Sustainable Development Select Committee agreed this item on Thursday 22 March 2018. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved : the Committee agreed to share its views with Mayor and Cabinet as follows – · The Committee welcomes the newly developed vision for rail, however it would like to see lobbying for the extension of the Bakerloo line to Hayes become a priority for the Council. · The Committee recommends that considerations about accessibility be broadened to include a wider range of issues, not just step free access (to include braille signage and support for people with cognitive impairments). The Committee also recommends that support for the provision of accessible public toilets at stations be included in the vision for rail. · The Committee welcomes the ambition to improve Lewisham’s stations but it recommends that officers should be tasked with undertaking a station by station analysis of options for land that could be safeguarded for future public transport, cycling and pedestrian accessibility. · The Committee recommends that the proposal for the relocation of Lower Sydenham station be included in the vision. · The Committee supports the possible future transfer of services from rail operators to TfL and recommends that this be included in the vision for rail. · The Committee recommends that further consideration be given to the impact of rail changes on different socio-economic groups in the borough, with consideration given to affordable options for Lewisham residents to access their places of work. · The Committee believes that reference should be made in the vision to the night time economy in the borough, including both the benefits to the economy and the importance of cultural activities. · The Committee would welcome further information about timelines and potential dates for action and implementation to be included in the vision. · It was also agreed that, the Committee would ask the transport liaison committee to consider the recent incident at Lewisham station during poor weather during which passengers were forced to walk on the rail tracks.
Word for word from the decision Lewisham published for this meeting.Source: councilmeetings.lewisham.gov.uk
Report to Sustainable Development Select Committee
A Vision for Rail Document Feedback from A Cinderella Line
Page 3: “Other than the London termini, busy interchange stations are Canary Wharf, Canada Water and Blackfriars.”
Blackfriars is a station included in London Terminals, so to be factually accurate this should either list all prominent London Terminal stations or remove Blackfriars from the list.
Page 4:
“Frequent services call at the main interchanges at New Cross Gate, Lewisham, Grove Park, Catford and Hither Green.”
Catford station itself is not an interchange, however you can interchange for Catford Bridge station. In addition to this, this reads as if Catford has the same frequency as Lewisham which (sadly for the Cinderella Line) is not true!
Suggest this is reworded to take these points into account.
“East-west services are limited to infrequent services across the north of the Borough calling at Nunhead, Lewisham and Blackheath.”
Nunhead is not in our borough! Suggest this is changed to say Crofton Park instead.
Page 10:
“Demand on the Network in Future”
We know already that stations on the Catford Loop line are significantly under- counted as there are no ticket barriers along the route so any oyster card data does not give an accurate reflection of passenger volumes, and on top of this, the Office of Rail and Road have changed their methodology for counting passenger numbers so according to our official figures, our passenger volumes have gone down despite us knowing that this is absolutely not true on the Catford Loop.
We are also aware that there is supressed demand on our routes – many passengers simply don’t use our services on the Catford Loop due to the current passenger volumes, so end up walking to Ladywell, Honor Oak or Lewisham to use other services instead.
I would be keen to see the methodology used behind these future predictions, as even with the new timetables for May, the capacity would only allow for a further two trains an hour (giving a total of six) due to current pathing restrictions for other services.
In addition to this, we would be keen to understand why the map between Bellingham and Crofton Park is shown to have fewer passengers for the route just for that particular stretch of the route?
Could we have an explanation for this please?
Page 12:
“Goals of Lewisham’s Rail Vision”
We feel strongly, that in the goals there should be a point to ensure that housing development/population growth in the borough is directly linked. To say “sufficient rail capacity” is probably not strong enough to enforce that any agreed housing development/growth should only be approved if there is sufficient rail capacity either currently available or signed off in a plan.
We have seen a huge increase in rail passengers from Catford as a result of the Catford Green development, and yet there was no extra provision in rail services to account for this.
It is the campaigns view that these two issues should be married together and housing development should only be agreed if there is sufficient rail infrastructure to support it.
“To enhance the quality of stations and provide step-free access at all station in the Borough.”
We would like to see this goal expanded to tackle not just step free access but making journeys accessible overall. Step free access only forms part of an accessible experience for passengers. Improving the gap between the train and platform is key to an accessible service for all, as well as appropriate signage (both visual and physical markers) and station staffing. What happens at the other end of the journey is equally important. This is why, as a campaign, we have been arguing for more trains through the core rather than terminating at Blackfriars where the interchange going north can be very long and involve many stairs / lifts; not great if you have mobility problems.
Page 15:
“New Southeastern Franchise”
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Follow Sustainable Development Select Committee at Lewisham and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.