Resolved
Decision 1. That the proposed Health & Environment Private Sector Housing Enforcement Policy (Policy 2) be adopted. 2. That the Association of Chief Environmental Health Officers (ACEHO) Civil Penalty Notice Policy at Appendix A of the officer’s report be adopted. 3. That the amendments to the Health & Environment Enforcement Policy (Policy 1) be adopted. Alternative Options Considered and Rejected. The most significant alternative option was to not develop and adopt the policy. This would have two impacts – • Be in breach of the Council’s statutory duties regarding the enforcement approach required for the Renters’ Rights Act. • The Council would not be able to apply the appropriate sanctions to those that contravene the law. • Penalty charge notices and civil penalties would not be fully adopted. Reasons for the Decision The Renters’ Rights Act introduced a significantly expanded civil penalty framework and placed new duties on the Council to enforce a broader range of landlord obligations. These included new compliance requirements, enhanced penalties for repeat or serious non-compliance, and clearer expectations that enforcement activity was fair, consistent, and proportionate. To meet these requirements, the Council must ensure its relevant policies were fully aligned with the new legislative framework. The Council’s existing Health & Environment Enforcement Policy was developed prior to the introduction of the Renters’ Rights Act and did not reflect the suite of new offences or amendments to civil penalties or evidential thresholds. Without a newly proposed Private Sector Housing enforcement policy there was a risk of inconsistent enforcement, legal challenge to decisions and reduced ability to demonstrate compliance with statutory guidance and best practice. Introducing the new enforcement policy and updating the existing enforcement policy was essential to ensure the Council could meet its statutory obligations. The Council’s current Health & Environment Enforcement Policy was developed within a regulatory framework where local authorities retained broad discretion on private sector housing enforcement to resolve non-compliance through informal or advisory action, reflecting the principles of the Regulators’ Code. That approach assumed enforcement was generally discretionary and that informal resolution would often be appropriate as a first response. The Renters’ Rights Act represented a fundamental shift from that position. Section 107 placed a statutory duty on local housing authorities to enforce landlord legislation, altering the balance between informal action and formal enforcement. Where there were breaches of the defined ‘landlord legislation’ the Council must now actively consider enforcement action to meet this duty, rather than defaulting to advice or informal resolution in the first instance. As a result, the Regulators’ Code could no longer be relied upon to justify informal action as the starting point for compliance under the Renters’ Rights Act. A voluntary group, Association of Chief Environmental Health Officers (ACEHO) had developed a suite of national model policies, including a ... view the full minutes text for item 15.