AI summaryLewisham Council approved changes to committee memberships, including replacing three members with Councillor Esther Lie on scrutiny, health and licensing committees, and swapping two councillors between planning committees.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedAll six membership changes agreed
MoneyNoneNo financial implications from the changes
What happens nextImmediateChanges take effect from this Council decision
Who it affectsCommittee membershipsPASC, Healthier Communities, Licensing, Planning A and B
What was decided
Councillor Esther Lie replaces Councillor Natalie Thomas on the Public Accounts Select Committee. Report P7
Councillor Esther Lie replaces Councillor Maria McKenna on the Healthier Communities Select Committee and on the Licensing Committee. Report P8, P9
Councillor Dall and Councillor Lambert-Morris exchange seats between Planning Committee A and Planning Committee B. Report P11, P12, P13
Why
Councillor Thomas was appointed to the Cabinet and, under the Local Government Act 2000 and the Council's Constitution, executive members cannot sit on overview and scrutiny committees. Report P12, P19, P20
Councillor Esther Lie was elected in the Crofton Park ward by-election on 18 June 2025, and her political group has reviewed its committee appointments. Report P13
Two councillors from Blackheath Ward were on Planning Committee A, which the Constitution does not allow, so the exchange is needed for compliance. Report P12, P20
What happens next
The new members take up their committee seats with immediate effect following Council approval.
The Licensing Committee change also applies to membership of Licensing Sub-Committee D. Report P10, P15
Options considered
Chosen: Appoint Councillor Esther Lie to the Public Accounts Select Committee. Needed to replace Councillor Thomas, who is no longer eligible as a Cabinet member Report P7, P12
Chosen: Appoint Councillor Esther Lie to the Healthier Communities Select Committee. Proposed by the relevant political group following the by-election Report P8, P13
Chosen: Appoint Councillor Esther Lie to the Licensing Committee (and Sub-Committee D). Proposed by the relevant political group following the by-election Report P9, P10, P13
Chosen: Exchange Planning Committee seats between Councillor Dall and Councillor Lambert-Morris. Two Blackheath Ward councillors sat on Planning Committee A, breaching the Constitution Report P11, P12, P13, P20
Implications
Legal: The PASC change is required to keep the separation between executive and scrutiny functions under the Local Government Act 2000. Report P12, P19, P20
Legal: Committee seat allocations continue to follow political balance rules under the Local Government and Housing Act 1989. Report P19
Equalities: There are no equalities implications arising directly from the report. Report P17
Financial: There are no financial implications arising from the recommendations. Report P18
Other: The Deputy Monitoring Officer is satisfied the recommendations are consistent with statutory obligations on appointments and political balance. Report P20
Who and where
Councillor Esther Lie (new member of PASC, Healthier Communities Select Committee, Licensing Committee, and Licensing Sub-Committee D) Report P7, P8, P9, P10
Councillor Natalie Thomas (removed from PASC after Cabinet appointment) Report P7, P12
Councillor Maria McKenna (removed from Healthier Communities Select Committee and Licensing Committee) Report P8, P9
Councillor Dall (moved from Planning Committee A to Planning Committee B) Report P11, P12, P13
Councillor Lambert-Morris (moved from Planning Committee B to Planning Committee A) Report P11, P12, P13
Timeline
20 May 2025: Committee memberships for 2025/26 set at the Annual General Meeting Report P12
18 June 2025: By-election held in Crofton Park ward; Councillor Esther Lie elected Report P13
15 July 2026: Report on changes to committee membership dated Report P2
22 July 2026: Council approves the membership changes Report P2
Plain English for the jargon
PASC: Public Accounts Select Committee, one of the council's overview and scrutiny committees
Overview and scrutiny committee: A council committee that reviews the work of the executive (Cabinet), separate from the decision-making body
Planning Committee A and B: Two planning committees that determine planning applications, each made up of up to ten members
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item9
Resolved
It was MOVED by Councillor Wills, SECONDED by Councillor Persian and it was RESOLVED to approve: (i) the removal of Councillor Natalie Thomas from the Public Accounts Select Committee (PASC) and the appointment of Councillor Esther Lie in her place; (ii) the removal of Councillor Maria McKenna from the Healthier Communities Select Committee and the appointment of Councillor Esther Lie in her place; (iii) the removal of Councillor Maria McKenna from the Licensing Committee and the appointment of Councillor Esther Lie in her place; (iv) that the change to Licensing Committee membership also apply to membership of Licensing Sub-Committee D; (v) the appointment of Councillor Dall to Planning Committee B in place of Councillor Lambert-Morris; and (vi) the appointment of Councillor Lambert-Morris to Planning Committee A in place of Councillor Dall.
