has been implementing a series of significant cost- cutting measures with closures, franchising (privatisation), job losses and cuts to staff terms and conditions.
The latest element of this was the announcement on 10th January 2017 that it intends to close and franchise a further 37 of its flagship Crown post office branches (with around 300 staff) and cut a further 127 Financial Specialist (customer advisor) roles across its network.
These cuts follow announcements from the Post Office for the closure and franchise of 62 Crown offices in 2016, 500 job losses from its cash handling section (which stores and transports cash for post offices and other retailers) and the closure of its defined benefit pension scheme.
The latest announcements on 10th January have been made despite the fact that the government has not responded to its consultation on the future of the Post Office, which closed on 21st December. The CWU delivered 75,000 postcards signed by members of the public in response to this to BEIS, which called for an end to the closure and franchising programme – these views have been ignored.
The closure and franchising programme means worse services for customers across a range of measures, the loss of good jobs which are typically replaced by minimum wage roles, the loss of a community asset and we believe it is part of a strategy of managed decline for the future of the Post Office network.
Crown Post Office closure and franchising programme
The Post Office has a network of around 11,800 outlets – 286 of these are ‘Crown’ branches which are directly owned and run by the Post Office and with directly employed staff. These tend to be the largest flagship offices in prominent high-street locations. While representing a small share of the overall network, they have historically brought in between 10-20% of the Post Office’s overall revenue.
The closure and franchise programme involves the Post Office closing down the Crown office and finding another retailer to install a post office counter somewhere in its shop – typically this has been in the back of a WHSmiths. While the Post Office claims this means no downgrade in service, certain products like identity services are only provided in Crowns; independent research has shown Crowns perform better than franchised branches on a range of measures; disabled access in particular tends to reduce; and it means the loss of experienced trained staff, being replaced by part-time minimum wage roles.
Key issues arising from the changes:
1. Impact on customers
The only independent research that has been carried out in the past five years found that the Crown office closure and franchising programme (seeing 70 offices closed and moved into WHSmiths) has been bad for customers.1 This ranked the WHSmith franchises worse than Crowns for:
1 Are You Being Served? (November 2012) – the research was conducted in 2011. Consumer Focus (subsequently Consumer Futures and now part of Citizens Advice) had statutory responsibility for monitoring
1 Queue times Service times (transactions take longer) Customer service/advice on the appropriate products Disabled access The number of counter positions (and counter positions which are staffed).
Despite this, of the twenty eight branches for which a franchise partner was announced last year, twenty seven have been with WHSmith.
The other impacts on customers that we would highlight are:
(i) the loss of experienced staff – this not only affects quality of service, but means a loss of what people see as a community asset when the Crown closes and relationships between staff and customers are lost; and
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Follow Sustainable Development Select Committee at Lewisham and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.