Word for word from the decision Lewisham published for this meeting.Source: councilmeetings.lewisham.gov.uk
Changes to Committee Membership Date: 15 July 2026
Key decision: No.
Class: Part 1
Contributors: Emma Campbell Smith, Head of Governance, Scrutiny and Committee Services
Outline and recommendations Council is recommended to:
1. Remove Councillor Natalie Thomas from the Public Accounts Select Committee (PASC) and appoint Councillor Esther Lie in her place.
2. Remove Councillor Maria McKenna from the Healthier Communities Select Committee and appoint Councillor Esther Lie in her place.
3. Remove Councillor Maria McKenna from the Licensing Committee and appoint Councillor Esther Lie in her place.
4. Note that the change to Licensing Committee membership will also apply to membership of Licensing Sub-Committee D.
5. Approve the exchange of memberships between the Planning Committees so that:
o Councillor Dall is appointed to Planning Committee B in place of Councillor Lambert-Morris; and
o Councillor Lambert-Morris is appointed to Planning Committee A in place of Councillor Dall. 1. Background 1.1. Committee memberships for the 2025/26 municipal year were agreed by Council at its Annual General Meeting on 20 May 2025. 1.2. At the Annual General Meeting, Councillor Natalie Thomas was appointed to the Cabinet. Under the Council's Constitution, members of the Executive may not serve on overview and scrutiny committees. This reflects the statutory separation between executive decision-making and scrutiny functions established by the Local Government Act 2000. Section 9FA(3) of the Act provides that an overview and scrutiny committee may not include members of the authority's executive. Consequently, Councillor Thomas is not eligible to serve on the Public Accounts Select Committee and a replacement appointment is required. 1.3. A by-election was held in Crofton Park ward on 18 June 2025 at which Councillor Esther Lie was elected to the Council. The relevant political group has subsequently reviewed its committee appointments and has proposed a number of amendments to committee memberships. 1.4. At the Annual General Meeting, Councillor Dall was appointed to Planning Committee A. However, another councillor representing Blackheath Ward was also appointed to Planning Committee A. The Council's Constitution provides for Planning Committees A and B to comprise up to ten members and further provides that no more than one member from the same ward may serve on the same Planning Committee. To ensure compliance with the Constitution, it is proposed that Councillor Dall and Councillor Lambert-Morris exchange places on Planning Committees A and B.
2. Recommendations 2.1. Council is recommended to: 2.1.1. Remove Councillor Natalie Thomas from the Public Accounts Select Committee (PASC) and appoint Councillor Esther Lie in her place. 2.1.2. Remove Councillor Maria McKenna from the Healthier Communities Select Committee and appoint Councillor Esther Lie in her place. 2.1.3. Remove Councillor Maria McKenna from the Licensing Committee and appoint Councillor Esther Lie in her place.
Is this report easy to understand? Please give us feedback so we can improve. Go to https://lewisham.gov.uk/contact-us/send-us-feedback-on-our-reports 2.1.4. Note that the change to Licensing Committee membership will also apply to membership of Licensing Sub-Committee D. 2.1.5. Approve the exchange of memberships between the Planning Committees so that: • Councillor Dall is appointed to Planning Committee B in place of Councillor Lambert-Morris; and • Councillor Lambert-Morris is appointed to Planning Committee A in place of Councillor Dall.
3. Policy Context 3.1. This report aligns with the ambitions and priorities of the administration elected in May 2026, as reflected within the Council’s emerging corporate delivery plan, including: • Safe, affordable homes • Cleaner streets and greener neighbourhoods • An economy of care • Healthier, happier communities • Justice, sanctuary and care
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Changes to Committee MembershipIt was MOVED by Councillor Roberts and SECONDED by Councillor Persian and it was RESOLVED to approve: (i) the appoint...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.